Hansard·Grand Committee·Vol. 860

Railways Bill

Monday, 26 October 2026

237 contributions17 members

Contributions

  1. Committee (7th Day)

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Scottish and Welsh legislative consent sought . Relevant document: 4th Report from the Delegated Powers Committee .

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Debate on A mendment 2 66 resumed .

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Clause 70: Access rights

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, since we were interrupted, on account of continuing and starting a new group, quite unnecessarily given the pressure of business that faces us today, I thought that it would be helpful if I gave some summary of what the debate was when we met last Wednesday. My noble friend Lord Lansley raised important questions of how the existing 2016 access regime will apply to infrastructure managers outside Great British Railways. He left the Minister with a specific question. He said: “With this amendment, all I am looking for is the Minister to say, ‘There is no further intention than to apply the existing 2016 approach to infrastructure managers other than GBR’ ”.—[ Official Report , 21/10/26; col. GC 336.] That is the question that the Minister was left with and I hope very much that he will answer it when he gets to his reply. My noble friend Lord Grayling, supported by my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe, focused on the breadth of the powers in Clause 71 and the risk that existing access rights could be altered in ways that go beyond what is genuinely necessary to transition to the new structure. The powers are drafted extremely broadly. I think that I am correct in recalling that my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe also made a point about the chilling effect on private sector investment in the railways, on which we will continue to be dependent as a result of the possible arbitrary exercise of these extremely broad powers. The noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, rightly emphasised the importance of independent assessment of capacity, while my noble friend Lord Harper drew attention to the significant long-term investment decisions made by open access operators and to the concerns of the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee about the breadth of these powers and the level of parliamentary scrutiny attached to them. My noble friend again set a specific question to the Minister: “if the Government’s intention, as set out in their memorandum to the Delegated Powers Committee, is genuinely that these are to be used only to make existing agreements work under the new structure, why are the Government taking powers that go much further? ”.—[ Official Report , 21/10/26; col. GC 340.] Again, I look forward to hearing the Minister respond to that. I have only one amendment in this group, to which I now turn, which is that Clause 71 do not stand part of the Bill. The explanation for it is very simple. The argument rests entirely on the arguments already made by my noble friends and the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley. We have simply chosen different methods to probe the effect of the clause. They have chosen to do so by amending the powers that the Government are seeking for themselves. I have chosen to do so simply by deleting the whole cause. The purpose is to provoke a discussion and to hear from the Minister why these egregious powers should be sought by the Government, so that we can consider, before we return on Report, amending them more precisely so as to narrow their effect and remove the threat to the private operation of railways that hangs so unhelpfully in the air.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. The Minister of State, Department for Transport (Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill) (Lab)

    My Lords, I turn first to Clause 71. In response to the opposition from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, I begin by setting out why this power is needed. The Government have been clear that they intend to honour the existing Schedule 5 rights—for clarity, these are contractual rights to access specific routes on the network—and the existing charging determination set by the ORR for the remainder of this control period to 2029. The purpose of the power at Clause 71 is therefore not to remove those rights but to ensure that existing contracts remain operable once responsibilities for access and charging transfer to Great British Railways and the framework comes into force. Many existing contracts contain provisions that, for example, rely on functions currently carried out by the Office of Rail and Road. Without a mechanism to update those provisions, operators would be left with contracts that no longer work as intended, creating legal uncertainty and operational risk across the network. This would place significant financial risk on businesses, as inoperable contracts could result in an inability to run services or to make changes to those services. For those reasons, Clause 71 is a necessary part of delivering the new railway framework. Network Rail has already begun engaging with operators on these contracts, with the intention of agreeing the precise changes that must be made. This is an essential process that will be handled collaboratively and openly from the outset. I turn to Amendments 267 to 271. Amendment 267 would focus the power specifically on facilitating the transfer of infrastructure management functions currently performed by Network Rail to Great British Railways. While some necessary modifications may indeed be connected to the transfer of functions, others are required for different reasons. For example, existing contracts contain references to the ORR’s functions, industry codes and processes that will no longer operate in the same way under the new arrangements. These are legitimate purposes for regulations but would be outside the scope allowed by the noble Lord’s amendment. Network Rail is consulting with existing contract holders to establish precisely what amendments may be required across the several hundred existing contracts that will need to be updated to operate under the new framework. It would therefore be undesirable to constrain the power in a way that could prevent necessary changes from being made.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Grayling (Con)

    My Amendment 267 is in this group. I understand the point that the Minister is making. Will he then bring back a government amendment on Report that circumscribes the limitation on the use of this clause to prevent, as I highlighted in my speech, a future Minister—I am not casting any aspersions on the Minister himself, but he may not be always there—from simply saying, as would be possible from my reading of the legislation, that, as part of the transition to Great British Railways, there is not enough space on the west coast main line and therefore they are going to reduce the number of open access operators? Will he bring forward an amendment that makes it not possible for a Secretary of State to take that decision?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    The answer is that I will not guarantee to do such a thing but I will reflect, between now and Report, on all the discussions that we are having on these amendments. As I said, Network Rail is consulting with existing contract holders to establish precisely what amendments may be required across the several hundred existing contracts that will need to be updated to operate under the new framework. It would therefore be undesirable to constrain the power in a way that could prevent necessary changes from being made. Inoperable contracts do not benefit anyone. My noble friend Lord Berkeley also seeks to limit this power though Amendments 268A, 268 and 269. However, a restriction based on broad and undefined concepts such as the “nature of the bargain” risks creating uncertainty and disputes about whether necessary amendments fall within the scope of the power. We should not allow restrictive drafting to undermine changes agreed to by all the parties. Clearly, that could risk frustrating the very transition that the power at Clause 71 is intended to facilitate. Likewise, imposing an unduly strict test of necessity, as under Amendment 268, would hamper the purpose of the clause, which is to ensure a smooth transition to the new access regime. A test of necessity would also risk creating legal dispute and uncertainty as to whether a particular change is strictly necessary or merely desirable. On Amendment 269, a number of existing access contracts extend into the mid and late 2030s, far beyond the start of the next funding period in 2029, as proposed in this amendment. It is therefore important that sufficient time is available to ensure that contracts can continue to function effectively throughout their lifetimes. A shorter sunset period could result in the power expiring before issues affecting longer contracts have been fully resolved. On Amendment 271, the Government strongly support engagement with industry, and, as I have mentioned, extensive consultation is already taking place. Network Rail is currently consulting on draft model access contracts and the future industry codes. Given that that extensive programme of engagement and consultation is currently live and in the public domain, we do not consider it necessary to impose retrospectively a separate statutory consultation requirement in Clause 71 itself, because it is already happening. The final amendment that looks to restrict this power is Amendment 270, from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. I am pleased to reassure her that the effect she seeks is already achieved by the Bill as drafted. Clause 71 applies only to access agreements and access rights “so far as the agreements or rights have effect in relation to GBR infrastructure”. The scope of the power is therefore already limited to those agreements and rights affected by the transition to the new GBR access and charging framework. As a result, the power cannot be used to amend access agreements that relate to non-GBR infrastructure. Those agreements will therefore continue to operate unamended under the existing framework. I hope that the noble Baroness is reassured by this. Turning to Amendment 340, from the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, the Government consider the negative procedure to be most appropriate in this case, because any future use of the power would be to make necessary technical changes to ensure that existing contracts remain operable under the new access framework established by the Bill. I reiterate that the power will not be used to alter the substantive access rights that operators currently hold. It is included purely to give effect to the discussions that are already ongoing between Network Rail and operators regarding the necessary amendments of contracts to ensure that they remain operable in the new framework brought forward by the Bill. The Government therefore consider that the negative procedure provides the appropriate degree of parliamentary oversight for regulations where the purpose is to operationally implement this transition. Finally, I turn to Amendment 266, from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley. He is right that the Bill revokes Regulation 5(8) of the access and management regulations, which places a duty on infrastructure managers to ensure that a train operator’s right to access their network is honoured. Although GBR will not be an infrastructure manager for the purposes of these regulations, the regulations will continue to apply to non-GBR infrastructure managers. I agree with the noble Lord that retaining this duty for non-GBR infrastructure is important and that its effect should be retained in those regulations. The Bill already achieves the noble Lord’s objective, because Clause 70 amends Regulation 5(1) to make it clear that it is the infrastructure manager who is required to grant access rights. As a result, Regulation 5(8) is no longer needed, because its effect will instead be achieved in the amended Regulation 5(1). For completeness, I emphasise that the existing right of appeal to the Office of Rail and Road in Regulation 5(9) also remains unaffected by the Bill, providing a clear right of recourse for operators if an infrastructure manager who is not GBR sought to deny access to any operator in contravention of Regulation 5. I thank noble Lords for their discussion on this topic. I believe that aspirations are aligned here, as nobody wants inoperable contracts or to remove the rights that operators have been legitimately granted to run trains on the network. The power is essential to make the railway work in the future and that is why I am defending it. It will not be misused. The Government have put that on record in a number of ways, including in this speech today. I hope that this will allow noble Lords not to press their amendments.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, the Minister has spoken as if this power were there to be used when there is agreement among all affected parties that some change is necessary for the purpose of efficiency. Do I understand that correctly? If I do, is he saying that the power will not be used if any of the affected parties—that might be only one of them—objects to the exercise of the power in the way proposed?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    The Government’s intention in this is certainly to obtain agreement, because everybody will want these things to work. However, it is important for the Government to retain some power for those who will not agree, for reasons that one would hope would be sensible, at least to them, but which, in the Government’s view, will not enable the regulations to work. Obviously, the Government would seek to have agreement, but the power is there to be used if agreement is not forthcoming.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Lord Moylan (Con)

