Contribution
My Lords, I declare my interest as a councillor in central Bedfordshire. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for his contribution both to this House and to local government, which, as a previous chair of the LGA, I can really appreciate. His introduction illustrated his knowledge about and passion for local government, but I have a curious question for him: how did a Sunderland supporter get to be elected as leader of Newcastle? I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, on his maiden speech and his exposition on Hull. I may have to take that difficult train journey and visit it.
For most people, it is their local council that has the most immediate and visible impact on their daily lives: the pavements they walk on, the roads they drive on, their leisure centres, their waste collection, their parks, and the planning decisions that shape their local communities. Councils also deliver other vital services, in particular adult and children’s social care. That is why local democracy is so important: your local council delivering for you. As a local councillor, I have seen what a difference a good local councillor can make at the personal level. In the grand scheme of things, getting a dropped kerb put in may seem minor, but for someone in a wheelchair, giving them access to their local village centre can be life-changing, as can following up the complaints of a resident to ensure that her frail husband has the care he needs, and, on a bigger scale, influencing planning decisions so that schemes such as community centres meet local needs rather than those prescribed by official guidance.
Yet over decades, we have seen under successive Governments Whitehall treating councils as a delivery arm of central government rather than as a truly independent, democratically elected body with the powers and resources to serve their communities and to be held accountable at the ballot box not by Whitehall diktat. Councils are expected to deliver statutory services, as had been mentioned, including social care, while central government controls much of the funding. For many councils, these services account for around 80% of their costs, yet many of the levers needed to improve outcomes and efficiency are outside their control, being in the NHS and in schools, leaving councils with financial and delivery pressures but without the powers to address them. The consequences fall on the non-statutory services—roads, youth services, parks and other facilities—that communities value and see every day. That is not local democracy.
Unfortunately, we see this situation worsening under this Government—an imposed, top-down reorganisation of local government; a decision-making process that has often appeared opaque—while the stop-start uncertainty has distracted councils from their core responsibilities. The Government cannot say they were not warned. I and many other colleagues in this House kept raising the issue. Just yesterday, a colleague pointed out that until the latest U-turn around 3,500 candidates were needed for next May’s local elections. Now, with unitary councils postponed, parties will need to find thousands more candidates in less than six months. That is no way to treat a vital service for many residents or the many councillors who were told that they were no longer needed but now suddenly are.
Restricting councils’ ability to bring planning applications before committees removes an important opportunity for local people to make their voices heard and seek changes that can make a real difference. That is democracy in practice, yet it is being weakened.
On the move towards mayors, I make no comment on the principle of mayors, but three things matter: boundaries must reflect local identity and service delivery networks, devolved taxes must not become a backdoor means of funding unfunded statutory obligations, and genuine devolution must transfer powers and money from central government, not merely shuffle the responsibilities within the local government arena. We can truly have devolution only if the choices, power and funding are decided at the local level, be it mayoral or council, not dictated centrally with a begging-bowl culture of grants and government removing growth incentives.
Voting systems matter. First past the post is simple and understandable. Voters choose their preferred candidate and the candidate with the most votes wins. Alternative systems may have their advocates, but they weaken that direct relationship between voters and their local councillors. On average, there are around 3,500 voters per councillor. A good councillor will be known by their residents and will have direct relationships. In practice, many people vote for the person rather than the party. A popular councillor will often receive substantially more votes than their colleagues on the back of that personal vote, demonstrating the importance of that personal connection.
In conclusion, local democracy matters, but too much top-down diktat, the imposition of LGR, emasculation of councils’ ability to deliver, and reducing the direct link between the councillor and voter all threaten local democracy. That is why I am very supportive of the move by my honourable friend in the other place, the Shadow Secretary of State, who is proposing a review of what the role of local government is and what it should it be. It is time we looked at that again.