Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Earl, Lord Russell. We are blessed in this debate to have four maiden speeches. I am delighted to have listened to two of them and look forward to the remaining two.
I want to say a word or two about the noble Baroness, Lady Ussher. I am sorry that she is not in her place to hear them. It is always good when someone says something nice about you if you are there in person, but I am sure that she will have the chance to read it afterwards. She was in the House of Commons from 2005 to 2010, which was my first term in the House of Commons. I saw her in action as a Treasury Minister, and I thought her speech today demonstrated her enormous experience from that role and her considerable economic experience in a number of roles since. I am sure she is going to make a tremendous contribution to the House.
My noble friend on the Front Bench, Lady Neville-Rolfe, in the time she had, was able to set out a comprehensive critique of the Budget. I agreed with everything she said, so it is not necessary for me to repeat much of it.
There are a couple of points I want to focus on. Budgets are fiscal events, front and centre, and that means we should judge them on their tax and spending measures. The Treasury and the Chancellor seem to be very cross that people are judging the Budget on the tax and spending measures, but that is fundamentally what a Budget is. The IFS came to the conclusion that the tax and spending measures were minimal and are not going to make a significant difference.
The other big opportunity you have in a Budget as a Chancellor is to drive forward significant supply-side reforms that are going to improve the performance of the economy and drive up growth rates. I am afraid there were none of them either. The Budget was a big missed opportunity. It kicked into the future decisions on welfare, social care and defence. Those were missed opportunities. If you are a new Prime Minister, as Andy Burnham is, with a significant majority, my experience is that you need to take those decisions early because they take time to come to fruition.
The key thing I want to talk about is where we go in our relationship with the European Union. I am afraid I draw the opposite conclusion from that set out by the noble Lord, Lord Liddle. If we look at the growth figures today and the growth in the economy this year, the fastest-growing sector has been information and communication. The OBR itself says that a lot of that is driven by investment in artificial intelligence and related industries. That says to us that the debate about the EU is in great danger of being backward-looking, looking at the industries of the past rather than the industries of the future. If this country is to have high growth, we will have to be successful in those industries of the future.
I will give one example. On artificial intelligence, the regulatory regime that we have chosen in the UK is one much more likely to deliver fast growth in artificial intelligence and fast economic growth as a result. The EU has taken, as it does in many areas of policy, a much more risk-averse, anti-growth policy framework. If we are to get closer to the European Union, we will end up regulating artificial intelligence closer to its model rather than to the much more successful model that we have. That will set growth backwards. There may be advantages to be gained from industries of the past, those that are not fast-growing, and we may get some economic gains there, but any economic gains in those areas will be dwarfed by the gains we will miss out on by regulating areas of the economy that will be fast-growing in the future.
The final thing I want to say—again, this is connected to the Government’s European Union approach—is about unemployment, particularly for younger people. My noble friend on the Front Bench referred to the OBR’s forecast for unemployment going up. The big issue of today and the next week will be Alan Milburn’s report about NEETs. It seems to me that the Government have made two policy choices that make that more difficult: they put up employers’ national insurance contributions, particularly hitting hospitality and retail, the sectors of the economy that employ younger people; and they have put £5 billion of costs on businesses through the Employment Rights Act. Then there is the impact of the youth mobility scheme, which is a terrible idea. If we sign up to a scheme that will potentially see up to 100,000 young people coming to the United Kingdom from Europe, there is no way that it will help get British young people back into work.
The Government are therefore in great danger of having a backward-looking European Union policy that will damage our economic growth prospects and the unemployment rate, and will not deliver the economic growth prospects for the future that all of us in this House want to see.