    The Minister has made it clear that the powers can be used coercively against parties who do not wish to see them put into effect. If, in those circumstances, there was an instance where the affected party could demonstrate that they had or would suffer financial loss as a result, what power do the Government have to pay compensation, or is it expected that there would be no financial compensation for having a position imposed on one which was both unwanted and expensive?

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    For the very great part, this provision is designed to get agreement, so that things that are already happening continue to work. In the event that there is a case for financial compensation, my understanding is that the Bill allows for that.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, I hate to press the Minister, but, since he has continued the conversation, would he just point to the clause which allows that, because I may have missed it?

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    It is Clause 71(2)(d), I believe.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Lord Lansley (Con)

    My Lords, it is not yet five days since I moved Amendment 266. It was a very simple probing amendment, to which the Minister has given, happily, the reply that I sought, which is that the duties continue for infrastructure managers in the same way as they have under the 2016 regulations; it is just that GBR will not be treated as an infrastructure manager for these purposes. Before I beg leave to withdraw, I just leave this with the Minister—I do not expect him to answer now. From reading this and the continuing definition of a railway undertaking—which, of course, includes GBR and its subsidiary companies for the purposes of the 2016 regulations—I was struck by something. Say, for example, that HS1 has to give access rights to GBR, if it seeks them. Is there any limitation? Where is the limitation on GBR’s activity, for example, in running international passenger services? I leave that question, because I am prompted to ask it now. Subject to that, I thank the Minister for his response and I beg leave to withdraw Amendment 266.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Amendment 266 withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Clause 70 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Clause 71: Operation of existing agreements and rights

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Amendments 267 to 271 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Clause 71 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Clause 72: Regulations about non-GBR infrastructure, facilities and services

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Amendment 272

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  24. 272: Clause 72, page 42, line 5, leave out subsection (1) and insert— “(1) The Secretary of State may by regulations amend, revoke, restate or replace provisions of the 2016 Regulations so far as those provisions relate to—(a) the management and operation of non-GBR infrastructure,(b) rights to operate trains between places using non-GBR infrastructure,(c) co-operation and co-ordination between Great British Railways, GBR companies and persons who manage or operate non-GBR infrastructure,(d) the provision and supply of facilities and services which facilitate the operation of trains, or(e) competition in the market or markets for the provision and supply of such facilities and services.(1A) Regulations under subsection (1) may not make provision except in connection with the amendment, revocation, restatement or replacement of provisions of the 2016 Regulations.”Member’s explanatory statement This amendment would limit the regulation-making power in Clause 72 to the amendment, revocation, restatement or replacement of provisions of the Railways (Access, Management and Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations 2016 relating to non-GBR infrastructure, facilities and services.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Lord Harper (Con)

    Before I start talking about my amendments, I will comment on the previous group. The Minister said that Clause 71(2)(d) covers the payment of compensation, but the subsection says that the regulations “may” provide for the payment of compensation, which means that, if the regulations do not provide for that—it does not say that they have to—there would not be a mechanism to pay the compensation. We had a conversation at an earlier stage about whether the regulations “must” provide for that, but they only “may”. I think that is the gap that my noble friend Lord Moylan referred to. I have Amendments 272, 273, 274, 276 and 279 in this group. I will run through all of them briefly. The Minister, helpfully, wrote to me this morning. The private office sprayed out some letters this morning—I had seven. I have not had a chance to look at all of them, but I have looked at the one relevant to this clause. It deals well with a concern that I did not have, about whether this clause could be used, effectively, to nationalise non-GBR infrastructure. I think, from the conversation we had and certainly from what I will set out now, that the concern is a bit more nuanced than that but none the less important. I will set that out in due course. Part of the reason for this concern is that the Prime Minister keeps saying that he is very much in favour of public control of various businesses, without necessarily going through all the palaver of nationalising them and paying people lots of compensation. He does not really spell out what he means by public control. Therefore, he cannot be enormously surprised that, when businesses hear the leader of the Government say that he is quite keen on taking public control of things, they naturally think he is quite keen on taking control of their things without paying proper compensation, which he would have to do if he nationalised them. That is the context in which businesses are, perfectly legitimately, concerned. The concern about Clause 72, which refers to non-GBR infrastructure, facilities and services, is about the risk of open-ended interventions taking place after companies have taken investment decisions. If you do not address that it will change the climate in which companies make investment decisions. On earlier clauses, we talked about what I think is a shared concern on all sides of the Committee: we want to see private sector investment in rail infrastructure—I see the Minister nodding. The danger is that the clause, as drafted, will put that at risk. That is certainly the understanding that a number of private businesses have. I will set out what those concerns are and then run through the amendments. I will then move the lead amendment, Amendment 272. For many of the investments that people carry out, such as rail freight terminals, a model is set up under which rail freight companies pay per train, and the charges are set to recover the capital over a period and cover the ongoing maintenance and life cycle risks. Clause 72, as drafted, creates a risk that the Secretary of State could intervene in that pricing or access policy after the decision has been taken. For example, the clause talks about the “terms, conditions and charges” that people may make “for the use of non-GBR infrastructure and for the provision and supply of facilities”. If people think it is possible for the Secretary of State to make those changes retrospectively then it undermines the business case for making the investment in the first place by putting uncertainty over that revenue stream. Open-ended powers also reduce certainty and increase the risk of different interpretations of the legislation, which again makes long-term infrastructure harder to justify, particularly in business areas where the margins are relatively low and you have to recover the cost over a considerable period of time. That will reduce the investment into rail terminals, the expansion of ports and so forth. The other risk is that the Government could set terminal charges or access terms when long-term logistics contracts rely on agreed access fees. A number of businesses are concerned that Clause 72 could require fee reductions and broader access for competitors, affecting profitability, contract compliance and the competitiveness of the port against other hubs. There is also a concern, if Clause 72 is applied unevenly, that some businesses could face stricter requirements than others, which is clearly an issue. If you weaken the ability of the Office of Rail and Road to act as the independent regulator and appeals body—we had a lengthy debate in earlier groups, which I do not propose to revisit, about the basis on which you can refer things to the ORR and that being on a judicial review model rather than on a substantive debate about the detail—that then reduces people’s confidence in the system. The final issue, if you have that regulatory uncertainty, is that you risk reducing investment into moving freight from road on to rail, and the investment required in green infrastructure in our ports to ensure that that transport is low carbon. Both those things are to do with the Government’s own policy areas. The amendments would do a number of things. Amendment 272, which is the lead amendment—I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Moylan for having signed it—would limit the regulation-making power in Clause 72 specifically to “the amendment, revocation, restatement or replacement of provisions” in the existing Railways (Access, Management and Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations. These regulations were set up in response to European Union directives that applied to us because we were members of the European Union at the time. They provide an appropriate basis that people are comfortable with. The amendment would limit the extent to which changes can be made. Amendment 273 would limit the use of that power in Clause 72 to a single exercise in relation to each of the relevant provisions, and would require the power to be used only to facilitate the transition to a replacement regulatory framework. In other words, you cannot use it to keep changing things, but you can use it for the intended purpose, which is to make sure that the existing rules work under the new model. Under my amendment, you would not be able to keep changing the rules and, effectively, shifting the goalposts for private sector businesses. Amendment 274 would require the regulations to “apply consistently and without discrimination” to persons, service facilities and locations in “materially comparable circumstances”. It would allow Ministers to have “objectively justified” and “proportionate” differences in treatment, but they would have to be clearly justified. That, again, is to deal with whether these are applied fairly. Amendment 276 slightly repeats the debate we have had on previous occasions. It would mean that there would be a right of appeal to the ORR for people affected by the use of decisions under Clause 72. It would not just be on a judicial review basis; it would mean you could bring an appeal on the grounds that the decision was “inconsistent with a statutory duty … based on an error of fact or law … discriminatory, or … disproportionate”. It would be a much more comprehensive appeal mechanism and provide investors and businesses with confidence that the power was not going to be misused.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. The final amendment, Amendment 279, relates to Clause 72, which refers to some consultations. It says:

