Contribution
My Lords, it is a real pleasure and honour to follow my noble friend Lady Aglionby and to congratulate her on a maiden speech that was thoughtful, wise and—I hope the House agrees—rather good fun. I kindly point out that being put at the top of a white-water canyon in a canoe without a paddle worked quite well for Ed Davey, but I recognise that this is not a way to deal with our food security.
My noble friend brings to this House something that we can never have too much of: real, practical, grounded experience. She has spent 30 years in professional practice as a land agent, negotiating on upland commons between people with very different interests. She has done so by building relationships as much as by reading budgets. This is a rare and valuable skill, on which this House will be delighted to draw.
She also holds a PhD in law, so she will be well equipped to scrutinise the legislation that comes before us, and she will, I am sure, hold the Government to account with precision and passion. I must admit that I also admire the fact that she has never left the land behind her and still finds time to be a wild swimmer. She therefore speaks with an authority that cannot be learned from a briefing paper. She is, in the truest sense, a bridge from Cumbria to Westminster, and she represents the important voice of our farmers and our rural communities, who we know will be better heard in this place because of her practical experience.
Her argument today was analytical, logical and persuasive: that warm words are cold comfort without adequate budgets and a working delivery mechanism. A 60% decline in the payments that our farmers and landowners receive is something that must be changed. I hope the Minister will listen carefully to her call for the 0.3%. I know she will be productive and powerful here as a campaigner for the environment, nature and the land management changes we so desperately need in these times of increasing uncertainty. I wish her well in this place and I hope that she continues to live adventurously. I also pay tribute to all the other noble Lords making their maiden speeches today.
Turning to the Budget, I will focus on energy, climate and the cost of living. It is a Budget of small measures, temporary reliefs and short-term savings when what we require is a serious, detailed, long-term plan. Brent crude is up 60% and UK gas prices are up nearly 200%. Fossil fuels are proving yet again that they are volatile in price and insecure in supply. The OBR tells us that higher energy prices have pushed inflation to 3.5%. Real households will feel that economic pain, colder homes and even greater energy debt.
The Chancellor’s principal response is £2.6 billion for payments of £100 to households in council tax bands A to D—a breathing space for 20 million, as the Minister put it. This will help, but it is blunt and poorly targeted. It is too small to meet the scale of the problem, yet broad enough to reach many households that do not require the support, while many people in genuine fuel poverty are left without enough. A one-off payment will not protect households from the next shock.
Removing VAT from domestic energy bills until July 2027 is welcome, though it is worth only £45 a year. Abolishing the gas standing charge is the most significant, and a lower electricity-to-gas price ratio is essential if families are to choose heat pumps and electric vehicles. I ask the Minister to confirm what safeguards will protect fuel-poor households who cannot reduce their usage.
There are too many contradictions in this Budget. The Government say they want cheaper energy and clean power, yet they have cut many of those very programmes. The warm home plan loses out by at least £1 billion. Funding for the boiler upgrade scheme is held at £400 million rather than growing as planned. Carbon Brief estimates that this could mean around 100,000 fewer heat pumps over the next three years. At the same time, VAT on solar heat pumps, batteries and insulation rises from zero to 5%. The Government are raising upfront costs just as they withdraw the grants. The new warm homes loan scheme is welcome, but loans are no substitute for grants for lower-income households.
The response on the net-zero emissions vehicle mandate is delayed, amid briefings that it may be watered down. If that is the case, it would be the single most damaging decision this Government have taken on climate change. It is the biggest lever this Government hold, and it is working to support UK jobs and growth. It is a mandate, not a request. I call on the Government to hold firm. We should be making clean transport cheaper, not preserving subsidies for petrol while taxing clean forms of transport.
I welcome the Prime Minister’s announcement at COP of the world’s first special representative for climate security. This summer, we saw extreme heat, drought and wildfires, 2,877 heat-associated deaths in England, 1,700 schools closed and an economic cost of £4.4 billion, yet this Budget offers no serious national programme for resilience, homes, cooling or public health preparedness. This is a health and national security issue. We need to fund a national retrofit programme, delivered through councils and mayors, aimed at first-time, low-income and poorly insulated homes. We need faster grid connections, simpler planning and market reforms that reward clean and homegrown power.
The Chancellor speaks of a new course on energy, but that must be backed by coherent policy. This Budget salami-slices programmes that would reduce bills and emissions while preserving dependencies that keep bills high. Our case is simple: support households now, but target that support at those who need it most with our essential energy guarantee; invest in insulation, heat pumps, solar and grid infrastructure; reform the energy market so that clean power lowers bills; and give investors certainty.