Contribution
My Lords, I wonder whether the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle—we have both done a stretch today—is as fed up as I am with Ministers saying that national security is food security, when at every step, whether by tax, regulation, ignorance or prejudice, obstacles are put in the way of those who put bread on our tables.
We have never imported more of our food than at present, either by weight or by value. Last week, the Food and Drink Federation told us that overall imports rose by 0.9% to £33.1 billion in the first half of the year, the highest since records began in 2000. That £33 billion is twice the entire farm gate gross domestic product of all the farmers in our nation. By a ratio of 2:1, we are importing more than we are producing. That is not healthy. In the hierarchy of needs, food in your belly ranks above a roof over your head. We have heard about public money for public goods: there is no public good more important than feeding the nation.
We have the most productive broadacre agriculture in the world, and some of the best dairy and livestock ground, all of which enhance our natural landscapes. Nowadays, one man can do 2,000 acres. It is astonishing. The old days when a 500-acre family farm could support three generations are well and truly over. I know this more than most because I have a first-class degree in agriculture; I am a director of a large farming business, and I have built a career in the fertiliser industry, which is the foundation of the entire food chain. Hugely complex, technical and market-driven upstream supply chains drive world-leading innovations in plant nutrition, seed production, and crop protection. Not only that but those firms—mostly privately owned—take the big financial and logistical risks so that, when spring comes and crops start growing, farmers have the critical input they need to ensure that their crops meet their full potential.
The problem is that our yeoman farmers have the Government on their backs. The National Audit Office has in recent weeks called on the Government to make our food system more resilient, but they have stopped investment in our farming future stone dead with the family farm tax. However, not only do they attack those farms, handed down in trust over generations, but they harm that wider economic private ecosystem that supports them. Somebody mentioned Warburtons earlier—a private business; all are under threat, alongside machinery dealers who are on their knees and a network of fencers, ditchers, drain workers and groundworkers who now have no incentive whatever to invest in their or our future.
By some delusion, the Chief Secretary breezily tells them not to worry about inheritance tax—dear oh dear. The Government’s stand is incomprehensible because their land use framework—which is a shoddy piece of work that would shame a sixth-form geography project with its suggestion that Norfolk, breadbasket of our nation, should be forested— requires a 20% improvement in agricultural productivity by 2050. I ask the Minister: where does she think this 20% productivity gain is going to come from when yield improvements have flatlined over a decade, when new investment has been made irrational or where our best land is carpeted with solar panels?
I was grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Smith, for an important and telling contribution when, for the first time to my knowledge in this House, he raised the risks that are faced in the cold store business. Cold store and cool chain are extraordinarily vulnerable pieces of national infrastructure that ensure food arrives in our stores safely and nutritiously. I am grateful to him for raising that threat to our food security.
We heard last week that there is one civil servant for every five farmers. What have these people been doing? They have been designing an SFI system, which launched mid-morning during the best drilling conditions of the year; it was exhausted after five and a half hours and resulted in only 50 upland farmers in the most fragile environments—of which the Minister knows best—being accepted. Three-quarters of eligible farmers missed out because they did not employ armies of land agents and have now been forced to rip up the environmental improvements, lovingly cherished for years, and instead go hell for leather on intensification. That is a failure.
It is this Government who have driven the wedge between economic security and environmental benefits. They have forced farmers to plough up as much land as they can. No wonder they have all gone to the pub for a pint of warm beer; their black Labrador has a better idea of what is going on than the Government we pay to sort this out. It is a battle of survival now, while real ale dulls the drone of the sanctimonious Defra press releases pretending SFI was a success while treating the callus-handed farmers with contempt. I am sorry for the farmers who thought they could put 75% of their farms into regenerative approaches, which is only really fit for rooks and crows. They were suckered.
Those who remain wonder how they are going to get cash flow from the crops they are meant to be putting into the ground after three bad harvests. First, it was too wet, then too cold, and lately too hot. Could the economic security of these farms get any worse? Well, yes. Say what you like about Brexit, but we now have effective blackgrass control for the winter wheat that millers and bakers use to bake our bread. I attempt to pronounce the product name, but it is a miracle which could be traded away in a late-night session on 20 November alongside that other miracle, precision breeding.
I have met the people using CRISPR technology to breed more nutritious tomatoes, longer-life strawberries that halve food waste, and faster-flowering, healthier purple broccoli, and the Norfolk company protecting the Cavendish banana in Africa and Latin America from disastrous fungal attack without the need for chemicals. All this is at risk from an SPS deal that asks for alignment rather than mutual recognition. The EU has seen us coming.
It is not just the EU; the US has done a CO deal which rewards French farmers with a £1 million subsidy per day over our own. It was needed only because the former Prime Minister recklessly decimated our clean biofuels industry when he negligently surrendered 1.4 billion litres of tariffed product—which just happened to be the market—in another one of those late-night phone calls with the US President.
This week, the other place rubber-stamped new taxes on fertilisers, the thing that drives productivity the greatest, which will be added to a farmer’s most expensive input. That will do nothing to reduce carbon emissions, because this Government’s energy policies make domestic production impossible. All it will do is incentivise the importation, at huge cost, of the most polluting fertilisers and drive up the cost of food in an inflationary spiral that affects the poorest the worst.
We have a Minister who faints at the sight of blood while a former Agriculture Minister says the Government do not understand these issues. We know this because Defra has entered into a contract to send its civil servants to see what farms look like. It is unbelievable.
I want to be helpful to the Minister. This litany of failure is bad politics for the Labour Party. It has a majority in the other place of some 160, but 80 of those MPs are in rural or semi-rural seats. They are the Government’s majority.
The Government say they want to reset relations with the countryside. On all these issues, they are going to have to square away the farmers and those who form part of that wider £160 billion GVA in the food, drink and agriculture industry, or they will be done. Labour have estranged themselves from the countryside, and now they need to make an existential choice between putting food on Britain’s table or pursuing a class war fantasy grounded in a world they say never existed. Dogs, warm beer and roaring fires do exist. The only delusion is a hard-left fantasy, blind to the reality that a nation that cannot feed itself in a dangerous world is no nation at all.
For the Prime Minister and Chancellor, it is “make your mind up” time: stop the war on the countryside, the farmers and family businesses or face the music. It is as simple as that. The choice is theirs.