    View contribution permalink →

  27. “Before making regulations under this section the Secretary of State must consult such persons as the Secretary of State considers appropriate”.

    View contribution permalink →

  28. My amendment would ensure that that bit is left out and instead sets out a list of people who should be consulted. This means the Secretary of State would have to publish a draft of the regulations and consult the ORR, Scottish Ministers, Welsh Ministers, TfL, any other relevant local government body and people who own, manage or operate non-GBR infrastructure likely to be affected. In other words, the Secretary of State would have to consult those people whom the use of the power would affect but who are not currently provided for. The Secretary of State may feel like consulting them when the time comes but, at the moment, does not have to and can just use the power whether the operators of service facilities and others are likely to be affected or not.

    View contribution permalink →

  29. There would have to be a reasonable period for representations and then, before the statutory instrument was laid, the Secretary of State would have to publish the representations and set out how they had been taken into account. Therefore, my amendment does not force the Secretary of State to take action as a result of the representations, but it does force the Secretary of State to show how the representations have been taken into account. I think that is very reasonable.

    View contribution permalink →

  30. These changes would still allow the Government to do what they say they want to do, which is to make sure that the existing 2016 regulations can be brought up to date and operate under the new structure. However, they also give the businesses investing in rail infrastructure at our ports, terminals and other non-GBR facilities confidence that the agreements they got for access to the infrastructure—which they need to get a return on investment—are protected. If the Government were to make any changes, the affected businesses would be consulted, and the Government would have to set out how they plan to alleviate their concerns. That is very reasonable.

    View contribution permalink →

  31. As I said, the amendments cover things that the Minister did not touch on in his letter to me, which focused on taking things into ownership, but businesses have concerns other than just a straight grab of their assets—which, of course, they also do not want to happen. If the Government make a business unable to make an economic return on its invested capital, it is just as bad as taking the assets away; in fact, it is worse because they are not paying any compensation. That, therefore, is the root of businesses’ concern with Clause 72. I will listen carefully to what the Minister says when he responds to this group, about whether he thinks these concerns are justified and whether he wants to bring something forward on Report to tighten it up—or whether it will be down to us to do so. I beg to move Amendment 272.

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Lord Grayling (Con)

    My Lords, I rise to speak in support of Amendment 275, in my name. My noble friend Lord Harper has articulated the concerns that many of us have about this specific part of the Bill very well, so I will not repeat all his points. I have highlighted the issue of specific facilities, and I declare my interests as set out in the register. I might work for Hutchison Ports Europe but this issue is broader than that: it is not just about ports, it is about private sector facilities in freight in ports and airports. The key point here—I say this in the full knowledge that the Minister is smart enough to realise the implications of the decisions he is making—is that the Minister will not always be the Minister, and this is a Government who have taken decisions that are sometimes ideological, and sometimes ideological in a way that takes things into reverse rather than going forward. They know what some of those decisions are. I do not have confidence in a Labour Government not to make decisions for ideological reasons, and I do not have confidence that we will always have a Minister who does not make decisions for ideological reasons. The decisions taken for ideological reasons can sometimes completely undermine the commercial viability of a new investment or an existing investment or business. We are talking about facilities that may be extremely important to the United Kingdom, where the public sector can sometimes encourage the private sector to open up to doing positive things, but if it gets them wrong, the consequences may be serious. The obvious example that comes to my mind is the opening of the line to Okehampton. The Minister was involved in that when he was at Network Rail, as I was when I was Secretary of State. To my mind, it was a great success, but the Minister also knows that part of that route was a freight line controlled by a local quarry business. If the Government were to decide to pass regulations to bring more services to Okehampton or to extend the line beyond Okehampton, what would happen to that quarry business or the facilities it accesses? As the Minister knows, when the Government proceed with their support for the expansion of Heathrow Airport—as I hope they will—there will be no scenario in which the taxpayer can afford to pay for western and southern rail access. That will have to be privately funded. What will prevent a future Minister making a decision about access to the network and the line into and around Heathrow Airport that materially impacts on the business case for private sector investment in those two essential rail routes? As my noble friend Lord Harper rightly said, we are looking for the Minister to provide some comfort on Report—to indicate that there will be constraints on how the powers in this clause can be used, particularly to prevent decisions that will materially undermine investments made by the private sector, which the Minister rightly wants to see. There is another point in this clause on which I have not tabled a specific amendment, but where I thought I could issue a friendly challenge to the Minister, who has been extremely accommodating on this subject in other areas. There is a reference in this clause to criminal prosecutions. If those prosecutions are to be focused purely on safety, it would be absolutely right and proper for an operator of a section of private infrastructure that has broken safety rules in a criminal way to face sanction. I accept that. However, I should like to see some constraint on how this power can be used. As the Minister and I have discussed, on the civil aviation Bill and earlier on this Bill, it is very easy to stick a reference to criminality into a piece of legislation without any clear idea of what it is for. May I therefore ask the Minister to go away and review that clause, to see whether it would be sensible to make some clarification before Report? Neither he nor I want open-ended legislation that would allow a future Minister to make pretty much anything in this area a criminal act. I hope he is willing to do that and come back to us with some thoughts on Report.

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

    My Lords, I declare that I am a member of the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee. I was prompted to table Amendment 284 by our report after looking at this Bill, because Clauses 72 and 73 both contain Henry VIII powers. I was tempted to say “the dread Henry VIII powers”, because we are always concerned about increasing power to the Executive away from parliamentary scrutiny of aspects of legislation, and we are well aware that secondary legislation cannot be amended. These difficulties were all dealt with in our publication Democracy Denied? I note that the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, has an amendment to Clause 72 that, if I have interpreted it correctly, addresses the criticism from that report, in part. However, we are still left with Clause 73, which includes the Henry VIII power to make a consequential amendment to Acts of Parliament. This clause defines “GBR infrastructure”, which is straightforward and logical. The term is fundamental to understanding the scope of the Bill’s provisions on access to infrastructure. In what circumstances might such a fundamental and straightforward definition therefore need to be amended? We looked at the memorandum, which gives rather a short justification. It says that the definition may be updated “to remain consistent in the context of updates” and refers to “new technological advances”. Let me put this in context for the Committee. In many Bills, we see the term “new technological advances” being used as a justification for sweeping Henry VIII powers. Sometimes it is quite difficult to see what these technological advances will be that are so rapid and so great that we cannot come back to Parliament with primary legislation. In fact, the power makes a consequential provision that amends or repeals provisions contained in this or another Act of Parliament, and that links to Clause 72, which the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, will address shortly. But the example of covering technological advances seemed inadequate. In the light of inadequate justification from the Government for the delegated powers in Clause 73(2), we recommended that the power be removed from the Bill. I should say that, when our report came out, the Minister made contact with me almost as soon as I had tabled the amendment. We had a very helpful discussion, in which I asked the Minister to ensure that he makes comments that justify this Henry VIII power, because we cannot just put more and more Henry VIII powers in Bills without really understanding what they do.

