B

Baroness O'Neill of Bexley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for this important debate on democratic accountability, public participation and electoral reform in local government. It is particularly poignant that he chose his final speech to be on this subject, which is so important to so many of us in this Chamber. There is no doubt that his presence will be missed. I add our thanks for all he has done and wish him and his family all the best for the future. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, on his maiden speech. His experience will no doubt come in handy in this Chamber and it is nice to have yet another local government champion to join the pack already here. Many noble Lords spoke about good local government. My noble friend Lord Jamieson referenced some of the statutory services that we all delivered when we were councillors. Someone told me some years ago that they referenced local government as the fourth emergency service. I think that is a really good account of what good local government is about. Members should remember the things that local government did during the pandemic, when there was no question about what was or was not our job. We stepped up to the plate. In our case, when the winter fuel allowance was withdrawn by the Government—subsequently to be brought back at some lower level—we stepped up to the plate in looking after our vulnerable residents. I really do not think we can afford to forget the benefits of good local government and what it delivers. However, when it comes to democratic accountability, this Government have made local government less local. When it comes to public participation, they cancelled local elections. When it comes to electoral reform, their Representation of the People Bill risks weakening safeguards against voter fraud. For all the rhetoric, this is not a strong record. On the first point, the Government promised community empowerment and continue to talk of further devolution; yet local government reorganisation aims to centralise local authorities and transfers more power into the hands of regional mayors from locally elected councillors. Schemes such as the national scheme of delegation have shifted power from elected representatives into the hands of unelected officers. Moreover, local government reorganisation has now been paused due to, we are told, updated legal advice and new government priorities. I understand that some of the leaders involved were told that there would be an announcement today; they have subsequently been told that that would not be the case. Major structural reforms to local government, with changes to staffing, finance, public service delivery and, yes, democratic accountability, cannot be fleeting. What was described by the party opposite as a once-in-a-generation opportunity has now been put on hold. I ask the Minister again: what is the estimated total cost of this review, both to national government and to the authorities affected, and when will those councils involved get the detail, as my noble friend Lady Eaton asked earlier? This is not to say that we on these Benches are opposed to devolution in principle. As my noble friend Lord Evans of Guisborough reminded us, in 2010 the only area in England with a devolution settlement was Greater London. By March 2024, thanks to the work of the previous Government, over 64% of England was covered by a devolution deal. This included over 90% of the north of England—some 14 million people. It is clear that there must be a balance, and devolution to local government should not be used to outsource responsibilities which clearly lie with national government, or as a disguise to make local government less local, as we have seen. I turn to public participation. Let us not forget that this Government tried to cancel local elections without consulting political parties beforehand or informing the Electoral Commission about the May 2026 elections. The Government then U-turned, only in the face of a judicial review challenge. When those elections in May took place, the Electoral Commission reported that public confidence in voter registration and awareness of voter ID requirements remains high. This brings me to the Government’s proposals for electoral reform in the Representation of the People Bill, such as automatic voter registration. Individual voter registration ensures that there are proper checks concerning eligibility to vote, with more accurate registers, which are updated. When it was introduced, this system removed the concept that only a head of the household could decide who should be on the electoral roll. People are increasingly mobile. One in three private rented tenants will move every year, and we do not want registers relying on potentially outdated information or adding people to the electoral roll who may have a residence but are not eligible to vote. Moreover, we do not know how much automatic registration will cost. Can the Minister give us an estimate now? The Bill also seeks to water down voter ID requirements, such as allowing bank cards. Bank cards do not have a photograph, yet photo ID is required to drive or to buy alcohol if you are under the age of 25 —a long time ago for me. It is also worth noting that many young people do not use bank cards; they have a banking app on their phone. We understand that we want more people who are eligible to go out to vote, but why do the Government not focus their efforts on increasing awareness of the free voter authority certificate, for example, rather than weakening requirements? No doubt we will discuss these proposals in greater detail in Committee, but any further information the Minister could provide us with in this debate would be helpful. We all want local government to be simpler, with clearer lines of accountability and strong participation. We also want local government to be genuinely local, to be democratically accountable and for the public to be inspired to participate. We should not look to centralise local government further, put more power in the hands of unelected officers or undermine the safeguards in the electoral systems. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response.

More from Baroness O'Neill of Bexley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.