L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

Very good. That is perhaps slightly better, but it does not make the argument any more compelling. The central bit that is completely missing—I am sure the Minister will say this—is the fact that the Government and the public sector do not have an infinite supply of capital. In the real world, the one we live in, the Government have choices about borrowing money and what they spend it on. I am afraid that if we adopted the model that the noble Baroness set out, the railway rolling stock would be competing for taxpayer-funded government capital against the capital available to build schools, hospitals and other public assets. The evidence from the past is that trains are not the winners in those competitive processes, which is exactly why we had privately financed rolling stock in the first place. When we had privatisation—I see my noble friend Lord Young nodding—we had massive investment in new rolling stock and better and more modern trains, which would never have happened if it had all been funded by taxpayer-funded capital. The reason for the returns that the noble Baroness talked about—she cited ASLEF’s figures on the money “extracted”—is the fact that capital has a cost. To access capital, you have to pay for it. There is a risk attached to it, and that has to be paid for by somebody: either the private sector taking these risks or the taxpayer. You cannot just wish it away. The noble Baroness is right in saying that the Secretary of State had in her party-political conference speech a throwaway line about looking at this. However, I suspect—I may be wrong—that a small number of people in the department are doing a bit of work, the conclusion of which, in due course, will be that they are going to stick with the current model, and that that will be slipped out quietly, as opposed to the party-political announcement to cheer up the Labour troops at conference. I do not expect the Minister to comment on that either way, but I suspect that that is what happened and I would not put too much weight on there being a solution that requires the taxpayer to fund it all. Finally, I have to confess that I have not spent lot of time on Clause 95, which is the subject of a stand part notice, but when I had a look at the two things that the noble Baroness refers to, they sounded like a fantastic idea. The Cape Town convention gets rid of legal inconsistency, lowers costs and has good insolvency protections for mobile assets, which seems a very good thing to do. I am amazed that she is against the Luxembourg rail protocol, because it establishes a global legal framework to make it easier and cheaper to finance trains, trams and other railway equipment, thus making it more likely that we can invest and shift people from roads to rail, supporting the green transition and net-zero goals. I would have thought that the noble Baroness would be in favour of all those things. Clause 95 should absolutely stay in the Bill, and I hope that that is what the Minister says when he responds.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.