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Lord Berkeley (Lab)

    My Lords, I will speak briefly to Amendment 280A, in my name, and comment on the other amendments in this group. First, I should declare an interest: I am the non-executive chair of a company called Gemini, which is trying to run trains from London to the continent on a high-speed line. In such discussions, one gets involved in all the issues that are happening and which we have been debating this afternoon, including the role of the Government and of the infrastructure manager when it is not Network Rail, and many other things. One example that concerns me is the fact that, two or three weeks ago, DB Cargo, which is the UK part of the German railway Deutsche Bahn, was put up for sale. This is something to do with European regulations and DB’s concerns in Germany; it is nothing to do with the UK, except that it has been told that it must put it out to tender and sell it by the end of the year. That does not give it a lot of time. Given that this company has, as far as we know, been operating quite happily for many years, is it something that GBR might think about buying? If so, we are going to have a state-owned freight company competing with three or four non-state-owned freight companies. How will this be assessed for fairness, especially if the ORR is not allowed to go into it too deeply? DB Cargo certainly owns terminals and it may own the odd rail facility at a port—I cannot really remember. The Government might decide that they would like to own the rail facility at a port, to put some money into it, invest in it and make it operate more effectively. Would the big ports that are in the private sector, such as Felixstowe and Southampton, think that this was fair? How would they go about challenging the Government to demonstrate that? They would probably have to take it to the competition people eventually. It would be very interesting to know from my noble friend whether there is any ability in the Bill for GBR to own a rail freight company or a terminal—a port or inland terminal, it does not matter where—which could accept customers from all around the country. How would they be able to demonstrate that it would be done fairly? I look forward to my noble friend’s comments.

    View contribution permalink →

  35. Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay (Con)

    My Lords, I can be brief. The noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, and I have Amendment 282 in this group, which simply seeks to ask the Minister whether the powers at Clause 72 for the Secretary of State include any infrastructure or asset of a preserved or heritage railway. When reading the clause, I do not think that is the case, but it would be very helpful to have that reassurance from the Minister on the record and from the Dispatch Box, if he is able to give it.

    View contribution permalink →

  36. Viscount Stansgate (Lab)

    My Lords, it would be it would be remiss of me if I did not intervene briefly to support the amendment tabled by my noble friends Lord Parkinson and Lord Faulkner, both of whom happen to be in the room. I have already set on record my interests in this area, which are completely non-financial. I should add, while I am on my feet, for when my noble friend the Minister comes to reply, that I also have reservations, for the reasons outlined, about Clause 72(4). This raises issues that go far beyond this particular Bill.

    View contribution permalink →

  37. Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

    My Lords, this is an important group of amendments, and clearly many of them are trying to achieve a similar result. I thank the Minister for his detailed correspondence, which was sent out this morning and which provided a lot of assurance. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, for raising such important points from the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee. I will focus on the two clauses. Clause 72 grants the Secretary of State significant powers that could be exercised beyond the limited justification described in the Explanatory Note. While clearly there is a desire to ensure smooth regulatory interfaces between Great British Railways and other rail infrastructure managers, for organisations such as London St Pancras Highspeed, alignment with regulatory processes in Europe remains really important. This is because any international passenger services will need to pass through the Channel Tunnel and on to European infrastructure. Changes, for example, to the timetable change date could make securing new services more challenging, by creating additional regulatory and process friction. London St Pancras Highspeed is concerned that secondary legislation could be used to prevent non-Great British Railways infrastructure managers offering large discounts, currently permitted by the railways regulations 2016; to modify procedures governing operator access to non-Great British Railway facilities and services which are essential for train operators such as Temple Mills Depot, which we all know well; and to make changes to the rail regulations 2016, which make the growth of international traffic harder by increasing divergence with European rail processes and timelines. There is wide concern—I have outlined London St Pancras Highspeed, but also in the freight sector—that this clause would distort the market, disincentivise private sector investment and add additional regulation. My Amendment 283 would prevent regulations under Clause 72 affecting the arrangements of a non-Great British Railways infrastructure manager unless the Secretary of State has consulted those affected and published an impact assessment. It would bar provisions that materially alter the economic effect of existing arrangements or prevent the manager levying charges, unless expressly approved or necessary. It would restrict regulations requiring alignment of processes for international services when this would create inconsistency with Channel Tunnel or European rail processes. On this clause, will the Minister confirm that the intent is alignment only and consider tightening the clause so the power cannot be used beyond that purpose in relation to non-Great British Railway infrastructure managers? Can the Minister confirm that no changes will be made to the regulatory framework that would restrict growth in international traffic by adding complexity between the regimes? I would hope that the Minister would be sympathetic to these concerns and respond accordingly, and provide from the Dispatch Box the assurance that is clearly needed. My Amendment 285 would prevent regulations from redefining “GBR infrastructure” to capture non-GBR-operated assets—which could include High Speed 1 or a freight terminal—without consultation, impact assessment and parliamentary approval. The reason for this amendment is that Clause 73(2) says: “The Secretary of State may by regulations amend the definition of ‘GBR infrastructure’”. That is worrying for organisations that interface with the railway, whether High Speed 1 or private sector freight infrastructure and service facilities. How will these organisations be able to secure funding, as has already been mentioned, when Clauses 72 and 73 are written as they are and given how people will interpret them? Will the Minister confirm on the record that High Speed 1 and other private freight facilities are not intended to be reclassified as Great British Railways infrastructure and that Clause 73 will not be used in a way that will unintentionally bring them within scope of the Bill? I am hopeful of clarification from him. The sector is concerned about this and any unintended consequences for non-Great British Railways organisations. I look forward to hearing from the Minister the assurance that the sector so desperately needs.

    View contribution permalink →

  38. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, I start by aligning myself completely with the words just spoken by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. My only point of departure from her is that, while she is hopeful of clarification, I am doubtful whether clarification will be sufficient, given the extent of the Henry VIII powers contained in the Bill. Words from the Minister as to his intentions—sincerely meant, I have no doubt—are not a sufficient binding of these powers. If they are needed, it should be explained what they will be used for. If they are not needed, they should be boiled down to something in the Bill which removes the objectionable features. My Amendments 278 and 280 would require broad consultation. Other noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, have spoken to the principle of this. I do not expect much comfort from the Minister because I do not think that he has so far accepted any suggestion made by the Committee, with one possible exception some time ago. Amendments 277 and 284 relate to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee’s recommendations, which have been clearly explained by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay of Llandaff. They concern very broad Henry VIII powers. As drafted, regulations could amend not only existing primary legislation but Acts passed in future Sessions of Parliament. That is, quite honestly, intolerable. If someone is going to pass an Act of Parliament in the future, knowing full well that this statute is on the books, then they should write it taking account of the fact that this statute is on the books. It should not be written in such a way that it might need to be changed to make it compliant with this Bill. My Amendment 277 would prevent regulations under this clause from amending or repealing provisions contained in Acts passed in future Sessions of Parliament. The Delegated Powers Committee pointed out that the Government have provided no justification for taking such an “unusual” power. It is no doubt desirable from the Government’s point of view, but it is none the less unusual. We do not normally put up with this. I support the amendment tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, to which I have signed my name. This would remove Clause 73(2). I think it has been explained; I do not need to go through it further. The definition of GBR infrastructure contained in Clause 73 could, when it is in an Act of Parliament, be rewritten by the Secretary of State using regulations which are, as we know, subject to relatively light scrutiny in your Lordships’ House and unamendable. The Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee was clear that the Government have not justified why such a fundamental definition should be capable of being changed by secondary legislation. It will not be enough for the Minister to say that an amendment to the definition may be needed in the future for practical reasons; everyone knows that a change may be needed in future for practical reasons. We are all willing to concede that. We are not willing to concede that the definition contained in statute should be changed by Ministers using powers that are very skimpy on scrutiny. I turn to Amendment 281 and my opposition to Clause 72 standing part of the Bill. The Minister has provided us with some assurance that this clause will not be used for the wholesale nationalisation of private infrastructure. However, as my noble friend Lord Harper said, although that concern can never be totally dismissed from the minds of right-thinking people, given the way this Government seek constantly to hark back to the 1970s and the features of the economy then, which certainly included widespread nationalisation, it was none the less not our primary concern. The letter that came this morning at 9 am, while welcome, clear and an important contribution to this debate and the Government’s commitment at the Dispatch Box, to which they can be bound in the future, none the less did not address the issues that concern us so much. This is quite a poorly drafted Bill and some of these issues arise because of the poor drafting, but it is not fair for the Government to say that they may need these powers and, therefore, they should have these huge powers that will not be referred back to Parliament.

