L

Lord Evans of Guisborough (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to take part in this interesting and well-informed debate. I add my thanks to the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for bringing the debate to the House and wish him well for his future beyond us. I am sure many more exciting challenges lie ahead. I am a relative newcomer, having been here only for 18 months, but I have listened to some of the speeches made by the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, and he always brings a great deal of expertise and interest to our debates, and he raises questions which are worthy of our interest. In this case, the point he raised was that there are questions to be asked around the effectiveness of devolution. Devolution is too often treated by politicians as a magic wand, rather than as the tool it is. To get good results, it needs to be applied correctly. Back in 2000, I had the great pleasure to be one of the first members of the London Assembly to be elected, and I remember there was a great expectation around devolution to London, and a lot of lobbying in favour of it. Among the people who lobbied for it were the various public bodies that we were going to be in charge of. The Metropolitan Police wanted it, and Transport for London were very keen on devolution. This was principally because they saw they would be able to get a mayor and a layer of politicians who would lobby for more resources for them than they were currently getting from the Government. I recall that they were not so enthusiastic about devolution when it came down to accountability. The police were at first reluctant when they had to appear in front of the Assembly’s policing committee and the Metropolitan Police Authority. “Who are these people,” we had some say, “to be questioning what we do?” They had never had that sort of accountability from the Home Office, which had just given them the money and sent them away to spend it. I remember Transport for London also kicked up a bit of a fuss. One of its directors spoke to me after a meeting: “You know those audit reports that you keep asking to have sight of? You do realise that if we made them public, we would have to write them differently in future, don’t you?” Devolution can therefore shed light in all sorts of places, but sometimes it is not the panacea that people believe it to be. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, on his maiden speech, and I look forward to hearing from him more often. As someone who grew up just up the coast in North Yorkshire, I fully agree with his assessment of Filey and the east coast. It is a wonderful part of the world, and we would treasure the weekends that we spent there. I also agree with his assessment of the railway between Hull and Liverpool. I travel only on the bit between Leeds and Manchester, and that is sufficiently slow. Several months ago, the Minister for Rail offered me a visit to that line, and a trip from one end to the other to see the work that was being done. Unfortunately, like so many things concerned with our railways, that trip has yet to arrive. But when it is finally arranged, perhaps the noble Lord would care to join us. I can see a potential alliance between parties to try to get something done there. My noble friend Lord Redwood made a number of very striking and telling points. Particularly, he referred to the tendency of local government to blame national government for not having enough funds and vice versa. Devolution has led to a bit of that in this country. I do not think anyone would claim that the Scottish National Party is doing a particularly good job of running Scotland—nobody in this Chamber would anyway—yet, quite often, it says it wants more powers and money from government, and it is the Government’s fault. If it is any consolation to the Minister who has to preside over these disagreements, I spent several years in the Middle East attempting to improve decentralisation in Arab countries and the same problems arose with mistrust of central government. The people in the provinces would say, “We are not getting enough money; we want more powers”, and central government would say, “Why would we give you the money and the powers when you don’t make good use of them when you have them?” It is a challenge that everyone everywhere has to face, and I do not necessarily envy the Government in trying to sort that out. My noble friend Lady Eaton lamented the final removal of the committee system in so many local authorities. I went through this process at the London Borough of Waltham Forest. After my first term, the committee process was changed to a leader and cabinet process. Committees were not easy; when we had a housing committee, we had to work through 40 papers in an evening, so it was fairly tough stuff. But we got to see the workings behind the decisions, crucially, before they were made. We got to ask questions if we had read the report. There were questions such as: “Why doesn’t this pie chart add up to 100%?”; “Why is the average bus fare you quote in your press releases less than the cheapest bus ticket that you can buy?”; and “Why are you recommending we close the road to traffic turning left when your own traffic figures demonstrate that over 80% of the traffic is turning right?” I very much fear that, without the committee system, the cabinet member responsible for those things will not ask those questions because they do not have any incentive to ask them. They owe their position to their own party on the council and to their leader on the council, so they will not actually dig into those details. Why are they going to read through 40 reports by themselves? I almost think the opposition does them a favour sometimes. The council at Waltham Forest, despite being very strongly Labour, sent back a number of officers’ recommendations because it was demonstrated that the evidence they were based on was faulty. I do not assume that the process has got any better with time; it has just become invisible. I very much regret the changes that the Government are making.

More from Lord Evans of Guisborough (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.