Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for this timely and important debate. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord Trees, and the other noble Lords who have spoken with such knowledge and insight today.
Food security is clearly essential to the well-being—indeed, the survival, as the noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, said—of this and every other nation. It is something that, in our globalised world, we have taken for granted for too long. It is especially timely when one considers the increasing geopolitical threats we face, with all the dislocation and turbulence that they could bring to food security, as well as what emergency planners might call the slow rising tide of climate change.
We discuss food security at the same time the country faces the most dangerous and volatile international situation since World War II. Europe is rearming at a variable pace, led by Poland and Germany, but it is rearming none the less. There is a superpower arms race in AI and compute, with all the risks, known and unknowable, which that entails, including the risk of new bioweapons, which has been much reported. Alongside this geopolitical landscape, the impact of climate change continues, with all the demands that will place on agriculture and food production, as so many noble Lords have mentioned.
As has been said, today the UK imports just over 40% of our food, with by far the largest element—around three-quarters of total imports—coming from mainland Europe. Our level of food imports places the UK among the least self-sufficient developed nations in food production. We have been here before. In 1939, the UK imported 70% of the food required to sustain the population—which was then 50 million—and much of that came from the Empire. Some data suggests that imports were responsible for nearer 90% of the total calorie intake—a remarkable sum. This reliance on imported food became a strategic vulnerability when German U-boats attacked merchant shipping in the Battle of the Atlantic, threatening supplies of grain, meat, sugar and other essentials. Incidentally, that was a battle in which my uncle, Able Seaman David McGroarty, serving in the Royal Navy, died aged 19.
The best-known element of the government response was called Dig for Victory, which encouraged people to cultivate gardens, allotments and unusable land to grow vegetables. However, much more importantly, farmers were encouraged to switch production to grow wheat, potatoes and other crops rather than maintain pasture for livestock. Mechanisation, including a greater use of tractors, helped compensate for labour shortages. The Government transformed how food production and consumption were managed. They exercised extensive control over agriculture through guaranteed prices, subsidies, compulsory cropping requirements and the direction of farming resources.
Food rationing—which was mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Teverson; I was not alive at the time—ensured that scarce supplies were distributed more fairly and reduced waste. Scientific advances improved farming techniques and more intensive land use contributed to higher output. I do not suggest that exactly the same thing would or should happen now, but, as has been mentioned, we do not have to look far for examples of where conflict can bring to a halt the shipping of essential global commodities. Today, things can be halted by much cheaper and more agile autonomous boats, drones, submersibles, et cetera.
Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 caused a major shock to global food supplies. Ukraine was and is one of the world’s most important exporters of wheat, maize, sunflower oil and other commodities. The invasion disrupted production, blocked ports, damaged infrastructure and made shipping through the Black Sea dangerous. The result was not only a shortage of food worldwide but higher prices and reduced access to affordable food, especially for poorer countries, some of which had sourced over 80% of their wheat from Ukraine prior to the invasion.
Given our disproportionate reliance on food imports, I, like the noble Lord, Lord Smith, would like reassurance that contingency plans are in place for how we would respond to systemic shocks to those imports. The threat is real, and we need to plan accordingly.
As has been mentioned, climate change will also require a major rethink of UK food production and whole-system change. One obvious example is the viability of grass as animal feed in a warming climate and the impact of that on livestock production. We need only to think back a few months to those images of a scorched Hyde Park to understand the impact climate change is having.
Over time, different sources of protein may be required, all of which, as has been mentioned, will require producers, retailers and consumers to work together. New technology today might mean gene editing rather than tractors, but I am optimistic, as our agricultural sector has seen whole-system change at pace before and may have to do again.
Before I conclude, I will raise one other issue which impacts upon both geopolitical risk and climate change: our sovereign capacity to produce ammonia, the essential element in the production of fertiliser and in what the defence industry calls energetics—what noble Lords and I would call explosives. In 2021, the then Government allowed the only ammonia production plant in the UK to close, citing market forces. This was not long after the same Government allowed one of our last virgin steel-making plants—also in Teesside—to close, but that is another story.
The ammonia plant based in Billingham in Teesside still produces fertiliser, but since 2021, it has been entirely dependent on ammonia produced in and imported from the USA. To repeat, the UK no longer has sovereign capability in the production of one of the most important base chemicals—an essential ingredient to both food security and national security.
I have two questions for my noble friend the Minister. Do the Government have a live and active contingency plan for how they would respond to major disruptions to food imports to this country caused by major geopolitical shocks? Are those plans kept up to date? Are they active or under review? Is there a plan to restart ammonia production in the UK, and if so, what are the timescales for that? I look forward to the Minister’s response.