    View contribution permalink →

  39. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    My Lords, Clause 72 enables us to ensure that the existing regulatory framework applying to non-GBR infrastructure can continue to operate alongside the new access and charging framework for that infrastructure. Although GBR infrastructure will not be subject to the access management regulations, adjacent infrastructure, including High Speed 1, the Core Valley Lines and some Transport for London infrastructure, will remain subject to those regulations as they are today. When the new GBR framework is introduced and as it subsequently develops, it is possible that inconsistencies, gaps or operational frictions may emerge between the two regimes. This could increase complexity for operators that run services across both GBR and non-GBR infrastructure. As with any reform of this scale, it is not realistic to expect that every technical, consequential or operational issue which may arise can be identified in advance. Clause 72 therefore provides the power to make regulations, with the flexibility necessary to ensure the two frameworks can operate effectively alongside one another, to preserve alignment as the GBR framework evolves and to make other necessary or beneficial changes where appropriate. One example concerns the main annual timetable change date, which is currently in December and enshrined in the existing access management regulations. If GBR were to change this to a different date—as it is actually a rather unsuitable time to change railway timetables just before Christmas—and other infrastructure managers wished to follow suit, this would require a change to the existing regulations. As well as supporting regulatory alignment, the power also provides opportunities that non-GBR infrastructure managers may wish to take advantage of. For example, the Welsh Government have indicated a desire to reform the current arrangements as they apply to the core valley lines in South Wales, in particular to integrate the management and operation of track and train. The power in Clause 72 would be important in facilitating such reforms. Removing Clause 72 would therefore risk the GBR and non-GBR regimes diverging over time, creating inconsistencies and adding complexity for operators, as well as losing the opportunity to support Welsh Ministers’ aspirations and other potential improvements. I make it absolutely clear from the outset that Clause 72 cannot be used to bring other infrastructure managers, the operators of privately funded freight-only facilities or any of their assets into public ownership. We also do not intend to interfere with the operation of private freight facilities or alter the fundamental principles governing access to them. I should also—

    View contribution permalink →

  40. Lord Grayling (Con)

    The Minister says that it cannot be used in the way he described. Can he explain why? If you read it, it suggests very clearly that it can be used.

