Contribution
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lady Teather for initiating this all-important debate. I had the privilege of working with her at the other end of the building for many years, and her tenacity in pursuit of something should never be underestimated. I am delighted that she is involved in this issue.
My noble friend outlined, with her usual eloquence, in a comprehensive opening speech, the need for readiness for shocks across the wider food system. Over the summer, with an interest in this issue, I found myself listening to the prepper Mike Chappell. I am not sure that I would relish all his food choices, and the sachets of ex-army rations sound pretty foul. But I guess that is not the point, if you need to have seven days’ worth of food stored in a cupboard. It is certainly pause for thought about how ready any of us are for a significant food shock and the necessity to be ready.
I will concentrate on the producer end and the farmers at the very start of the chain and the crisis that they face now. I am acutely aware that this is a very complex issue that has been covered in many of the brilliant speeches that we heard this afternoon.
Small or large, tenant farmers, family farmers or upland farmers—yes, even Jeremy Clarkson—all farms are facing the worst drought in 50 years. According to the NFU, and I thank it for its briefing, this was the driest July on record in England and Wales. The Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit estimates that for arable farming alone, there was a shortfall of 2.5 million tonnes, costing the industry up to £390 million. As my noble friend Lady Teather said, it may be the worst harvest on record. Four of the five worst have now come within this decade. For livestock farmers, replacing the forage lost to drought cost about £34 million.
We have spoken many times in this Chamber about the cash flow crisis in farming, and that was before this blistering summer. Added to that, as the noble Lord, Lord Trees, outlined, are more than 3,000 bluetongue cases—nearly 2,000 of them in Devon, Cornwall and Somerset—and an avian flu outbreak on the Isle of Lewis that has cost Great Britain its disease-free status. We are facing significant issues. As the Nature Friendly Farming Network warns, next year is now at risk too. With reservoirs this low, farmers will plant only what they can be sure of watering. Potatoes, vegetables and salads are most at risk. Spring crops are being dropped altogether, because the market simply does not pay farmers to carry that level of risk.
The Government’s responses are welcome first steps, with a £15 million water management grant, £50 million through SFI and changes to environmental land management schemes. However, this year’s SFI money ran out in six hours in September, leaving thousands of farmers empty-handed. Support for species-rich grassland has been dropped and, as my colleague in the House of Commons Tim Farron MP pointed out, farmers on common land were locked out altogether just by the software. The Budget on 28 October is a chance to undo the damage that has been done by changes to the agricultural property relief, which my colleague Sarah Dyke MP has rightly called
“an ill-thought-through family farm tax”.—[Official Report, Commons, 12/1/26; col. 693.]
The last Government’s Agriculture Act 2020 was built on the slogan “Public money for public goods”. They are fine words, but that Conservative Government forgot the most important public good of all: food. Instead, they delinked payments from farming altogether, so a landowner received the same cheque whether they grew wheat or grew nothing at all. Scotland, Wales and every other country in the European Union kept backing their farmers to produce food. England alone walked away. That cannot be right. That is why we on these Benches say, as my colleague Tim Farron put it in the House of Commons, that food must be treated as a public good and paid for as one.
We should take up the recommendations to let farmers build reservoirs on their own land without a full planning application, to run the water management grant every year rather than once, and to let the Environment Agency match abstraction to the water that is in the river.
On disease, as discussed by the noble Lord, Lord Trees, we need longer-term investment in the Animal and Plant Health Agency—its labs, vets and surveillance—and farmers need help now with the cost of fallen stock and bluetongue vaccine supply.
Above all, we must pay farmers for growing food, through stronger environmental land management payments, alongside the 75% domestic production target in the good food Bill that my noble friend Lady Teather has described.
Retailers need to share the weather risk in partnership with farmers. Take one family farm in Saint Erth, the story of which was shared with me earlier this year by my noble friend Lord Teverson. Cornish growers have supplied around 90% of the nation’s winter supermarket cauliflowers, yet last winter supermarkets halted their harvest for weeks while stocking Spanish cauliflowers, some under a “Supporting British farmers” banner, and hundreds of acres were ploughed back in. In April, seed for this winter had not even been ordered. That is what happens when retailers carry none of the risk. It means that we need flexible contracts and a Groceries Code Adjudicator with real strength and real teeth.
Farmers in England and Wales deserve a level playing field. On 3 September, the European Union banned Brazilian beef and poultry because of antibiotic growth promoters, which we banned here 20 years ago, but we have not, as yet, followed suit. Our farmers should not be undercut by food that it would be illegal to produce here.
Uncharacteristically, I have only one question for the Minister today. If we are serious about food security, will England, like Scotland, Wales and every country in the European Union, recognise food production in its farm payments? Every farmer in England right now is deciding what to plant for next year, with less water, less money and less certainty than ever. If we fail them, we will all pay the price at the checkout. For the one in eight households already struggling, decent, affordable food will simply be out of reach. Our farmers need an answer and they need it soon.