T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (Baroness Taylor of Stevenage) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform

Contribution

My Lords, I begin by thanking the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, for an excellent valedictory speech and for securing this debate as his final farewell and statement to this House. The noble Lord was introduced to the House in 2010, but it is his service over many more years than that, both in local and national government, that we should celebrate with him today. I met the noble Lord recently in Newcastle, at the funeral of my noble friend Lord Beecham. It was interesting to have that connection between Jeremy Beecham and the noble Lord. I know that the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, was the housing and planning spokesman for the Liberal Democrats from 2017 to 2019, so he has brought, as do many of us from local government in this House, all that experience to the work of the House. I particularly thank the noble Lord for the fantastic contribution he made recently to the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act. He was not exactly every Minister’s nightmare, as his interventions were welcome, but he is both forensic and informed by his extensive experience in local government. I am sure that has been the tone of his contributions throughout this career in this House, and I am very grateful to him. As the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, said, support for Sunderland Football Club was a bit of surprise, but that is the north-east for you. I wish the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, and Margaret all the best for the future. I thank him for his service to this House and I hope he will keep in touch with all of us. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, for an excellent maiden speech. He too has long experience of local government. He joins a very dedicated local government club here in the House of Lords. I know that he will be a powerful advocate for both local government and Yorkshire. I heard an interesting connection, because my town, Stevenage, also has a charter fair granted to us by King Edward I in 1281—the noble Lord might have just pipped us at the post. We have a very long-standing connection in that respect. I was interested to hear about the transport issues in Hull, and I look forward to the noble Lord’s support for the devolution programme that will, I hope, change it in the future. I congratulate him, his council and partners on the City of Culture and the fantastic work that was done in Hull. I look forward to working with him. This debate has been thoughtful and characteristically well informed on the topic that the noble Lord, Lord Shipley, placed before us. We have shown that, across the House and regardless of our political differences, there is a shared purpose and ambition to strengthen our local democracy and democratic participation. The Government share that ambition. We heard similar contributions during the passage of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, on the Representation of the People Bill and in other recent business. The strength of our local democracy and democratic participation is more important than our party politics. We all agree on that, which is precisely why the Government value all contributions from across the House as we take forward measures to strengthen all our country’s democratic structures. As noble Lords have heard, the Government’s ambitious devolution agenda will strengthen local democratic accountability and participation. We think that local accountability is strongest when it is closer to local people, and that the full potential of devolution will not be met without the participation of those residents and communities. As I said when we debated the then English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill, the Government are delivering the most significant transfer of power out of Whitehall and into communities in a century. We know, and have heard today, the importance of proportionate and effective local democratic accountability in strengthening that local democracy and community voice. Of course, local authorities are independent and autonomous bodies with their own democratic mandate, primarily accountable to the local electorate. Central government wants to support local authorities in that. We also have an important role to play in reducing the system risk that may exist in there, primarily by setting out the requirements and obligations for robust and effective internal governance and financial management, as well as the processes by which local communities can hold their local institutions to account. Getting the balance right on local accountability is important. This Government are reinforcing their commitment to ambitious devolution by making sure local accountability evolves at the same pace. Devolution is underpinned by the principle that decisions should be taken closer to communities, with local leaders empowered to shape priorities that deliver outcomes for their areas. It follows that accountability should also be closer to and accessible by the communities impacted by those decisions. We are simplifying and improving how to understand outcomes in a local area. The noble Lord, Lord Shipley, referred to mayoral accountability, which is a really important feature. The local outcomes framework will make outcomes-based assessment more accessible. Commitments to streamlining the integrated settlement outcomes framework will make oversight of strategic authorities much more coherent. We are further strengthening local transparency and external scrutiny and assurance. The local audit office will streamline, co-ordinate and oversee the local audit system and ensure there is timely and clear reporting of financial and governance risks in individual authorities. More accessible and easier to understand information about how it is going in a local area will better inform local residents and communities, and enable them to more effectively engage in democratic processes. That is not about getting into the weeds of the spreadsheets—though I know there are some people who love to do that—but about having an overall picture of how the authority is performing. We are making sure local scrutiny arrangements match the greater powers and funding being granted to mayors. As noble Lords know, we are introducing local scrutiny committees through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act. As I said in that debate, and as I reiterate now, they will play an important role in