L

Lord Docherty of Milngavie (Non-Afl)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Leigh of Hurley, and so many other noble Lords, especially those who have made their excellent maiden speeches today. Several noble Lords have mentioned growth; persistent low growth is this country’s major economic problem. In the 40 years up until the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, UK growth averaged just over 2.5% per year. That means the economy doubles in size every 30 years or so, doubling with each generation. Since 2008, the economy has grown at just over 1% per year on average, meaning that the economy doubles in size every 70 years or so, or once in a lifetime. This collapse in growth defines our standard of living. It is the position the Government inherited, and it is the backdrop against which this and future Budgets must be made. As the Minister said in his opening remarks, good growth in every postcode is this Government’s central mission. The Government recognise that, in order to achieve this, we will have to do things differently. To quote the Treasury itself, we need to fundamentally rewire the state. I welcome the commitment in the Budget to introduce, for the first time in my lifetime, meaningful fiscal devolution. The noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, and my noble friend Lord Watson of Invergowrie raised this. Devolution in England is not a new idea; Bruce Millan’s report, Renewing the Regions, made the case over 30 years ago to “devolve power away from an overly centralised bureaucracy”. The Labour Government of 1997 introduced regional development agencies and established the Greater London Assembly and the office of the Mayor of London. In 2004, I enthusiastically campaigned for a north-east assembly and a referendum—an enthusiasm that, it is safe to say, was not shared by the voters of the north-east. That was all the work of John Prescott, Lord Prescott, who was in so many ways ahead of his time. He passionately believed in devolving power, to have decisions made closest to the people affected by them. Yet this belief has been successfully resisted across Whitehall for decades. It has been Treasury orthodoxy to control from the centre, yet even the Treasury concedes that, today, the UK is one of the most centralised economies in the developed world. The announcement in the Budget of fiscal devolution is a landmark for England. It gives mayoral authorities revenue and flexibility that should, if properly administered, incentivise local economic growth. There are three principal elements to fiscal devolution in the Budget, only one of which is actual fiscal devolution. Sharing tax revenues, welcome as that is, is not quite the same as devolving tax-raising powers. The Budget allows for a visitor levy to be raised directly by mayoral authorities. It will also assign a portion of the basic rate of income tax raised in an area to the same authorities, putting their budgets on a stable and long-term footing. It will also increase the share of business rates retained in an area, with the aim of 100% being retained by the end of the decade. Crucially, the Government made clear that an equalisation mechanism would be introduced to ensure that areas with historically lower levels of growth will be protected to a degree while—and this is essential—remaining incentivised to share in any economic upside. Similar mechanisms exist and work well in other European countries that have much higher levels of fiscal devolution. Fiscal devolution will present new challenges for mayors and local politicians, who will have to think more about investing over the long term to grow their economies, rather than periodically negotiating the Treasury for grants and administering national programmes locally. There will be experimentation and good ideas can be copied—we have seen that with buses already—and bad ideas can, one hopes, be quickly dropped. It will require a different mindset, but it presents a real opportunity. The legendary investor Charlie Munger once said: “Show me the incentives and I will show you the outcome”. He was right. In conclusion, I believe that the commitment to fiscal devolution is, unlike some of the comments about the Budget, bold and radical and gives cause for optimism. Someone once said that devolution is a process and not an event. That process has picked up speed. The Chancellor and my noble friend the Minister are to be congratulated.

More from Lord Docherty of Milngavie (Non-Afl)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.