L

Lord Fuller (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, I would like to place on record my thanks to the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, who has been a worthy sparring partner over the last two and a half years that I have been in your Lordships’ House. It is often the way that, as one door closes, another opens, and the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, appears to be another local government expert—one in, one out. At the Second Reading of the elections Bill last month, we were entertained by the noble Lord, Lord Foulkes, who regaled us with a tale of a Scottish Government election in which he was elected to Holyrood despite not having stood in that election himself. We laughed, but it was not funny. It is just another example of how the simple principle that the person who gets the most votes wins the election is being systematically eroded. In that debate, I enumerated all the different ways you can vote in this United Kingdom. There is first past the post or alternative vote—uniquely for the Scottish Crofting Federation, apparently. We heard about supplementary votes earlier in the debate. There are hybrid lists, closed party lists and changes in the franchise across the devolved nations. Only British citizens can vote in a general election in England, but elsewhere any resident, regardless of nationality, can vote—even 16-year-olds in Scotland, and, of course, there are carve-outs for EU citizens in English local elections. These may be all out or by thirds in either single or multi-member wards. That is not a joke. But we need to guard against the democratic process becoming a joke. The public had their say in the 2011 referendum, when they expressed a clear and decisive preference for first past the post, but some people are not paying attention. Anything that interferes with the simple idea that the person with the most votes wins is just funny business. Party lists cooked up in smoke-filled rooms do not provide a solid mandate for a motivated community champion to serve. Only first past the post delivers the clear outcome at a local scale that people recognise and relate to, so they know who they are getting—perhaps that young mum they know from the school gate, or the chap who referees the youngsters’ football matches on the rec. I agree with the Chancellor, who said: “Our democracy has been built on one person, one vote. The last thing we should do is throw away what works in favour of an unfair, perverse electoral system”— quite. We know what bad looks like. On an election day in Cambridgeshire in recent history, there were elections for five different levels of local government on the same day, with three different processes. No wonder the voters are confused. Only people within the system want this complexity and confusion; they are the only ones with the time, energy and self-interest to game the system to their own ends by fiddling the franchise. That confusion breeds distrust. A lack of trust in the system leads to a lack of confidence, respect and affinity for the institutions these elections serve. A fundamental premise of this debate is that fiddling with councils and the voting system is a good thing, but it is not. I want to sound a warning: rather than bringing people together, proportional representation and party lists will lead to more campaigning in Urdu, greater sectarian prejudice, incentives for extreme single-issue pressure groups to force their obsessive minority agendas on the rest of us, and more post-election rainbow alliances, able to tear up the manifestos they stood on. It is a recipe for division, not pulling together. Those campaigning for change need to be careful what they wish for. Another core premise of this debate is that we need to view this through the lens of local government reorganisation. Let us set aside for a moment that LGR should be dead and buried, given that the Prime Minister has announced he will nationalise the care system. The provision of care is local government’s largest and most expensive budget line, consuming about two-thirds of the £40 billion local spend—although, as we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, it is 92% in some cases. Simply put, I cannot see how LGR can proceed by law, because if that biggest-ticket financial item is uncertain, then the statutorily required value-for-money assessments cannot be concluded until the scope of the care system review is clarified. Until that is done in the next Parliament, those legal tests cannot be completed. The law is clear on this, having been determined by Justices Cranston and Ouseley in 2009 and 2010, respectively. When will the Minister give us clarity on that point? Will we have to suffer another two years of pointless LGR navel-gazing before it all gets thrown out again, humiliating her hapless department once more? That said, this debate asks whether democracy can be improved without pulling the lever marked “electoral funny business”. Before we blunder into another half-baked proposal, let us take a moment to think about maintaining equality in the value of the vote. In the other place, a 5% divergence from the average prompts a boundary change. Within a council, if an electoral ward varies by more than 10%, the boundary committee is called in; these are important safeguards. I want to put flesh on the bones of the noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, so to speak. Across the whole of local government, there are 3,108 electors per councillor in London, yet five times that quotient in other parts of the country. What the Government tried to deliver in Lincoln was a shabby gerrymander that would disgrace a banana republic: a proposal that would have seen three councillors per ward in Labour-voting areas, but only one per ward in the sticks—a 300% variance. Thank goodness we did not have to test that obviously unlawful proposal in court. If we contemplate reorganisation, we should at least have approximate equality of voting power for each resident on a national basis. Around 400,000 adult electors and 80 councillors per authority would lead to about 5,000 electors per councillor across the board, which seems about right. That would provide symmetry and an attempt at electoral equality that we should welcome. Ultimately, we have more pressing matters to attend to than fiddling with the vote. Why can the ministry not get over its obsessive-compulsive disorder on LGR and just stick to the day job, so that people who are grounded in their communities can serve on a geography and a canvass they recognise and can get it out in? In that way, we could avoid the disaster in Yorkshire, home to the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, where they put Scarborough, Selby and Skipton in the same local authority, an area it takes two hours to traverse, and is the preserve solely of the rich and retired motorist. That is not the way we should go.

More from Lord Fuller (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.