Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Teather on her excellent speech; it was completely comprehensive in going through all the areas that she said she would cover—areas on which we would all love to be experts.
One thing to say is that the UK is no stranger to food crises. When I was born—I will not say exactly when—we still had rationing from the Second World War. The rationing of sweets, chocolate and sugar ended in 1953, while the rationing of meat, poultry and, I think, fish products finally ended in 1954. I am pleased to say that I do not remember that time at all, though I was alive and it is within living memory of people in this country.
I was also present—much more so—at the point the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, mentioned: the explosion of just-in-time. During the 1980s, I operated under contract fleets for Sainsbury’s and other major contractors. I dealt with a company called Crazy Prices—a brilliant food retailer in Northern Ireland that has since been taken over by Tesco. At that time, the fast-moving consumer goods industry in groceries moved from around a few hundred lines to between 4,000 and 11,000 in a typical supermarket or superstore. As a nation, we were in a situation where we had an amazing variety of foods from across the globe and across the country that we could enjoy, and we made the most of it and took it totally for granted. Just-in-time, for which I take some responsibility, did exactly what the noble Baroness said: it took stocks completely out of the system, which was very profitable for those retailers. That system, with the help of further computerisation and automation, still exists. I may come back to that later.
There are so many things that I could talk about, and my noble friend has mentioned a number of them: the challenges of nature-friendly farming, biodiversity, pollinators and invasive species—which we have not talked about, but which is key. But I want to talk about the other 70% of the planet: our oceans and seas, which I do not think have been mentioned today. They provide something like only 6% of total global protein, but in many countries it is far higher, up to 50%. In the UK, it is higher as well, with our tradition of fish and chips, although we export 80% of our fish and import 80% of what we consume.
Two reports have come out this week on the state of our oceans and fishing stocks globally and nationally. In the UK, the MSC seafood report has highlighted that 29 categories of fish have gone from green or amber to red, or from green to amber. That is clearly not good. There is some good news for North Sea herring and bluefin tuna, which I have been privileged to see from Land’s End, down in Cornwall, near where I live—a fantastic spectacle if Members have the opportunity to see them. There is a little positivity but, despite all our management, our fish stocks are not in a good position. Internationally, in comparison with 1970, global fish stocks are down something like 59%. That is a truly worrying figure for the future of biodiversity in our oceans and, particularly, the artisanal fisheries in the developing world that rely on those fish stocks.
Will the Minister say whether, nationally, we are pursuing hard enough the illegal, unregistered and unreported fisheries? Are we doing enough? I feel that we still are not. It is a difficult issue, but one that we need to address. Are we pushing the International Maritime Organization on those fishing vessels and huge trawlers that go across the high seas, unflagged or flagged with nations of convenience that take no control over their actions? Are we doing something on that? Something I know the Minister feels strongly about and has worked on with us all in this House is the treaty on biodiversity beyond natural jurisdictions. Now that the UK has ratified the treaty, it gives us the opportunity to get together with other like-minded nations to have some influence and control over piracy on the high seas outside EEZs. I would be interested to hear from the Minister what we are doing on that. Are we pushing that important agenda forward? That is national and international, but I want to come back to the national aspect.
One important area of understanding scientifically what is happening in our seas is equipping our fishing vessels with remote electronic monitoring. The Government have said that they want to do this, and I am absolutely sure that they do, but, at the moment, I think we have only one vessel that has remote electronic monitoring and can analyse exactly what has been caught and give such depth of scientific information. Scotland has moved ahead on this: its pelagic fleet has to be equipped in that way. When will we do that in England? Because of our agreement with the EU, if we do that in English waters, it means that foreign vessels in our waters will also need to have similar technical equipment and do exactly the same. This would not only solve the issue for British waters but would, I hope, have a contagious effect on European fisheries. Those are the areas that I would like to see accelerated, as they are so important in saving our oceans and seas.
Finally, we talk about food imports, but we do not often talk about food exports. We export some 14% of our agricultural production, mainly fish, meat and drink—which I will come back to later. I would be interested to hear the Government’s view of how that affects strategy. How should we look at that? I am not suggesting a Trump-style diesel export ban, but perhaps there are some possibilities there that would make us more secure.
I mentioned at the beginning of my speech that we had rationing. That was state imposed. These days, we have family-imposed rationing. We have at least 2,800 food stations in this country, and the Trussell Trust alone put out some 2.5 million parcels of food last year. We need to change that. We have moved from state rationing to family rationing, and that cannot be right in our advanced society.