Contribution
It is a great pleasure to follow the right reverend Prelate. I understand that this is her third speech of the day, so I congratulate her stickability.
I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for bringing this incredibly important issue to the Floor of the House. We have heard that food security is national security and, as such, it should be treated as a permanent strategic priority rather than something which is focused on only when there is a crisis. There is no doubt, however, that recent geopolitical instability has demonstrated how quickly international disruption can feed through to the cost of producing food. Of course, agriculture is particularly exposed through energy and fuel security issues of supply and cost, and fertiliser’s availability and cost. From a Northern Ireland point of view, the carbon border adjustment mechanism—coming in at the start of next year—will have an impact on the availability and the cost of fertiliser. Again for Northern Ireland, transport and logistics can be an issue in and around the Windsor Framework, as well as all the international changes in relation to commodities.
The issue, therefore, is not simply whether food can be imported today. The Government really need to consider how resilient our supply chains would be during a sustained international crisis. We need to move away from responding to individual crises with short-term measures and towards long-term contingency planning for food.
As noble Lords would expect, I want to bring a Northern Ireland flavour to the debate. The Ulster Farmers Union has supplied me with some contemporary figures, and I wanted to bring them to the House. Fertiliser prices were at least 25.9% higher in June 2026 than a year earlier. Energy costs were 20% higher. At the same time, the agricultural output price index was 4.3% lower year on year. In Northern Ireland in 2025, expenditure on fertiliser and lime increased 32% to £133 million. That all matters in relation to food security.
It is not merely about higher costs. Persistent pressure on margins affects a willingness to invest. The replacement of machinery and infrastructure is pushed back, as are decisions about future production. It affects productivity, succession and the next generation, and our capacity to deal with environmental requirements. Ultimately, it is also about the amount of food that we are capable of producing in the UK.
On succession planning, the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, already mentioned the inheritance tax changes. It might interest the Minister to know that, in a recent survey carried out by the Ulster Farmers Union of its members, 88.6% of respondents indicated that the inheritance tax changes had increased family stress and worry. The economic health of primary agriculture is an early warning indicator on food security, and we need to acknowledge that.
The good news is that, notwithstanding the pressure on family farms, Northern Ireland should be regarded as strategically important in relation to food production for the UK. It has productive family farms and established livestock, dairy, poultry, egg, arable and horticultural sectors. It has an experienced agricultural workforce and, of course, a significant downstream food and drink industry. Maintaining that capacity is important, not only for us in Northern Ireland but for the wider UK food system. The Government should think strategically about agricultural productive capacity, rather than viewing agriculture purely through the lens of annual support budgets. The question should be not simply how we support agriculture but what agricultural capacity the UK believes it needs to remain resilient.
In that regard, have the Minister and the Government given any thought to a food production duty on our farmers, given the importance of food security to the nation? We have all sorts of duties on welfare, the environment and the health of our produce but, given the seriousness of food security, perhaps we should think about a food production duty. That would give farmers the certainty that they need.
We should view this not just as domestic production increasing versus lessening our imports; that is a false choice. Imports are, and will remain, an essential part of our food security. Equally, becoming overly dependent on imports from a small number of countries or vulnerable supply routes carries obvious risks. We need a resilient UK food system with a strong domestic production and diverse international trade. It is not an argument for isolation or complete self-sufficiency. Having said that, our ability to produce food domestically is a strategic national asset and one that we should absolutely celebrate.
As I think the noble Lord, Lord Smith, said, food security must start at the farm gate. Farmers cannot be expected to continually absorb increasing input costs, maintain high production standards, improve productivity, invest in new technology, improve environmental performance, respond to climate change and continue providing affordable food without receiving a sustainable return from the market. We need a fair, competitive and functioning supply chain with greater transparency; that is so important. Food security ultimately begins with the primary producer. If farmers cannot make an adequate return then they cannot invest, maintain production or respond to the shocks we have seen over the past months. I would like to see food security embedded in government decision-making as a long-term strategic objective.
My last point is that food security and environmental policy must work together. We must avoid portraying food production and the environment as competing objectives. Northern Ireland farmers are already doing significant work around soil health, which has been mentioned, as well as genetics, carbon footprinting, nutrient efficiency, biodiversity and environmental management. The objective should be sustainable production, rather than simply less production. There is little food security benefit in reducing UK production if consumption remains unchanged and production is simply displaced overseas. My message to the Minister is that environmental resilience and food security should be designed together and not pursued in separate policy silos.
I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response, in particular on the idea of a duty on food production, which could change the dynamics around our food security.