Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 183 and no fewer than 10 other amendments that I have in this group, although I hope to be relatively brief. These amendments all concern the powers and duties of the passenger watchdog, the Passengers’ Council, which is referred to here. I have a fairly lengthy interest in passenger representation which goes back to 2004 when the noble Baroness, Lady Featherstone, became chair of the London Assembly’s transport committee and I was appointed her deputy. The committee had a very wide-ranging role, so she asked me to take on the role of reviewing the performance of what was at the time the London Transport Users’ Committee.
The London Transport Users’ Committee was an unusual organisation. It covered a much larger area than Greater London because it covered the airports as well. It was also unusual because its management board, its supervising board, had more members than it had members of staff and, although they were very committed to improving transport services in London and very interested and very well informed, a lot of those people had backgrounds in the transport industry, particularly the rail industry. They often seemed to feel that the interests of the rail provider were exactly the same thing as the interests of the passengers. They could not really discriminate between the two. They were products of what my noble friend Lord Moylan—who, sadly, is not in his place at the moment because I am sure he would agree with me—calls the no-choice railway or the Soviet-type railway. They had been in public service for so long that they thought they knew exactly what the passengers wanted without actually asking the passengers themselves.
The amendments here are designed to bring a little more focus to the Passengers’ Council and give it more powers so that it becomes a body that has some real teeth on behalf of passengers and to differentiate between what might be in the interests of the railway providers and in the interests of their passengers.
My Amendment 183 seeks to introduce a new clause that would define the purpose of the Passengers’ Council with six different subsections. The first seeks to
“champion the interests of all users and potential users of the railway, including, in particular, the needs of disabled persons”.
The next seeks to advocate for reliability, and lists the various measures of reliability for passenger services. The following seeks to advocate for the “safety and security” of passengers on railways. Another seeks to advocate—this has a broad heading—for passengers’ “comfort and on-board experience”; I briefly touched on this in our previous debate. That includes the availability of power sockets and the provision of wifi for passengers; that was not important in the past but certainly will be in the future. There is then a subsection that seeks to
“advocate for affordability and value for money”,
and another, looking forward, to advocate for “passenger growth” and coverage. I am pleased to move this amendment, as it spells out the function of the council and aligns it better with what we know passengers’ priorities to be.
As I stated, I have 10 other amendments, and I will visit them very briefly. Amendment 186 seeks to amend Clause 36(b), to change
“make efficient use of those funds”
to
“ensure value for money through a cost benefit analysis”,
which is a stronger and more focused definition.
Amendment 187 seeks to add the requirement for Ministers and GBR to respond to Passengers’ Council representations within one month. That is important because, otherwise, these things can drag on. It would require a timed response.
Amendment 188 seeks to add a requirement for the Passengers’ Council to assess user satisfaction every 12 months. This is intended particularly to deal with the tendency of such organisations to conflate the needs of the provider with the needs of the users. A survey will give the council a clear steer about what it should be looking for.
Amendment 189 seeks to give the Passengers’ Council the role and power to deal with unsatisfied requests, rather than referring them to the ORR. It would be a faster process, less bureaucratic and make the Passengers’ Council stronger.
Amendment 190 means that contraventions of the licence or the condition of any passenger licence will have to be referred to the ORR and the Secretary of State. It would remove a potential loophole that could be commonly used to avoid doing that.
Amendments 191, 192 and 193 are all designed to ensure that, where a contravention of a licence is referred to, action is taken by the ORR. We would leave out the second option, which is to take no action if a contravention has been referred to the ORR.
Amendment 194 would replace “may” with “must” in Clause 43(3), so that if the Passengers’ Council prepares a report of an investigation, it must then publish it. This will ensure more openness and accountability for the passenger watchdog.
Finally, Amendment 195 would add a requirement to publish such a report within six months of the investigation, again providing a deadline.
That is a brief run-through the various amendments that I have tabled, and I look forward to hearing the Minister’s comments, as well as those of other Members of the Committee.