Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for securing this crucial debate. Noble Lords have made important points about the various global threats to our food security, which is, in truth, national security. In these turbulent times, we cannot simply assume that food will always be available on world markets or that imports will always arrive when needed. Therefore, more than ever we must examine how the policies of this Government support British farming and domestic food production.
A recent McCain report found that 77% of farmers surveyed considered government policy to be the biggest threat facing agriculture. Even more worrying, 42% said that they had considered leaving farming in the past year, while 40% questioned whether they would still be farming in 10 years’ time. When four in 10 farmers are contemplating leaving the industry, the Government should ask themselves whether current policies are helping or hindering domestic food production.
Just recently, the Sustainable Farming Incentive scheme, mentioned extensively today, which is not a blanket subsidy to every farmer but supports sustainable farming, closed its application window less than six hours after opening. This meant that eligible farmers, including some facing IT difficulties, simply lost out. Can the Minister explain what financial support is available for sustainable farming practices for those farmers who were unable to access the scheme in time?
On the issue of sustainability, I would stress that we cannot continue to treat agriculture primarily as a pollutant requiring ever greater layers of regulation. British farmers already operate to some of the highest environmental and animal welfare standards in the world. Of course we should farm sustainably, protect our environment and safeguard biodiversity—farmers themselves have the greatest stake in healthy soils, clean water and productive land—but we must also be realistic. We already rely on imports for around 40% of our food. If we continue to burden our farmers with higher costs and lower competitiveness, we do not save the planet; we merely outsource production elsewhere.
I have briefings from various bodies suggesting that we should cut British meat production to reduce the UK’s carbon footprint. For those who imagine that British agriculture can somehow solve global warming on its own, I remind them that China produces around one-third of global carbon emissions, the United States produces around 15%, India produces around 8% and Russia produces around 5%, while the United Kingdom produces less than 1%. If British agriculture produced less beef, lamb, cereals or dairy while global demand remained unchanged, production would not disappear; it would simply move elsewhere. We would then import more food, often produced to lower environmental and welfare standards and transported thousands of miles to get to us. That might improve our domestic carbon accounting but would do little or nothing to reduce global emissions.
We should be particularly cautious about policies that simply export production. Britain has reduced many of its territorial CO emissions, but some of that apparent success reflects the fact that manufacturing has moved overseas and products are imported back into the UK. We must not repeat the same mistake with agriculture. The closure of productive British farms does not necessarily reduce carbon emissions globally; it merely moves them elsewhere.
Rather than forcing food production abroad, we should be supporting our farmers to adapt and become more resilient, as the noble Baroness, Lady Foster of Aghadrumsee, stressed. That includes investment in water infrastructure. Existing reservoirs have been heavily depleted and there is every possibility that we may face another dry spring. The Government have announced funding of up to £15 million for on-farm reservoirs. Can the Minister confirm when the water management grant will reopen this autumn?
What are the Government doing to reduce planning obstacles, which that can make reservoir construction lengthy, expensive and uncertain? I understand that reservoir safety rules are under review. How much additional regulation do the Government envisage, and what size of reservoir will fall within any revised regime? Furthermore, can the Minister reassure the House that the forthcoming water Bill will not treat agricultural water use as an afterthought?
The Government also need a coherent strategy for domestic fruit and vegetable production. The exceptionally hot and dry conditions this year have significantly affected harvest expectations, while depleted reservoirs are already influencing planning decisions for next season. Farmers report that, without confidence in future water supplies, they are less willing to plant irrigation-dependent crops such as potatoes, vegetables and salads. As the noble Lord, Lord Trees, said, we get more rain than we need in this country; we just seem incapable of holding on to it.
If Ministers genuinely wish to improve British food security, increasing domestic horticultural production would be a sensible place to start. That means more water storage, quicker planning approvals for reservoirs, affordable energy for glasshouses and controlled-environment agriculture, and support for investment in modern growing technologies. What specific plans do the Government have to reduce our reliance on imported fruit and vegetables and increase production here at home? It is also vital that we maintain gene editing and do not sell it out to the EU in a new reset.
That brings me to the Government’s broader approach. Food security is not simply what happens on farms; it also involves fertiliser production, food manufacturing, storage, refrigeration, transportation, fuel supplies, digital infrastructure and a trained workforce. The Food Resilience Commission has highlighted that the UK’s food system depends on functioning warehouses, refrigeration networks, cold stores—as noble Lords have rightly pointed out—energy supplies and communications infrastructure. I just wonder what additional cost the new private owners of Northern Foods have faced in the last year in trying to get food to the market.
More than 60% of wholesalers surveyed reported that their existing arrangements could not withstand another summer comparable with that of 2026 without significant additional costs for support. Food has now been recognised as critical national infrastructure. If that designation is to mean anything, it must be reflected in practical government policy and national resilience planning. Food resilience should be treated as a national security priority and not simply as an agricultural issue, as the noble Lord, Lord Smith of Ranmoor, pointed out in a very interesting speech.
When it comes to food and drink manufacturing, the sector supported around 500,000 jobs in 2025 and remains the largest purchaser of British agricultural produce, yet manufacturers face industrial electricity prices significantly higher than those of many international competitors, and we now have some of the highest electricity costs in Europe. At the same time, we continue to reject domestic oil and gas exploration but can approve it, quite rightly, for our Falkland Islands territories.
So what are the Government doing to improve Britain’s competitiveness? Energy costs, fuel costs, employment costs and inflation all continue to pile pressure on food producers and manufacturers. These sectors, alongside our farmers, repeatedly warned Ministers about the cumulative impact of government policy. The Countryside Alliance has identified 27 separate policies since 2024 that rural communities believe have had a detrimental effect on them. To ensure our long-term food security, there must be incentives to farm, and that means businesses must remain profitable. That is not economic rocket science.
The family farms tax directly threatens long-term business viability and reduces the ability of farming businesses to invest in technology, productivity and environmental improvements, and we have already seen evidence that family farms have reduced employment and delayed investment. The former Farming Minister in another place subsequently revealed that he knew nothing about the policy before the 2024 Budget announcement. Why did the Treasury fail to consult the Minister for Farming? I demand a cast-iron assurance from the Minister that the Budget, when it comes, will not repeat that mistake. I am sure she will be able to deliver on that.
What is more, at the Labour Party conference, the parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Nature suggested that the image of rural communities gathered around warm ale in a pub, with a black labrador at their feet, was a far-right vision that never existed. We know that was absolute rubbish from a Labour MP who gave the impression that she had never been out of Felixstowe.
The Minister knows that all over Cumbria—which now has socialist MPs and a Lib Dem—rural people in our hundreds of villages frequent our pubs with an assortment of dogs. They are not full of hate, as Miss Riddell-Carpenter seems to suggest. It seems, as was pointed out by the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, that all those right-wing extremists voted for 160 Labour MPs in rural areas. When rural people hear such bigoted comments, is it any surprise to the Minister that farming communities feel alienated by this Government? I say to my noble friend Lady Shephard of Northwold that there is a certain merit in putting local government in charge of food production and distribution. It will certainly tackle the obesity crisis as we all starve in the future.
Food security cannot be separated from profitability. Farmers cannot invest in environmental improvements, water resilience, new technology and productivity if their businesses are no longer viable. We need sustainable farming, but we also need farming. We need lower emissions, but we cannot avoid simply exporting those emissions abroad. We need environmental stewardship, but we also need food production. Above all, we need a Government who see British agriculture not as a problem to be managed but as a strategic national asset to be supported. If food security is indeed national security, then British farming deserves to be treated as such. I look forward to the Minister’s response.