T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Food Security

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Teather, for securing this very important debate on the growing threats to UK food security, and I thank all noble Lords for their valuable contributions. It has been an important debate, and that is because food security underpins every household’s ability to access affordable and nutritious food. The United Kingdom benefits from a diverse and resilient food system built on strong domestic production, international trade and the expertise of food businesses from right across the supply chain. That resilience has been demonstrated, although challenged, through successive problems including the pandemic, EU exit and international conflicts. Resilience is not a fixed state, of course. Climate change, as we have heard, is placing sustained pressure on production and supply chains; cyber threats are evolving and geopolitical tensions can disrupt energy, transport and the critical inputs on which food production depends. More severe and potentially catastrophic events, including major infrastructure failures, could test the system in ways that previous disruptions have not. What characterises many of today’s risks is that they do not occur in isolation. Climate impacts, cyber incidents, energy disruption, infrastructure failures and geopolitical events can interact and reinforce one another, creating consequences that extend far beyond a single sector or region. The conflict in the Middle East illustrates these interconnections. Its effects on energy and fuel costs, freight routes and agricultural inputs all impact farmers, manufacturers, cold-storage facilities and retailers, even where food is not imported directly from that region. Defra therefore works closely across government and with industry to understand these pressures and to monitor their impacts. Climate change presents perhaps the most significant long-term challenge to our food security. Drought, heatwaves and flooding can affect crops, livestock, water availability and transport networks, and can disrupt production overseas, reducing the availability of alternative sources of supply. These impacts can persist long after the immediate event and can combine with other existing pressures on farm businesses. That is why building resilience remains a central priority. Through the environmental land management scheme, we are helping farmers to improve soil health, strengthen water management and increase resilience to future shocks. In Defra we work closely with farmers, the Environment Agency and the water sector, including through the National Drought Group. Our research and innovation programme supports both a better understanding of risks and the development of practical solutions. Cyber disruption, however, is a growing challenge. Digital systems increasingly connect production, ordering, stock management, distribution and payments through the food chain. An incident affecting a major business or a shared service provider can have consequences right across multiple sectors and communities, even when the food itself remains physically available. Defra has strengthened engagement with industry and is working closely with the National Cyber Security Centre to understand risks, improve resilience and support recovery planning. Exercises and information-sharing are, of course, very important components of that work. My noble friend Lord Smith mentioned that food security is national security, as did others, including the noble Earl, Lord Russell. But he very clearly laid out that food security is about more than food being available nationally. It is about whether people can access and afford the food they need. People’s ability to manage disruption varies according to income, health needs, caring responsibilities, storage space and access to local support. We saw during the pandemic the invaluable role played by local authorities, community organisations and voluntary groups in helping food reach those who needed it most. Through the good food neighbourhoods, we are investing almost £10 million in deprived areas of England to improve access to healthy, affordable food at all times. I stress here that our sector plans will align productivity and growth with health objectives. There is also existing advice on the GOV.UK Prepare website about practical steps that all households can take, and the Cabinet Office is launching a preparedness campaign this autumn. Through our food preparedness group, we are bringing food chain organisations together with local and voluntary partners to clarify responsibilities and agree planning assumptions. Alongside this, we are developing a clearer resilience framework for food. That demonstrates the importance of cross-departmental working, which has been mentioned often in this debate. We continue to work very closely with colleagues responsible for energy, transport and other critical sectors where their resilience is closely linked to the resilience of our food supply. I will try to get through as many questions as I can in the time I have. The SFI closure was mentioned by a number of noble Lords. We are looking at how we can improve the SFI for next year. In doing that, we are continuing to work closely with farmers and stakeholders. We are listening carefully to the experiences that people had this year and learning lessons from that. We are exploring alternatives to a first come, first served application process for the SFI in 2027. The noble Baroness, Lady Grender, asked specifically about payment for production and whether that will be part of it. We will be looking at that in our discussions. Coming back to the point from the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, it is important to note that the SFI is just part of how we are allocating our £11.8 billion of farming funding. There are other funding opportunities; for example, the new expression of interest process that is providing a simpler route into the countryside