    View contribution permalink →

  41. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    The Government believe that it is not drafted to enable it to be used. I emphasise the safeguards that apply to any proposed use of the power. The Secretary of State must consult on any regulations made under this clause, and any regulations would be subject to the affirmative parliamentary procedure, ensuring parliamentary scrutiny and debate in both Houses before any changes can be made. Turning to Amendments 272 and 280 to 283, from numerous noble Lords, I reiterate that the power cannot be used—we believe that the clauses are so drafted that this is their effect—to bring other infrastructure managers, the operators of those facilities or any of their assets into public ownership, whether they are freight, open access or heritage. Clause 72(1) sets out the matters about which the Secretary of State may make provision by regulations, and neither those matters nor the consequential power in subsection (4) confer a power to transfer ownership of infrastructure or assets into public ownership. If the Bill intended to confer a power to transfer ownership, it would have needed to spell that out explicitly. Equally, it is not intended to disrupt the way that such facilities are operated, change their commercial basis or weaken the protections that underpin private investment. As I have explained, its purpose is to ensure that the adjacent regulatory frameworks remain coherent and workable alongside the new arrangements for GBR. However, I emphasise that any regulations made under this power will be subject to the affirmative procedure, meaning that they cannot be made without first being considered and approved by both Houses. Turning to my noble friend Lord Berkeley’s Amendment 280A, I have already made it clear that Clause 72 cannot be used to bring private infrastructure into public ownership. However, there may be circumstances in which changes affecting the wider railway require amendments to regulations that apply to non-GBR infrastructure, including freight-only facilities. Excluding such infrastructure entirely from the scope of the power could unnecessarily prevent necessary changes. My noble friend raised the sale of DB Cargo. My understanding currently is that there are a number of bids, all of which treat the company as a going concern. The Government are not considering or taking any action to buy the company, and neither do they intend to buy its terminals, although many of them are protected by covenants to ensure the use of freight. The Government’s intention is to leave freight operations in private ownership. Constraining the power in the ways suggested by these amendments risks making it ineffective as well as limiting the opportunity to make future improvements sought by the Welsh Government or other infrastructure managers. I also emphasise that restricting this power could ultimately be detrimental to the very infrastructure managers these amendments seek to protect. As the new GBR arrangements bed in, changes to the wider railway could have unintended consequences for non-GBR infrastructure, potentially affecting its ability to operate effectively alongside, and remain connected to, the wider network. Without the flexibility provided by Clause 72, we could find ourselves unable to make the regulatory changes necessary to address these consequences, leaving non-GBR infrastructure managers worse off. I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Harper, that, if the existing regulations need to be amended or replaced using the Clause 72 power, the access and management regulations are most likely to be affected. However, railway legislation is interconnected, so amendments to one piece of legislation may require consequential amendments to other Acts or regulations. It would therefore be unwise to exclude the possibility of such amendments, as doing so could risk preventing necessary or beneficial changes in the future. In relation to international rail services, while the Bill does not directly impact those services, I recognise the importance of maintaining effective cross-border operations, including services operated on High Speed 1 through the Channel Tunnel. We agree that consultation with those involved would be particularly important where proposed changes to the domestic framework could create misalignment with European arrangements. However, Clause 72 already requires the Secretary of State to consult such persons as she considers appropriate before making regulations, providing the flexibility to engage with relevant parties where these issues arise. With these points in mind, and recalling the consultation requirements and parliamentary scrutiny provided for in the Bill, the Government consider that Clause 72 strikes the right balance between flexibility and oversight. I turn to Amendments 275, 278, 279 and 280 and am mindful that this is also relevant to Amendment 283 from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. I completely agree that consultation is an important principle and that the Secretary of State should consult those affected. As I have said, Clause 72 already requires the Secretary of State to consult such persons as she considers appropriate and she must act reasonably in deciding who to consult. Where facility owners, operators or users are affected by proposed changes, we would certainly expect that they would be consulted and would also expect consultation to include the Office of Rail and Road. The amendment would also require the publication of an impact assessment before regulations could be made. However, established government processes already require the impact of regulatory proposals to be assessed proportionately. Where appropriate, an impact assessment or other supporting analysis would accompany the regulations, providing transparency on the expected impacts and effects of the proposed changes. We therefore do not consider that a statutory requirement is necessary. The noble Lord, Lord Grayling, raised the issue of criminal sections at Clause 72(3)(a) and, in light of our previous discussions about criminal sanctions, I will consider what he says further. Amendments 274 and 276 focus on appeals and non-discrimination. On Amendment 274, public law principles already require the Secretary of State to act proportionately, rationally and fairly when exercising this power, meaning that an additional test for non-discrimination is not necessary. The amendment also creates ambiguity and uncertainty, as it means that the scope of the power depends on judgments about whether different people affected by regulations are in materially comparable circumstances. Rather than introduce this uncertainty, we have instead designed the power so that a combination of public law principles and appropriate scrutiny provide the necessary safeguards against it being used unfairly. Amendment 276 would require regulations to provide a right of appeal to the ORR against decisions made under the regulations, but that is unnecessary because the access and management regulations already provide for a right of appeal under Regulation 32, and I can reassure noble Lords that there is no intention to remove that. I turn to Amendments 273 and 277. The Government do not consider the restriction in Amendment 273 to be workable. As I have set out, one possible use of the regulations is to avoid inconsistencies, gaps or operational frictions emerging between the GBR and non-GBR regimes. This could arise not only when the new regime is introduced, but successively over time as the GBR regime evolves. I point again to the Welsh Government’s aspirations for the Core Valley Lines as an example of why that would be inappropriate. If the power was used only once to help align the GBR and non-GBR regimes, it could not then be used again to amend the same provisions to support those aspirations. On Amendment 277, I have read the report of the Delegated Powers Committee carefully. I take its recommendations seriously and, of course, will take today’s debate into account as I continue to consider them prior to Report. I turn to Amendment 285 and reassure the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, that the concern underlying this amendment has already been addressed during the Bill’s passage. It is certainly not the Government’s intention that third-party infrastructure should be brought into the scope of the GBR access regime. Indeed, earlier this year the Government identified a risk that the original definition of GBR infrastructure could have been interpreted as including infrastructure operated by GBR on behalf of another infrastructure manager under a contractual arrangement—High Speed 1, among others. A government amendment was therefore made in the other place to clarify that infrastructure managed or operated by GBR on behalf of another person does not fall within the definition of GBR infrastructure in Clause 73(1). The change was specifically intended to ensure that infrastructure adjacent to GBR and managed by GBR under contractual arrangements, as the noble Baroness describes, remains outside the GBR access and charging framework. The Bill therefore already draws a clear distinction between infrastructure for which GBR is responsible in its own right and infrastructure that it may operate in future on behalf of a third party, such as the specialist management that Network Rail High Speed delivers to High Speed 1 today. To be clear, the Bill, following this amendment, ensures that the High Speed 1 concessionaire can continue to outsource various activities for operations, maintenance and renewal without impacting the nature of the concession agreement itself and without bringing that infrastructure into the GBR access regime. Further, the Government recognise that any future change to the definition of GBR infrastructure would be significant. That is why regulations made under Clause 73(2) would be subject to the affirmative procedure, ensuring that Parliament would have the opportunity to scrutinise and approve any such change before it could take effect. I have already set out the Government’s approach to assessing the impacts of proposed regulations. I am happy to confirm that the Government do not intend to reclassify freight facilities, HS1 or any other private infrastructure in the way that the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, has described. I turn to Amendment 284, from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay. I understand the concerns of the Delegated Powers Committee that the definition of GBR infrastructure ought not to require amendment. This definition is of fundamental importance, because it determines which railway assets fall within the new GBR access and charging regime created by the Bill and which are to remain subject to the existing regime. The Government consider that, given the importance in defining the boundary between the two regimes, there should be a means short of primary legislation to update the definition should circumstances change. While the definition is intended to provide a clear and enduring boundary between the two regimes, it is not possible to anticipate every future development in the structure, ownership or operation of railway infrastructure. For example, new infrastructure could be built under commercial or contractual arrangements that differ from those used today. In such circumstances, it may be necessary to adjust the definition to ensure that the relevant infrastructure falls within the correct regulatory framework. The power may also be needed to provide clarity and certainty when questions arise about the application of the definition in particular circumstances. Indeed, as I have explained in relation to Amendment 285, the Government brought forward an amendment earlier in the Bill’s passage to make sure that the definition does not capture infrastructure operated or maintained by GBR on behalf of a third party. That enables us to reassure stakeholders that their particular commercial arrangements would not be unintentionally affected by the Bill. The power could be used in a similar way. I recognise that any change to the definition would of course be significant. That is precisely why the power is subject to the affirmative procedure. Any affected parties would also be appropriately consulted before any such changes were brought forward. I hope that the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, is reassured by what I have said. Of course, as I have said before, we will be responding formally to the Delegated Powers Committee’s report before Report, where I will set this out in further detail.

    View contribution permalink →

  42. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, the Minister speaks in relation to that delegated power as if it were likely to be used in connection with, for example, new very largescale infrastructure, but does he not agree that if there were new very largescale infrastructure, it is very likely, given past practice, that it would be approved after many years, subject to a hybrid Bill in Parliament? If that was so, such a Bill could contain an appropriate amendment of the definition at that stage, in a way that would not require a power to rewrite Acts of Parliament. The Minister may have other possibilities in mind, such as new infrastructure that does not require a hybrid Bill, but it would encourage the use of a hybrid Bill. The main point I want to make is that, whatever method is used—be it a hybrid Bill, a Transport and Works Act order or planning permission under a development consent order—no new infrastructure will be built at short notice; that would be very surprising, given the history of rail infrastructure in this country. All new infrastructure will be built after a very long period of time. That time would allow the Government to find an appropriate Bill that was passing through Parliament to carry the amendment that they needed, even if a hybrid Bill was not actually required for the approval of the infrastructure. Does the Minister agree?

    View contribution permalink →

  43. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    The noble Lord has rather made my point. It is of course possible that a hybrid Bill might consider how the infrastructure it is proposing to build would be considered in future, but the other routes he talked about—and I agree with him—to the construction of new infrastructure, such as Transport and Works Act orders and routes that involve planning powers, are very unlikely to consider that as part of the approval process, which might go on for many years.

    View contribution permalink →

  44. Lord Moylan (Con)

    That is the point; it might be many years.

    View contribution permalink →

  45. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    Many years. Some of them are smaller than others, but the Government think that the point of this is to try, as far as is possible, to make sure that the management arrangements surrounding the railway reflect what will be needed in future to clarify access.