strengthening local democratic accountability. I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, that good practice in scrutiny should be both pre and post decision-making, and I hope those local scrutiny committees will do that. Local scrutiny committees are just the first step in strengthening the accountability system for strategic authorities. Through the Government’s ambitions in Rewiring the State, we have set out a suite of measures to ensure that increased autonomy and power for mayors is met with stronger accountability alongside that. This includes designating chief executives of mayoral strategic authorities as local accounting officers, providing a stronger role for the local audit office and streamlining the existing outcomes frameworks for those authorities. We will set out more detail on these measures in due course. It is important that accountability and oversight arrangements are revisited to keep them effective. The Government are updating the English devolution accountability framework and scrutiny protocol to provide greater clarity on roles, responsibilities and expectations across the devolved powers. We know and have heard today the importance of an empowered local community and the vital role it plays in local democracy. This Government are introducing new powers for communities, to provide a stronger voice for them in their place, which I will talk more about a bit later. We want to enable local people to protect treasured local assets and to create meaningful opportunities for people to participate in shaping local priorities beyond elections. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle spoke powerfully about this. I agree with her: we cannot carry on thinking that engagement is sticking up a green notice on a lamppost and hoping people will spot it and get engaged. I saw for myself in Halifax, which suffered from dreadful floods, the importance of local networks in an emergency situation such as that. It is important that we look at new ways of developing approaches to consultation. Our First Secretary of State issued a press release recently in which she confirmed that: “In the Autumn, government will set out its vision for public participation and will issue new guidance providing practical steps for modern, meaningful engagement”. As noble Lords know well, democratic participation goes beyond voting in elections. This Government are committed to encouraging broader and more inclusive participation in democracy by tackling the barriers that prevent people getting involved. That is why we are implementing the £2.5 million democratic engagement fund, through which civil society organisations will deliver politically neutral, place-based activities that help people understand, engage with and participate in democracy. We have had over 350 applications to that fund. We will be announcing the results in January, and I look forward to monitoring those experiments as they go forward. An essential part of local democratic participation is people feeling that they can safely stand and hold public office free from intimidation or harassment. This is a topic that the whole House and the other place are united on and that I and this Government take seriously. We outlined proposals in the strengthening standards and conduct framework that we are taking forward. These proposals will create a more robust, clearer and more consistently applied conduct system that will help locally elected members to hold themselves and their colleagues to account in meeting the high standards and conduct that their roles demand and the public have a right to expect. We are changing the law to disqualify from elected office those convicted of intimidating or abusing electoral staff, and empowering courts to give tougher sentences to those who abuse candidates, campaigners, elected representatives and electoral staff. We know and have heard about the importance of effective local elections both in encouraging greater democratic participation and turnout and in holding safe and secure elections free from interference. The Prime Minister has been clear about his commitment to electoral reform, and I think that all noble Lords in this debate raised that issue. We recognise the strength of feeling about the operation of our democracy. That is why the Prime Minister has announced the establishment of a new national commission on electoral reform, so that our voting system can better give power to people in every postcode. The commission will ensure that everyone can have their say on this important issue, including political parties, community groups, trade unions, businesses, faith groups and voters of all parties and none. That will include the election geeks who look at and work on the systems—it is very good that they will have a chance to make their views known. We will work to create a more automated voter registration system, making it simpler and easier for those who are eligible to register to vote. I say to the noble Baroness, Lady O’Neill, that I do not think it is acceptable that we have over 7 million people in this country who are eligible to vote but are not registered to vote. We have got to do something about that and we will work on that. That will involve enabling electoral registration officers to make better use of public sector data and looking at ways to integrate voter registration into other services. My noble friend Lord Campbell-Savours referred to the link with constituency. The link with the local community is important both at a local level for councillors and at a national level for MPs. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle reminded us of the principles by which any change must be judged. I absolutely agree that we have to hold fast to those principles as we go through the process of having a national conversation on electoral reform. We need to think very carefully about all these issues on electoral reform, and I believe that a national commission is the right way to do that, as we can go through all the detail that people want to discuss. As we have heard in this House, there are strongly differing views on this, so it is important that all those views are heard. A number of noble Lords spoke about “genuine” devolution. The noble Lord, Lord Shipley, made it the centre of his speech, and the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle, the noble Lords, Lord Wallace, Lord Pack, Lord Jamieson and Lord Evans, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, all featured it in their contributions. Devolution is about moving decision-making from Whitehall and bringing decisions