Contribution
My Lords, what is meant by food security? What it is not is complete self-sufficiency. We looked up a definition produced by the FAO which was very long-winded but might be précised as the adequate availability of healthy food at affordable prices. Surely, along with defence, and energy, a prime responsibility of any Government should be food security. This debate is therefore very welcome, and I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for securing it. The Motion before us asks us to take note of growing threats to UK food security, but before considering those, it might be useful to set in context the current situation by looking at recent historical trends.
The UK self-sufficiency values since the 1950s have risen for all food, from 50% in 1956 to a maximum of 75% in the early 1980s, before dropping back to the current figure of 60%. For indigenous food—that which we can produce in the UK—the respective figures for 1956 were about 62%. It rose to 90% in the 80s and has currently fallen back to 75%. For the last 20 years or so, these indices have remained more or less stable, in spite of Covid-19 and geopolitical instabilities. Our farmers and the whole supply chain deserve much credit for that stability.
However, climate change and increasing international instability against a background of a rapidly rising global population present real and acute food challenges, nationally and internationally. With regards to climate change, this year in the UK we have faced the worst drought in 50 years, which has resulted in historically low harvests, failed crop production and much reduced grass growth for feeding animals. While much of England is still classified as in drought now, in October, the total precipitation over the UK has not changed over historic levels. What has happened is that rainfall is much more lumpy and has changed in its seasonality. We urgently need to move to actively conserve the water which falls from the sky, to secure assured supplies for both domestic and agriculture purposes. Farmers are increasingly storing on-farm water in their reservoirs and seeking further abstraction possibilities. Can the Minister say what His Majesty’s Government are doing to improve planning policies and guidance to enable the building of more on-farm reservoirs and enable more abstraction to safeguard food production?
The multiple threats to food security, apart from climate change, include plant and animal diseases, land-use changes, increasing vulnerability arising from dependence on imports, labour shortages and, most recently, as has just been mentioned, failure of cold chains, either through malicious cyber hackers or abnormally high temperatures.
Threats to the biosecurity of animals and plants are increasing due to the volume of movement of goods, people and animal and plant products, and the spread of vector-borne disease. Bluetongue virus disease is now established thoroughly in the UK and is transmitted by midges, causing various problems with cattle and sheep. It does not affect humans or food safety but is extremely detrimental to the health and productivity of livestock. Other vector-transmitted pathogenic viral infections are also established here, such as Schmallenberg virus. The new kid on the block is Shamonda virus, which has appeared in mainland Europe and very recently in Jersey. Avian influenza continues to threaten the poultry industry, and African swine fever and foot and mouth are constant serious threats to our pig industry.
A fundamental parameter that limits food production is the amount of land devoted to agriculture. Given the current increase in threats to productivity, it is concerning that the recent land use framework policy document, published in March this year, recommends that 9% of agricultural land be taken out of food production. It is proposed that improved productivity should or could make up the difference. It is certainly presenting a challenge to our UK food production and supply chains to produce that level of increased productivity, given the uncertain challenges faced through more extreme weather events.
The extent and size of loss of agricultural land is well illustrated by the current pre-application for the West Oxfordshire Energy Park, a solar farm which is planned to occupy 2,400 acres of what appears to be grade 2 or 3a agricultural land.
Imported food has always been an important part of the food we eat, particularly fruit and vegetables. Diversity of sources of some products actually improves the security of supply and buffers against any failures in our indigenous sources. It also enables exports of products of animal origin, for example, to help balance carcass sales.
UK self-sufficiency values for milk, mutton and lamb are very high—over 100%—and, in spite of some reduction, have been reasonably stable for poultry meat, beef and cereals, at over 80%. The cereal situation is worrying because historically, a substantial global source of wheat has been from Russia and Ukraine.
Critical to both imported plant and animal products is that the standards applied to their production should not undercut the standards expected of our indigenous producers, thereby enabling cheaper products. Not only would this unfair competition threaten our indigenous production and food security, but it may carry animal and plant health risks. A recent example of that is salmonella infection from imported eggs. In that respect, I ask the Minister, will His Majesty’s Government develop core production standards that will apply to both domestic and imported agri-food products?
Labour shortages have presented challenges, particularly to the fruit and vegetable industries, but innovations in mechanisation and precision farming with the use of autonomous machines and drones are increasingly compensating and mitigating the labour position.
An essential element of food security, as has been mentioned by a number of noble Lords, is the affordability of a healthy diet for our population. But it is often not recognised that the UK population average expenditure on food is as low as 11% of disposable household income and has remained between 10% and 12% for the last 20 years, excluding Covid, while for the lowest income 20% of households, it is around 14%. Looking at historical trends, these are low levels compared to those we had in the 1950s, and so on.
In summary, our farmers and the food supply chain have proved extremely successful and resilient in maintaining an adequate availability of healthy food at affordable prices in recent times. But the threats, as demonstrated this year, warn us that further and probably greater challenges lie ahead. Agriculture desperately needs the consistent backing and support of government to maintain the food security to which the UK population has been accustomed and which it expects.