    View contribution permalink →

  46. Lord Harper (Con)

    My Lords, where to start? Let me start with the easy, uncontroversial bit. I congratulate my noble friend Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay and the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, on once again crowbarring references to heritage railways into this group of amendments—they have done so brilliantly throughout this Committee, and I congratulate them again. It gives me an excuse to mention the fantastic Dean Forest Railway in my home area, as people would be very disappointed if I did not do so. I was considering raising the concerns that the Delegated Powers Committee set out so ably in its report. I then spied the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay of Llandaff, and assumed, because I do not think that she has been in one of our sessions before, that she was here to do that. It was much more powerful coming from her, as a member of the committee, and I think that she set it out very well. The only thing I would suggest to the committee, if I may be so bold, is this. It has the Henry VIII definition, which it is forced to use quite a lot—and not just under this Government, to be fair. If we are going to see increasing reference to this ability to amend not just existing legislation but future legislation, perhaps I could suggest an amended definition of a Henry VIII power crossed with “Doctor Who”—although I do not quite know what that would look like—so that the committee could go into the future and change future legislation. It clearly needs another definition to show that Henry VIII powers are not the ultimate legislative terribleness and that there are worse things, such as amending things that have not even been written yet—as my noble friend suggested, you could just write them properly in the first place. If you are passing future legislation, perhaps you should just do it right, rather than relying on powers in existing legislation to fix the stuff you have not yet written. The noble Baroness set out all of that very well. I listened carefully to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, who had similar concerns. The only point I would make—I say this to not just the Minister but the Whip—is that it should have been obvious, in listening to the debate, that the concerns seem to be coming from across the Committee and from all of the groups that are represented here. I am sure that the Whip will be doing the maths ahead of Report. I gently suggest to the Minister that he might want to reflect on this, and that a well-crafted amendment from the Government to address at least some of our concerns would be well advised. Let me touch on the points that the Minister made in response to concerns, particularly those that I set out, before I ask the Committee’s permission to withdraw my amendment. First, he set up another straw man in suggesting that people want to get rid of Clause 72 in its entirety. My amendments would specifically not abolish Clause 72; they would heavily amend and constrain it. I recognise that you need some powers to bring regimes into alignment, and I do not think I heard any dispute about that in the Committee. So that was a bit of a straw man, as nobody suggested it in the first place. The Minister repeated the point that I made in my introduction about his letter, which he helpfully sent today. I agree with my noble friend Lord Moylan that it was helpful to have that on the record. However, public ownership is not really the point, and my noble friend Lord Grayling challenged the Minister on this. My reading of Clause 72 is not that it gives the Government the right to take ownership of the assets. The problem—I come back to the point that the Prime Minister keeps making about public control—is that, if you make provisions about management, operation, pricing and all that, you are doing something worse than taking ownership of these assets because, by taking ownership, you would have to pay and compensate somebody for them. The danger here is that you can alter their economic use without having to pay for it. That is the concern of the investors and operators of these assets, and I do not think I heard anything from the Minister that would have reassured them. On the issue in Amendment 276 about the right of appeal to the ORR, the Minister referred to the access and management regulations already containing a right of appeal, but, unless I am missing the point, this is not about access to the GBR network but about the basis on which people can use these private sector assets and the ability to charge for them. Unless I am very confused, I do not think the access and management regulations and the right of appeal to the ORR cover that point. As we have talked about previously, being able to appeal on a judicial review is quite narrow and does not encompass operators’ concerns. A further point on Clause 73 is around the definition of GBR infrastructure. The Minister was talking slightly at cross-purposes when he said—I think I have got this right—that he wanted the definition of GBR infrastructure, and therefore non-GBR infrastructure, to be enduring. That is a good thing, but “enduring” means something that is set and that lasts for a long time, not something you keep fiddling with. Therefore, an enduring definition in which people can have confidence ought to be set out in primary legislation that cannot be amended by secondary legislation. As soon as it can be amended by secondary legislation, it is not an enduring definition any more, because Ministers can fiddle about with it pretty much at whim. My final point, which is connected to this, is one which my noble friend Lord Moylan set out. We might lament the fact, but this infrastructure does not pop up without notice. In his response to my noble friend Lord Moylan, the Minister accepted that this stuff takes a very long time. In those circumstances, it would be up to the Government—I do not think it is that hard—to find an appropriate primary legislative vehicle. I accept that that would be an issue if you were trying to do it within a year or so, but it does not seem impossible over a number of years. We are talking here about significant capital investment, such as freight terminals and ports. That is hundreds of millions of pounds—even billions of pounds—of capital investment. If someone is making that sort of investment into the country then it would not be an enormous challenge for the Government to come up with a short piece of primary legislation to deal with any ambiguities or difficulties there might be in ensuring that that asset can operate. Investment in such infrastructure will not be made, go through the planning process, built, constructed and start to operate in less than a number of years. The concern is not really one that we should worry about. Before I beg leave to withdraw my amendment, all I will say is that I do not think, based on what the Minister has said so far, that any of the concerns that people have set out have been addressed. The Minister should reflect further, following this debate, on the points that were made. We will look closely at his written response to the Delegated Powers Committee’s report and reflect on that before we get to Report to see whether we need to table any of these amendments again. The Minister might accept that there is an issue to be dealt with and, even if he does not go as far as we would ideally like, may wish to bring forward amendments of his own to constrain—not get rid of—the powers in Clauses 72 and 73 in a way that would reassure investors and those that operate this non-GBR infrastructure. On that point, I beg leave to withdraw Amendment 272.

    View contribution permalink →

  47. Amendment 272 withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  48. Amendments 273 to 283 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  49. Clause 72 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  50. Clause 73: Interpretation of Chapter 1 of Part 3

    View contribution permalink →

  51. Amendments 283A to 285 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  52. Clause 73 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  53. Clause 74: Monitoring Great British Railways

    View contribution permalink →

  54. Amendments 286 to 291 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  55. Amendment 291A

    View contribution permalink →

  56. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  57. 291A: Clause 74, page 44, line 9, at end insert— “(d) whether costs, revenues and public funds are allocated between Great British Railways’ online retail activities and its other activities in a manner which secures that its online retail activities do not receive any cross-subsidy which distorts competition in the sale of tickets, and whether Great British Railways is contributing a proportionate amount towards retail systems used by all persons selling tickets.(2A) Great British Railways must provide the Office of Rail and Road with such information as it may require for the purposes of subsection (2)(d), including the methodology used to allocate costs, assets and revenues to its online retail activities.(2B) The Office of Rail and Road must, in respect of each financial year, publish its conclusions on the matters in subsection (2)(d).”Member's explanatory statement This amendment and another in the name of Lord Dixon of Jericho would require the ORR, as part of its monitoring of GBR, to assess each year whether GBR’s online retail is being cross-subsidised and whether GBR pays its fair share of shared retail systems. The ORR would have full access to GBR’s cost-allocation data, and only its conclusions would need to be published.

    View contribution permalink →

  58. Lord Dixon of Jericho (LD)

    My Lords, in moving Amendment 291A, I will also speak to the other amendments in my name in this group. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for adding his name to all of them. This is the first chance we have had since the publication of the draft retail code to look at the issues of data and a potential subsidy. In general, I am very sympathetic to high-level principles-based approaches of regulation, but in these specific areas I think the code is less future-proof and will be more cumbersome in practice than it needs to be. I will start with data and then move on to talk about money. Despite many attempts over the years to specify that data should be more open and easier to use, we are in a complete mess. Fares come as large XML file dumps, and, as I said the last time we spoke about this, 11 operators publish accessibility data in 11 different formats—one of which is a PDF. The problem here is that the draft retail code takes the same approach that has failed time and again for many years. It is deliberately and consciously high-level principles only. I think we can do it differently and do it better. I am acutely aware that this needs to be future-proofed. As we have just said, while infrastructure moves slower than legislation, technology moves faster than legislation, and people are right to worry that a detailed technical standard that looks right in 2027 will look odd in 2035 and unworkable by 2040. The code presents that as a binary choice between high-level principles and short-sighted technical detail, but that is a false choice, and that framing is exactly what has got us into the mess that we are in today. I urge us not to make the same mistake again. Amendment 330JD tries to reframe how we think about this problem. If noble Lords will forgive me, the core idea is basically that GBR must eat its own cooking. The simplest way to make sure a meal tastes good is to make the person who cooked it eat it, and then we have to make sure it tastes good not just to them but to everyone else. In practice, that means that GBR’s retail app must use the same services it offers to everyone else—the same data, functions and pipe. That is, in essence, the whole idea, and the rest is basically detail. If you get that incentive right then the thing works without needing to be policed. If GBR’s own app depends on a set of interfaces, it has every reason to make them fast, reliable and well-documented. If it were ever tempted to give a competitor a slower feed, or a new fare a week late, it would be doing the same thing to itself. You would therefore not need the regulator to spot discrimination after the event because it would be fundamentally baked-in. This idea is not at all new. It is exactly how Amazon Web Services has worked since 2002, and it is how Openreach works. Section 89A of the Communications Act has basically the same mechanism. It is pretty much how open banking works: the interface that third-party apps use must have the same level of availability and performance as the bank’s own. Really importantly, certainly from our point of view, this is extremely simple to deliver and police. It is far easier to maintain one codebase—one kitchen and set of ingredients, in food terms—and it will result in far less work for lawyers than the proposed principle in the draft code of non-discriminatory access, which would have to be reinterpreted every single time something new launches.

