L

Lord Pack (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, it is a delight and privilege to follow my noble friend Lord McCobb’s eloquent maiden speech—the first of what I am sure will be many thoughtful contributions to our House and certainly the first of many times that we will hear him talking up the wonders of Hull. Those who know us both will perhaps not be surprised that his first email to me many years ago, after starting work for our party, was to seek some very detailed electoral statistics that he thought I might have; but that interest in using evidence and rigorously scrutinising assumptions will, I am sure, be of great benefit to this House in our scrutiny work. Although the noble Lord is perhaps best known to many for his formidable campaigning experience, he also, as we have heard, brings considerable historical knowledge and local government experience to our deliberations: years of dealing, on the front line, with the practical realities and consequences of decisions we make here in Parliament. The breadth of that expertise, accumulated in roles that have been very challenging and time-consuming at times, has—as for so many—been possible only due to the support and forbearance of the noble Lord’s wife and son. It was therefore such a pleasure to see them wearing two of the broadest smiles I have ever seen on the day of the noble Lord’s introduction. One of the reasons why our decisions here are so relevant to local government is that so much power has been and continues to be centralised in Westminster. That undermines local democratic accountability and puts people off local participation. When we considered the recent devolution Bill, for example, I particularly highlighted the continued central control over cattle-grids—a small but telling example of just how deep-set that centralising micromanagement culture can be at times. Aficionados of cattle-grid regulation had our hopes raised when the Government’s White Paper promised devolution of these powers; alas, by the time we got to legislation, the centralisers had won out, deciding that not even strategic authority mayors can be trusted with full bovine autonomy. That Bill was my first experience of working with my noble friend Lord Shipley, and I greatly valued the support, advice and mentoring he provided—just one of his many attributes that will be so missed later this year. To give a different example, the explanatory text that councils in England and Wales put out to explain the business rates system is not written by councils; nor is it a shared text produced for convenience by the LGA or a similar body for different councils to use; nor is it even a helpful draft provided by a civil servant in Whitehall. No: it is specifically controlled and legislated for in detail by, once again, that culture of saying, “We cannot really trust councils to do this themselves”. For all the talk, on other topics, that legislative time is such a precious resource that this thing the Government really want to do, sadly, cannot quite be done yet, in this case, that centralising micromanagement culture runs so deep that time has been found in Parliament every other year, on average, for the last quarter of a century, to legislate time and again on how councils are allowed to describe that business rates system. We do not set such requirements for other taxes, people or organisations. It is a reflection of how, at times, Whitehall unfortunately seems to treat local government as an untrustworthy or wayward young child. Then there is the problem of legislative time so often not being found for other local government matters that really need it. I will give the House two examples where good ideas have been proposed, consultations carried out and clear and strong consensus found for action, but then action has not followed. The first example was highlighted by the Ethics and Integrity Commission in its annual letter to the Prime Minister earlier this year. In 2024, there was a consultation and then, in 2025, proposals for a stronger and more accountable standards system for local government—something that the Committee on Standards in Public Life had first called for in 2019, a full seven years ago. Seven years on, we have no legislation and no slot promised in a King’s Speech for future legislation. We have no substantive progress in seven years to secure the benefits that a proper accountable standards system would bring for improving councillor and staff well-being, of public trust in local government, and of more effective local government. Instead, it has just stalled for seven years. There is a similar tale with remote or proxy participation at council meetings. Both this House and the House of Commons, in our own different ways, allow some degree of remote or proxy participation, as we have seen in this debate. It is a sensible way to deal with illness that does not impair the brain but precludes mobility, for example. It is something that was successfully done during Covid and, since then, in different ways by local government in the UK outside England. But in England, that centralising, controlling, micromanagement hand is at work again, banning councils from daring to decide for themselves how they wish to arrange their affairs. I wonder how we would feel in this House if someone in Whitehall was to say that we cannot decide how we will allow remote participation but have to have someone in Whitehall tell us instead. To be fair to the Government, there was an extensive consultation in 2025 on changing the rules and it found overwhelming support for change—not a free-for-all abolishing in-person meetings, but for the sort of sensible changes that we have now long since adopted in this House or in the House of Commons. But was legislative time found to implement the results of that consultation? No, it was not. Was the devolution Bill used as an opportunity to implement the results of that consultation? Once again, no it was not. That is the problem: Whitehall is just too busy to find the time to relax that centralising grip, but that is exactly why it needs to step back and trust local government more. I very much hope, when we hear from the Minister later, that we will hear not just the usual albeit very sincere words about the importance of supporting local government but maybe even a hint of progress on allowing councils to decide for themselves how councillors participate in their business, on putting in place a proper standards regime for local government, and maybe, as Christmas is not that far away now, on finally devolving power over cattle-grids.

More from Lord Pack (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.