stewardship higher tier. The noble Baroness, Lady Teather, asked whether the Government would introduce a good food Bill. We recognise that there is a lot of interest in this, and the value of long-term action on food system challenges. We are currently focused on delivering the outcomes of the good food cycle through a range of policy and regulatory partnership approaches. We will look at how we can best achieve the outcomes we want. On that basis, we have not yet made any decisions about bringing in dedicated food legislation. The noble Baroness also asked, as did others, about how we support small and local food producers. We are opening up our public sector supply chains to smaller businesses, and that includes farmers and growers, to help them access markets and support local food economies. We want at least half of our publicly purchased food to be locally produced or certified to high environmental standards. Small farms have an important role to play in that. Fertiliser came up from a number of noble Lords. The noble Baroness, Lady Foster, and the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, asked about fertiliser costs. We recently sought views on the tariff suspensions for agricultural goods, fertilisers and kerosene to help mitigate the consumer impact of the conflict in the Middle East; that consultation closed on 24 June. We are currently reviewing and analysing the responses received to that. We have asked the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board to improve market transparency. Its fertiliser price reporting has now been increased to weekly publication to support farmers’ purchasing decisions. The noble Baroness, Lady Teather, and the noble Earl, Lord Russell, asked how food security fits in with wider national resilience planning. I assure them that Defra is working closely with the Cabinet Office and other departments to ensure that food supply is fully incorporated as part of our emergency preparedness, which includes considering dependencies on other sectors. Defra aligns with cross-government working on risks that could have the biggest impact on the food system. The assessment of the top 10 risks to food supply is reviewed every two years as part of the Cabinet Office’s critical national infrastructure assurance process, and we are working towards the good food cycle, which we announced this year. That is a high-level strategic vision for the food system, with 10 priority outcomes, including greater preparedness of the food supply chain against disruptors. We are doing specific work on that. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, and the noble Lord, Lord Trees, mentioned farm reservoirs. As the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, said, we have announced the water management grant, which will make £15 million available to help farmers and growers build on farm reservoirs. I completely understand the importance of this and the need to move forward on it. The noble Baroness, Lady Grender, mentioned abstraction. Defra and the Environment Agency, with local partners, are conducting a smart abstraction trial in the Upper Cam catchment, using real-time monitoring data and alerts to enable farmers to dynamically abstract water when conditions allow, while protecting river flows during periods of low availability. The early findings are looking quite positive: they suggest the approach can both reduce environmentally damaging abstraction and increase opportunities to abstract and store water, while reducing reliance on the EA’s alerts. We are learning from that pilot, and there will be further announcements on that. The noble Earl, Lord Russell, asked how the Government are responding to the pressure of higher energy costs, and the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, also talked about this. We absolutely recognise the serious pressure that energy prices and wider supply chain disruption have been placing on the food supply chain, and we are working across government to look at potential support measures. In particular, we are assessing the impact of higher gas and electricity prices on the food chain and profitability for farmers and growers. Horticulture is very energy-intensive, so we need to look at those impacts. Defra has been undertaking some detailed work to assess and better understand the food sector’s exposure to rising fuel, fertiliser and energy prices—which are currently a triple whammy on the sector—so we can mitigate the impacts. We are also talking right across government, because, from Defra’s point of view, it is important that the agriculture and food supply sectors are considered in any future energy support measures; we need to get ourselves more plugged into that. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, asked how we are making the case for the sector. We have made, and we will continue to make, the case in government for energy support for the food sector. We recognise that the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero has the leading role on net zero, but we are working very closely with it to press on with that. The noble Baroness, Lady Shephard, asked about stockpiling and who is holding the Government’s food supplies. I assure her that the UK’s approach to food resilience is not reliant on stockpiling, whether by the public or otherwise. We work closely with industry to understand critical supply chains so that we can monitor the risks and strengthen preparedness so that food continues to reach consumers during disruptions. However, we keep these resilience options under review, because we need to make sure that we can manage any difficult situations. It was difficult during Covid, when we suddenly had food shortages; we do not want to go back to that, so we need to learn from those challenges. One of the issues is that the capacity of food storage infrastructure is for individual food businesses, but we work with local authorities—which were mentioned. Local authorities are part of the broader