closer to the communities they affect. It is about giving local leaders greater control over priorities such as transport, housing, skills and economic growth. It is not about taking powers from local government and giving them to mayors; it is about taking powers from Whitehall and Westminster and giving them to mayors and local government. The Government recognise that genuine devolution must do more than transfer power between institutions; it must give people and communities meaningful opportunities to shape the decisions, services and investment that affect their lives. Our Rewiring the State agenda sets an ambition to put power back into the hands of people and the places where they live, work and invest. The noble Lord, Lord Shipley, referred to our former Secretary of State’s comments about devolution from government. My right honourable friend Steve Reed, my honourable friend Jim McMahon and I worked together on the Co-operative Councils’ Innovation Network, which was all about that. It was about transferring power and letting policy be made from grass roots upwards. There were a number of contributions on participation in local democracy, which is an important issue—from the noble Lords, Lord Shipley, Lord Redwood and Lord Wallace, the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle and the noble Baroness, Lady Scott. Democratic participation is broader than voting; it includes understanding democratic processes, discussing issues, engaging with representatives, campaigning, joining local or youth forums and contributing to decisions. Supporting participation helps citizens to build the knowledge, skills and confidence to engage critically with information and democratic institutions, strengthening individual and community resilience. The democratic engagement fund that we have set up will help to lead the way in saying what works in terms of participation. Noble Lords raised the issue of clear lines of accountability—the noble Lords, Lord Redwood, Lord Wallace and Lord Jamieson, the right reverend Prelate and the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, spoke about it. A key purpose of devolution is to create those clearer lines of accountability so that residents know who is responsible for decisions affecting their area. Where powers over transport, housing, planning and other strategic functions are devolved, mayors and mayoral strategic authorities will be accountable for decisions and the outcomes they deliver. Local councils will remain accountable for their services and responsibilities. Community-level accountability will be maintained through local councillors, constituent councils and strengthened local scrutiny committees. Local people will be able to influence major decisions through elections, engagement with their representatives, public consultation and scrutiny arrangements. They will have the ability to petition local scrutiny committees on matters of local concern. The purpose of devolution is not to move decisions from one tier of government to another; it is to make responsibility more visible so that residents can clearly identify who is accountable for decisions and the outcomes they deliver. There were a number of comments on local government reorganisation, particularly from the noble Baronesses, Lady Eaton and Lady O’Neill, and the noble Lords, Lord Jamieson and Lord Fuller. I have spoken about this as the transfer of power out of Westminster. I have heard repeatedly that this is a top-down reorganisation—it absolutely was not; the proposals came from local government. The Government remain committed to reform and local government reorganisation. Achieving good growth will require a fundamental rewiring of the way the country works. Local government structures and strong, sustainable local government are vital to devolution ambitions. Single-tier unitary local authorities are a more effective and efficient building block, and unitary authorities are best placed to be partners with mayors in combined authorities. The Prime Minister promised that he would listen to concerns raised by local people about local government reorganisation decisions. As a new Administration, we want to pause and reflect. It is important that this is done properly. Further announcements will be made on that once this work is done. The noble Baroness, Lady Eaton, referred to warding and structural changes. Because of the pause, we cannot answer those questions at the moment, but I will come back to her as soon as we can. On her question about legal advice, she knows that it is a long tradition that legal advice is not published. The preservation of the role of councillors is vital. A number of noble Lords spoke about this, including the noble Lords, Lord Shipley, Lord Redwood and Lord Evans. We want to strengthen, not weaken, the role of local councillors. They remain the elected representatives closest to their communities, shaping local priorities and representing their residents, so they will continue to have that strong role in new structures. I have mentioned the local government standards reform already, but on enabling remote attendance for meetings, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Scott, that we must enable that participation, encourage people and help them to feel that they are safe in participating. To the noble Lord, Lord Pack, I say that I am absolutely on a mission now to devolve cattle grids. We are working on enabling councils to develop modern, accessible and locally appropriate remote and hybrid attendance policies. We are on the case with that. I am running out of time, as I knew I would. To the points I have not replied to I will do so in writing, but I want to pick up the point on parish and town councils, which will continue to have a very strong role in this new system. We are updating the guidelines on community governance reviews so that those who want to set up new ones can do so. We will also publish the neighbourhood governance framework this year. That will set out high-level principles on neighbourhood governance and how we are moving forward with that. I will reply in writing to any noble Lords whom I have not replied to directly. I am very grateful for the thoughtful contributions that have been offered in this debate. I thank again the noble Lords, Lord Shipley and Lord McCobb, for their outstanding contributions, and look forward to continuing to engage with noble Lords as the Government take forward work in these areas.

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (Baroness Taylor of Stevenage) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.