Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to wind, and I thank my noble friend Lady Teather for bringing forward this important debate and for the forensic clarity with which she set out the issues. I thank all noble Lords who have spoken and note the unanimity across the House and across political parties.
Our food security is national security. The noble Lord, Lord Smith, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Shephard, Lady Foster and Lady Boycott, all made this statement. Somebody said that food on a shelf is not food security, and the noble Lord, Lord Docherty, said that we perhaps have not concentrated on these matters and taken this for granted. I am more worried about our food security now than at any point previously in my lifetime. As many have set out, no single threat explains that: it is the warming climate; wars restricting supply and driving up energy and fertiliser prices; our dependence on food imports; other countries also facing a warming climate, which means that they cannot export to us; our ageing infrastructure; and hostile states probing our food distribution and retail systems. Our food systems might absorb any one of these shocks, but the real danger is the combination of them coming at us together.
My other concern is that the Government appear to be structurally locked into different siloed ways of thinking and planning. Nobody is really taking overall charge of the risks of resilience and adaptation. Many people in this debate have spoken about our warming climate, and Europe is the fastest-warming continent on earth. The UK is warming by about 0.25 degrees per decade. We are seeing both drought conditions and increased rain, as well as increasingly hot, dry summers and wildfires. All that means terrible things for our farmers: flooded fields in winter mean that they cannot plant their crops; then, in the summer, prolonged periods of extreme heat and drought stunt the growth of any crops that do manage to grow.
Our climate seems to be changing faster than our policies can keep up with. Our farmers are struggling to survive against this background, let alone to adapt and thrive. In August, after the driest July on record, Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit analysis suggested that 2026 is on track to be the worst cereal harvest since records began in 1984. As the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, pointed out, even if yields recover, four of our five worst harvests on record will have happened this decade.
The Green Alliance further reports that weather cost English arable farmers more than £800 million last year in lost revenue, and that 60% of our most productive farmland already sits in the highest flood-risk areas. Farmers have faced changing subsidy schemes since the end of Brexit and our small farmers have often struggled to get access to SFI payments. They cannot plan and invest, and we are a long way from where we need to be. On top of that, El Niño is coming this year.
The Government’s national security assessment is stark. It says:
“Without significant increases in UK food system … resilience, it is unlikely the UK would be able to maintain food security if ecosystem collapse drives geopolitical competition for food”.
I welcome the announcement of a new taskforce and research programme, and wonder whether the Minister might give further details on that. Many, including me, have asked for publication of the full report. It is the Government’s right to refuse that. However, the science is well understood, from my point of view, and I do not want arguments about publication to delay progress in dealing with what we know are the consequences and our need to adapt.
Many have talked about rising energy prices, which is also driving up fertiliser costs. The noble Baroness, Lady Foster, talked specifically about a 25.9% increase. The noble Lord, Lord Fuller, talked about fertiliser and the fact that we import 60%. The noble Lord, Lord Docherty, said that we do not have a sovereign ability to produce ammonia. We import 40% of our food and a quarter of it from the Mediterranean, which has also experienced floods and heatwaves and that is causing problems as well. We need to develop less energy-intensive and more nature-friendly farming systems and I warmly welcome the Government’s announcement about organic farming yesterday. The noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, rightly spoke to us about the need for regenerative agriculture and pressed the Government on what more can be done for that and on the need to support small farmers. These are important points.
On “just in time”, the NAO report shows just how far we are from any real food resilience. Food is critical national infrastructure, yet no one food asset sits in the Government’s infrastructure database. Will the Government reconsider that? Half of our food passes through the cold chain, yet the NAO says that Defra lacks detail on its role and on the risks should it fail, as many have said. This week, as has been mentioned, we have seen probing incidents and fridges on the continent cranked up to 52 degrees, destroying God knows how much food. We have had large-scale cyber attacks on M&S and Co-op. Our food distribution and retail systems are under attack from our enemies, and they will face further attacks.
We have had Exercise Mighty Oak probing the impacts of power shortages, and Defra decided that a full emergency food plan was too costly. Only one in seven food exercises are conducted involving the food industry itself. My worry is that Defra is unable to direct business in the event of a food catastrophe. In 2025, it told the Cabinet Office it had very little confidence that cross-government governance was joined up. I know Defra is doing more on this front, but this is an industry worth £148 billion a year. If we compare it with what is being done in terms of energy security, where Ofgem has a budget of £70 billion, it is hard to make the argument that there is any parity given the important role that food plays in our daily survival.
In the words of the NAO, food is largely unregulated. The cybersecurity and resilience Bill excludes food. “Just in time” is not reliable—and I now know that I can partially blame my noble friend Lord Teverson for that. The food industry itself is increasingly raising concerns about food security and its role in developing these “just in time” systems.
Many noble Lords also talked about the cost to families. My noble friend Lord Teverson said that we have self-imposed family rationing and the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Newcastle talked about health, dignity and opportunity. My noble friend Lady Teather talked about the shocking figures from the Food Foundation showing that many low-income households have to spend 85% of their disposable income to meet the Government’s recommended diet. Across all parties, we need to do more to make sure that people have access to good, affordable, nutritious food.
To conclude, I feel that we are too food insecure as a country. I worry that we lack coherent and joined-up policies and, perhaps most importantly, we do not talk about and co-operate on these issues enough as politicians across parties. One thing I have taken away from today, and I come back to it again, is the unanimity of some of the messages that have come across in this debate. We need to talk about it more.
I press the Minister to give serious consideration to setting up a Cabinet Office-led food systems resilience task force and to legislate for a food security and resilience Act, with a duty on government to ensure that the public can be fed in a crisis. The NAO has made some strong recommendations. I press the Minister on whether the Government will accept those. We need to move beyond “just in time”, we need a whole-system approach, and we need radically to stress-test everything.
My understanding is that we have virtually no strategic food reserves, so will the Government seriously consider the need for them and look at that in the round? Our cold-chain systems have been mentioned—they are ageing, they cannot cope with temperatures above 36 degrees and they are highly vulnerable. We need to do more on adaption and to support our farmers with more water storage, methods to diversify their income and support for agrivoltaics. We need more funding and research for our crops of the future that are more climate resilient. We must work across government to do more of these things.
There have been calls for a good food Bill. But I have run out of time, so I will conclude. The warnings from the intelligence community, NAO, Climate Change Committee and others are clear. What is missing is a whole-systems approach, leadership, urgency and funding.