Contribution
My Lords, I also welcome the maiden speeches so eloquently given in this debate. I do not think I agree with anything that any of the maiden speakers actually said, but I particularly welcome that they chose to make their maiden speeches in this debate, because I welcome all noble Peers who want to debate the economy and fiscal matters—so congratulations and thanks to them.
I suppose, in many ways, the best that can be said about this Budget is that, well, it was not as bad as the last two, when the previous Labour Chancellor frankly wreaked havoc on the economy. We are still reeling from the unnecessary increases in national insurance, and many are suffering from the retrospective changes to impose inheritance tax on what we were told were IHT-exempt savings. That was inexcusable.
The change in the Labour regime also allowed the opportunity for this Government to distance themselves from the disasters of the past and, in particular, remove the hated APR and BPR changes which are doing so much damage for so little gain—less than £500 million. I can tell the House that I am specifically aware of businesses—plural—of quite some size that are now planning an exit because they cannot see any other way of paying the BPR when it is due from minority shareholders on their demise. So, they are going to sell their businesses, and the buyers will almost certainly be from abroad. Thus, there will be a huge loss to the Treasury in the long term for very small, short-term immediate gains.
The Government talk about breathing space. I think breathing is actually about the only thing they have not taxed in this Budget and the last ones. They have taxed everything else: pensions, family businesses, even staying in a local UK hotel. However, I do have empathy with the Minister, because I have reached the age when people stand up for me on the London Underground, and it is incredibly irritating. I am tempted to tell them that I have run 20 miles that week—but I do not, I just gracefully decline it.
This Budget confirms the view, expressed by the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, that the Government do not regard employers as working people. Outrageous. The working people I know are bitterly disappointed with a reduction in business asset disposal relief. It reinforces the view that the Government are simply looking after those people in salaried employment, protected by unions, who never take a risk with their own cash to start a new business and take a chance.
To be fair, I naturally welcome the direction of travel implied by the founders’ relief. But, typically, it is wrapped up with so many conditions that it is unlikely that very many businesses will be eligible. For some strange reason, the Government believe this will cost £260 million in the first year and then drop to £180 million. Can the Minister explain the numbers? I am going to leave the detailed criticism to my noble friend Lord Massey.
The noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, focused on SMEs, and I welcome the opportunity for consultation on this proposal, to avoid it falling into the same traps as EIS and SEIS have fallen into. I am disappointed that no attempt was made to reform EIS and SEIS significantly. It would be great if it could be made easier for companies and individuals to obtain relief. Is the Minister aware that many of the restrictions currently on the EIS scheme stem from EU regulation, because the EU regarded EIS and SEIS as state funding? So, now we are no longer a member of the EU, could we look to lift those restrictions, and is he planning to have another look at them?
On the subject of capital gains, does he recognise that, with frozen income tax thresholds, there is essentially a tax rise here? It is disappointing that the Government do not seek to reform capital gains tax to respect the effect that inflation has on it. For example, if somebody purchased an asset in 2012 for £100,000 and it is now worth £150,000, they have made a 50% taxable gain of £50,000. Yet, inflation for that period was 49%, so the real value of that asset has risen by only £700. But, because they are taxed on the £50,000, it is something like 600% more than the headline 24%. I am sure the Minister is aware of this, and I would be very interested to know whether the Government have plans to address this inequitable taxation.
Finally, he will be aware that the Finance Bill Committee is looking at the proposals in respect of tax administration, so we will come back to that. I have an Oral Question for him in respect of the VAT changes for online retailers; I have concerns about that, and will raise them then.