Contribution
My Lords, I, too, will miss the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, in the Chamber. I thank him for his commitment and long service to local government; it has been a pleasure to work with him. I declare an interest as a vice-president of the Local Government Association.
Amid local government reorganisation and the ever-changing decisions and guidance issued by Government Ministers, local authorities across England continue to operate in a state of flux, uncertainty and instability. My noble friend Lord Redwood will be pleased to hear a positive note: it should be recognised that this year’s local elections saw one of the highest turnouts in recent years, with the Electoral Commission confirming a turnout of 45.2% for county council elections and 41.2% for metropolitan, London borough, unitary and district elections.
In the context of local government reorganisation, and on the matter of democratic accountability, the Government need to provide urgent clarity to the more than 20 local authorities that currently operate under a committee-based model. As the Minister will no doubt be aware, the English devolution Act requires local authorities to move to a leader and executive model by June 2027. However, where structural change orders exist in those areas, this deadline can be extended by the Secretary of State to June 2028. Given the uncertainty caused by the Government’s decision to review LGR, can the Minister provide some clarity in her contribution for the approximately 20 local authorities in this situation?
The thrust of my contribution this afternoon will be about ensuring that the process for agreeing structural change orders—in particular, interim warding arrangements—is fair, legal and democratic. To begin with, the Government should provide the legal advice given by officials to the former Secretary of State, Steve Reed MP, as part of his decision-making process when deciding on proposed new local authority boundaries before the Summer Recess. It is important that the sector fully understands the facts that were presented to the former Secretary of State before he made his final decision.
On the subject of interim warding arrangements, we need a far more democratic and fair process to ensure that new warding boundaries remain within tolerance, comply with the principles set out by the Local Government Boundary Commission and are not used by political parties to create questionable boundaries that favour certain groups. As noble friends may be aware, interim warding arrangements for shadow authorities, which are confirmed through the structural change order, must be submitted in advance by the constituent local authorities before being approved by the Government. To be clear, the Local Government Boundary Commission will therefore have no formal role in creating interim warding arrangements.
This is a far cry from the process followed by the previous Conservative Government, where new unitary authorities such as Buckinghamshire had interim warding arrangements based on existing county council boundaries. These boundaries would have been created through a fair process, overseen by the Local Government Boundary Commission. Over recent months we have seen highly questionable submissions, which some may argue are incompatible with the warding principles set out by the Local Government Boundary Commission.
Allow me to provide one example: the City of Lincoln Council submitted its option D proposals, which meant that areas of the city with higher levels of deprivation, according to the Office for National Statistics data, would receive more representation than residents living in more rural parts of the proposed unitary authority. Specifically, under the proposed 65-member model, a resident of Minster ward would be represented by one councillor for every 1,849 electors. By contrast, a resident of Witham Saint Hughs would have one councillor representing 4,354 electors.
My point, and what I hope will be understood as the central thrust of my contribution to this debate, is that I fear that local government reorganisation is providing an excuse for some not to follow the established norms and processes that we have followed for decades when bringing local authority wards together. This undermines the established democratic principles that have been set in stone for decades. I hope that the House will give serious consideration to this issue as local government reorganisation advances.