government response to food supply issues: they manage the local response. They do not hold government food stocks, but they are built into our general response. The noble Baroness asked specifically about LGR. I have checked the current position at MHCLG and have been informed that it will be setting out next steps in due course, because it recognises that areas need clarity over their future. Geopolitical shocks came up—the noble Lord, Lord Docherty, particularly asked about geopolitical shocks. We have been looking at home defence planning and, in July, the home defence planning acceleration was announced. That included updating classified government crisis plans, commonly known as the War Book, which is co-ordinated by the Cabinet Office. These plans will be tested through exercise Albiston Shadow in 2027. It will be the largest UK home defence exercise for several decades and will complement NATO’s own exercise, which I am informed is known as CMX27—it all sounds very James Bond, does it not? There is a lot of work going on. In fact, I have been involved in some COBR meetings looking at resilience planning as well. I was pleased that Defra and the importance of its role in resilience, both for water and food, is being recognised. There were a number of questions on the National Audit Office report. My noble friend Lord Smith of Ranmoor, the noble Lord, Lord Docherty, the noble Baroness, Lady Foster, and others asked about this. One thing to say is that the NAO report in fact agrees with our own assessment that risk to food supply is becoming more complex, which is exactly why we are working with farmers and the food and drinks industry to strengthen our food security and resilience. Our food businesses and supermarkets have continued to feed the nation through significant disruptions, but I stress that we are really carefully considering the report’s findings and recommendations as part of our ongoing work to build a more resilient, productive and sustainable food system. These reports are really valuable in informing the work that we carry out in this space. The noble Earl, Lord Russell, asked about timings. The Public Accounts Committee inquiry on the report is currently taking place and senior officials have very recently given evidence to that committee. We will be responding to the NAO report within two months—so, fairly shortly. It will be interesting to see people’s feedback on the response to that report. The noble Baroness, Lady Foster, asked whether the Government are planning a food production duty—not that I am aware of. However, I am more than happy to go back to the department to check and put it in as a suggestion if that is not something that we are looking at. The noble Lord, Lord Teverson, asked a number of questions on marine, seas and fish stocks. I have only three minutes left, so I do not have the time to go into that, unfortunately, but he raises incredibly important points—he is very knowledgeable. If he wants to, I would be really happy to arrange a meeting to sit down and get into the nitty-gritty and detail of this, as I think that that would be really helpful. The noble Lords, Lord Fuller and Lord Trees, asked about the report on profitability by the noble Baroness, Lady Batters, and productivity. Noble Lords will be aware that we have established the Farming and Food Partnership Board, which will bring together people from farming, food, retail and finance to drive profitability. That was one of the recommendations in the Farming Profitability Review by the noble Baroness, Lady Batters. Through that board, we are looking to set out how we can work to drive growth in all sectors, focusing on improving farm productivity and profitability but also, importantly, championing our brilliant homegrown produce and strengthening our national security. That joint government and industry board will explore how to increase our domestic food security as well as the potential of new export markets to boost farming profitability. The noble Lord, Lord Teverson, asked about export. I have recently been given the portfolio of rest-of-world trade in agri-foods and the noble Lord might be interested to know that, last night, I was in fact at a big do with businesses from right around the world to look at how we can work with them to increase our exports into new markets. There is a real appreciation of the standards that we have in Britain, food wise. That is something that I am specifically working on. While we are talking about standards, the noble Lord, Lord Trees, asked about core standards. Defra is always keen to improve standards. I am working with the Farm Minister all the time and with the Secretary of State on the best ways to achieve this. If the noble Lord has particular suggestions he would like to put to us, I am more than happy to hear them. I will have to rattle through quite quickly because time is running out. The noble Lord, Lord Fuller, asked about the fairness of supply chains and contracts. We believe farmers should receive a fair price for their products. We are committed to tackling contractual unfairness wherever it exists. The sector-by-sector approach that has been adopted will enable targeted regulation, which will address specific issues without introducing broad and burdensome regulations right across all sectors. My noble friend Lord Docherty asked about ammonia. We recognise that there is interest in domestic ammonia production. However, because it is so highly energy-intensive and requires significant private investment, our focus is going to be on strengthening the resilience of fertiliser supply chains, supporting innovation and helping farmers with price shocks. Finally, the noble Earl, Lord Russell, asked about publication of the JIC report. They are not routinely published for national security reasons. I think I have to stop now. I thank all noble Lords who spoke in this important debate. I look forward to further contributions on this issue.

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.