Contribution
My Lords, the Companion to our proceedings nowadays discourages Back-Bench Members from paying tribute to valedictory and maiden speakers and as a Deputy Speaker I feel obliged to follow the rules, albeit somewhat reluctantly, so I will simply thank my noble friend Lord Shipley for everything that he has done for local government over decades and let him know that, to me and to others, he has been an inspiration. Meanwhile, my noble friend Lord McCobb is very welcome; he brings a wealth of experience from which I know we can benefit.
I am proud to be the president of the National Association of Local Councils, representing as it does England’s 10,000 parish and town councils and over 100,000 councillors. If we are genuinely discussing democratic accountability and participation in local government, we have to talk about the level that is closest to the people. Through neighbourhood planning, community leadership and local participation, parish and town councils are already strengthening democratic accountability and civic engagement.
For the Government’s ambitions on democratic renewal, devolution and community empowerment to succeed, parish and town councils must be recognised as essential partners and not as an afterthought. Wherever we end up on local government review, it is likely that decisions will feel more remote to many residents, and that is why town and parish councils are so important. They meet locally, the councillors are more likely to be known by name, and they are not just administrative bodies but are rooted in their communities and provide local leadership. Parish and town councils are already on the ground in communities. There is no need to invent new structures or to come up with some new system. Indeed, as my noble friend Lord Wallace said, we need to encourage the creation of more town and parish councils where they do not currently exist.
There is much discussion these days about democratic participation and about declining trust in institutions, and I think we are all worried about that. However, it would be easy to overlook one of the most successful examples of public participation that we already have. Take, for example, neighbourhood planning. More than 3,500 neighbourhood plans have been made or are under way, led overwhelmingly by parish and town councils. Hundreds of thousands of people have participated and, crucially, local people have not simply been consulted or told; they have helped to shape the future development of their areas. It is interesting that independent analysis shows that, as a result of neighbourhood planning, more houses end up being built than were originally proposed by the local council. That demonstrates the important principle that people are willing to support change but where they have genuine influence over it—not when things are done to them, but when things are done with them.
If we want local government that genuinely reflects the communities that it serves, we need to look at how we remove the barriers that prevent people taking part—the right reverend Prelate covered this area very well. It means finding ways to encourage more young people to get involved, supporting more people from working backgrounds to stand for office and removing barriers for those with caring responsibilities.
Around 100,000 parish councillors volunteer more than 14 million hours every year to their communities. These are unpaid councillors and they have to absorb the personal cost of participation in a way that no other tier of local government has to do. For many, these are relatively modest costs, but for parents, people with other caring responsibilities and those looking after loved ones, these costs can be significant. Unlike councillors at every other level of local government in England and Wales, parish and town councillors are specifically excluded from claiming a dependant carer’s allowance. It cannot be right that a single parent should have to pay for childcare simply to attend a council meeting or that a councillor caring for an elderly or disabled relative should be left out of pocket to serve their communities. Local democracy should not force people to choose between caring and serving.
We need to ensure that local councils—indeed, councils at every level—benefit from the widest possible range of talents, experiences and perspectives. That is also why NALC has long campaigned for the return of remote and hybrid meetings—my noble friend Lord Pack described this very well. We learned during the pandemic that technology can widen participation rather than weakening it. It can help councillors to balance work, family and public service. It can help people with disabilities to participate alongside those of working age and with caring responsibilities. We also know that more members of the public participated remotely than have ever turned up in person. During the passage of recent Bills, the Government have said encouraging things about this, but we never seem to see positive action.
People are more likely to put themselves forward if they believe they will be treated with a certain amount of respect. But research shows that 88% of parish and town councillors report having experienced abuse, intimidation or harassment. This should be a concern for all of us, because local democracy depends on people being willing and able to serve, and there can be no democratic accountability if good people decide it is simply not worth it.
Whatever view one takes about electoral reform, I hope there can be agreement on some broader principles. Democracy is strongest when people feel connected to it, when it is easy to participate, when governance is transparent, when institutions are trusted and, crucially, when decisions are made as close as possible to the people on whom they impact. I have enjoyed this debate. I look forward to continuing it, and once again wish my noble friend Lord Shipley and Margaret all the very best.