B

Baroness Pinnock (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, this has been a welcome and wide-ranging debate, which has enabled many different interpretations of a general debate about local government and electoral reform. The health of our local governance structures is vital to our health of our democracy; the two are inextricably entwined. That is why this debate, initiated by my noble friend Lord Shipley, is so timely and important. It is no surprise that he focused his attention on devolution, its challenges and its failings. Good governance is a balancing act between decision-makers and accountability—but fundamentally, it is about place. My noble friend Lord McCobb’s love letter to and about Hull demonstrates that to perfection. I hope that we hear more about Hull in the months and years ahead; it is a fabulous city. Decision-makers in local government are made up, as we have heard from the noble Lord, Lord Evans, of a cabinet of up to 10 councillors, and the discussion about the decisions they make is taken not in public but behind closed doors, in private, with council officers. Cabinet meetings announce and confirm decisions. Cabinet members are not required to make a sustained argument to support those decisions. Of course, some councils modify those procedures to make them more open, but there is no requirement to do so, and many do not. My noble friend Lord Shipley, in one of his many memorable statements, described how central government can feel like a closed shop, but so can town halls. It is up to all of us who love local democracy to enable more involvement. More involvement comes from the good governance test, and the good governance test is the effectiveness of accountability. The main formal route in governance structures is through scrutiny, yet since the introduction of the cabinet and scrutiny model more than 25 years ago, the scrutiny half of this equation has struggled to be seen and treated as an equal. In cash-strapped councils, officer time and focus is on decision-making. Scrutiny committees’ attention is often on decisions that have already been made, and any recommendations to cabinet are inevitably minor changes to improve those decisions rather than challenging their principle and purpose. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle pointed to this as an area of concern. What can we do, she said, when local decisions fail us? It is a good question. An active democracy depends on engagement in layers of government that play that part. The move towards unitary councils covering a large area will inevitably lead to councillors representing as many as 5,000 electors each. The noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, pointed to this. The noble Lord, Lord Fuller, thought that would be doable, but I have to tell him—as I represent more than 5,000 electors in my council ward—that it is challenging to be a truly local councillor. The change that this requires removes local decision-making even further from the very local issues that create the greatest concern for people, such as the state of local roads, parks and waste collection, among many others. In addition, metro mayors representing subregions will be joined by combined county mayors. Governments recognising the value of decision-making at this level on transport, strategic planning, business and employment is so important, as my noble friend Lord Shipley so eloquently described. We on these Benches wholeheartedly agree. However, these two fundamental changes have not been introduced alongside complementary enhancements to accountability structures. In his excoriating analysis, my noble friend exposed the lack of a good governance structure for mayoral authorities. The West Yorkshire Combined Authority serves over 2.5 million people, but has just a single scrutiny committee for a budget of £1.2 billion, which, of course, will increase. If ever there were a need to enhance accountability models, as my noble friend has said, it is in these subregional mayoral governments. True devolution, as we heard, is about giving up power to others. That leads us to think about the consequences for democracy in this brave new world. Government structures are becoming more remote as councils cover increasingly wide areas, and it is becoming more difficult for ward councillors to get their area understood by centrally based decision-makers. Voters understand that, and wonder what difference their vote will make. Turnout falls, except in those instances when a dramatic, though often implausible, offer is being made. Giving voters a chance to make their vote count is a vital ingredient of refreshing local democracy. We have had an interesting and widely varying debate on that aspect of electoral reform. There are those who espouse the first past the post method of voting, because it is the method whereby one gets there first and therefore that is what everybody wants. My noble friend Lord Wallace used two examples. One was from recent local government elections in Cornwall, where a local councillor was elected by less than 20% of those who voted. A mayor in the recent mayoral authority elections was elected by just 25% of those who voted. That is hardly a resounding vote of confidence in the folk who won those elections. From the comments that we have heard from the Conservative Benches on first past the post, I think they have a blinkered view of how changes in the number of candidates in elections could change the way people think about voting systems. There are other remedies to improve accountability and enhance our democracy. My noble friend Lady Scott of Needham Market explained eloquently, as she always does, how town and parish councils can and should be the answer. If they cannot be there, the other option is to enact the power passed in the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026—in the “Community Empowerment” bit we have not heard much about—for establishing neighbourhood forums. I hope the Minister can tell us more about when local authorities will be encouraged to do that. My noble friend Lord Shipley has devoted his life to public service, particularly local public services, and to espousing the needs of others. He has shared his wisdom, knowledge, experience and dedication, to the enormous benefit of those of us on the Liberal Democrat Benches as well as the House as a whole. We will miss him, and we want to extend our very good wishes to him and Margaret as he turns this final page in his parliamentary and public life. His introduction to this debate was a bravura performance. That is why we will miss him.

More from Baroness Pinnock (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.