    View contribution permalink →

  59. I know that some noble Lords will see words in my amendment, such as “application programming interfaces” and “test environment”, and wonder how much this is really about eating your own cooking and whether this level of technical language belongs in an Act. I reassure them that my amendment uses only concepts that have remained consistent for more than 20 years in the internet. That does happen. While many things change, if you want to put data into an Amazon S3 bucket, which is essentially the store that most of the internet runs on, you use a GET and a PUT call. Those were first written in March 2006 and they still work today. You can use commands that are more than 23 years old to access some of the most advanced internet infrastructure in the world; you just have to make sure that you specify the thing in the right way. Reassuringly, Parliament itself first defined an “application programming interface” in the Communications Act 2003, and it used the same term again in last year’s Data (Use and Access) Act. It can be done; we do use such words in legislation, and it would make it much simpler.

    View contribution permalink →

  60. Briefly, Amendment 330JB deals with the data itself and builds on an amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, on publishing railway data. His amendment says what should be published, and this is about making it usable: documented interfaces, notice before they change and an annual check so that a developer can build on what is published. This is not for the existing suppliers or the main private companies in this world now; it is for the people who will build the British companies of tomorrow and the people who use those services to book trains and get refunds quickly, easily and simply. They do not need a licence negotiation or lawyers; they need an interface they can rely on. The Minister said on the first day that he wants all retailers to be able to sell all tickets. Those two amendments are the simplest and cheapest way of making sure that that is true in practice, in our view.

    View contribution permalink →

  61. I turn to money and to being able to tell the difference, essentially, between a public service and a subsidy. I will be brief here because I largely agree with the Minister’s big picture argument in this area, and I hope the amendments themselves are a bit easier to understand than the ones I have just talked through. The Bill’s approach is essentially for GBR to publish numbers in a business plan, with no requirements for separate financial accounting. The trouble is that, without any numbers, no one can tell whether there is subsidy. If no one is looking, subsidy is definitely more likely.

    View contribution permalink →

  62. I have tried to find the lightest thing that would work. Amendment 330JC does not ask for separate statutory accounts; the Government have already said no to that. It asks for one annual statement on what it costs GBR to sell a ticket online. The categories in it are not mine: I am very grateful for discussions with the Minister’s officials about how you would measure it. They gave me the five headings in the amendment. Officials have told me that comparing those categories with the commission independent retailers receive was the acid test in this area, and I agree with them. The amendment asks GBR to publish the result of that test, asks the ORR to give its view on it and asks the Secretary of State to lay both before Parliament. As I have argued, possibly in private, the sums here are not small. Passenger revenue is about £12 billion a year, and 4.3% of that is hundreds of millions of pounds. At the moment, almost nobody outside and very few people—I cannot find one—inside the industry can say where that goes with any level of detail.

    View contribution permalink →

  63. Amendments 291A and 291B, taken together, are a lighter alternative. If the Minister’s concern is commercial sensitivity, the detail would go to the regulator and the public would just see the verdict. Either approach would turn the Minister’s commitment to transparency into something that someone somewhere can actually check.

    View contribution permalink →

  64. I thank noble Lords for their patience. I hope that makes the intention of my amendments and the thinking behind them clear. I thank the Minister and the officials for the frank and constructive way they have engaged with me on this. It has been really helpful. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  65. Lord Harper (Con)

    My Lords, I strongly support these amendments, which the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, introduced so ably. He will remember that he and I covered this important issue at Second Reading. I will take the two aspects separately. Amendments 291A, 291B and 330JC are about stopping cross-subsidy from GBR’s other operations to its retail ticketing arm and putting in some transparency, which are mutually reinforcing and important measures. Successful businesses that operate competitively exist only because they serve their customers. If they did not serve their customers, they would not exist. They are not concerned about GBR in proper competition on a level playing field; they are perfectly content that they can operate in that space and compete perfectly well. Either they will be good at it, which they think they will, or they will not be good at it, and that is fine; they have no complaint about that. What they are worried about is GBR using its non-retail revenues, or its access to the infrastructure and the cost that it has to pay for that, to compete unfairly with them. In a previous group we talked about the fact that the passenger services part of GBR will not have to pay for the access charges to GBR infrastructure—the other part of the business. If a retail operator looks at that model, it will think, “Hang on, does that mean that GBR’s retail operation can access the data and infrastructure that it needs to run that operation without having to pay for it?” If it can do that, which is what the Bill sets out, that clearly means that it is not competing on a level playing field and that the taxpayer is, in effect, subsidising GBR to put out of business a company that employs staff, makes profits, pays taxes and has innovated to produce a model that serves customers very well. Clearly, that would not be welcome. As far as I can tell, all the noble Lord’s amendments would do is to make sure that GBR cannot cross-subsidise. He set out a number of ways in which that could be done, recognising that there are some commercial constraints here. Again, if the Minister does not like the way the amendments have been worded, it is completely open to him either to make suggestions to the noble Lord or to come back with his own amendments. These are real concerns that real businesses have and, frankly, passengers will have them too—they might not have them now, but they will if any of these commercial businesses stop existing and they get left with one monopolistic government operator selling tickets. That has never been a recipe for innovation and great customer service, which is what people are used to at the moment. The second part of the amendments is about access to the data, which I strongly support. This is something that the coalition Government did when my noble friend Lord Maude of Horsham was the relevant Minister in the Cabinet Office. They led the world in making available lots of government and official data in an open and transparent way, which led to the development by the private sector of innumerable apps that have been of enormous benefit to the public. That is what the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, is trying to do here: to make sure that GBR has to make that data available. His solution is an excellent one: it is consistent with best practice in industry—it is not a legislative vehicle that will not work; as he said, it is how many other businesses operate already—and it would ensure, in a very future-proofed way, that GBR’s retail operation has to run a good operation in terms of data because it will use the same systems and interfaces that all its competitors have. If it wants to disadvantage its competitors, it has to disadvantage itself in the same way and vice versa. That is a very good solution because it means it is future-proofed and does not require an enormous amount of regulation with somebody else managing a very complicated structure. It is a model which we know works in technology and retail businesses because we have seen it in others, including those that are heavily regulated, such as Openreach. These amendments have a lot to recommend them. The concerns are shared, as highlighted by my noble friend Lord Moylan signing several of them. I think, remembering back to Second Reading, that these concerns were shared across the House. I will listen carefully to what the Minister has to say in response to see whether he can deal with it. Setting out assurances about how he will conduct himself is obviously helpful, but we are passing laws that have to operate and endure under Governments of potentially many different complexions with many different Ministers and attitudes. It is the legislation that maters, not just what the Minister says about it. The legislation is too weak and requires tightening up. These are excellent amendments which have a lot to recommend them to the Committee. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

    View contribution permalink →

  66. Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

    My Lords, I will speak to this important group from my noble friend Lord Dixon, who has gone into great detail and shows his extensive knowledge in this area. It is important that we have this debate now, because we had an earlier debate before the draft retail code had been published. That was going to solve every problem, but it clearly has not. In a briefing note sent to me, Independent Rail Retailers has stressed that this is principle based only and that the mechanisms proposed are not enough to deliver these outcomes. The Bill is silent on many areas, as we have heard, including a fair, open and competitive market, funding and transparency. It does not yet provide the protections that retailers have repeatedly called for, or those the Government have promised. Even if the Government wish to redraft these amendments—they deal with a lot of the issues we discussed on the earlier day—it is really important that we make sure that data is open and easier to use for all operators, including future ones. The really strong point is that we have seen so much creativity across the country in this area. We saw it many years ago when Transport for London put all its data out there. How many bus apps popped up within a week or two, absolutely transforming how we use transport networks? It is really important that the data is in a format that is simple to use. Even with my lack of technological skill, I know that a PDF of data is next to useless. It is really important that Great British Railways provides it in that way and that Great British Railways retail must use the same as everyone else. Previously in Committee, I raised an issue that I had found recently. It may just be my technological skill, but I could not find the discounted fares on South Western Railway on my usual app. I had to buy the ticket through South Western Railway to get my £12 fare. Fair enough, I got a cheap ticket, but why was it not available on my regular app? Was it promoting it through its own app first? Third-party retailers need to have equal access. It has to be usable and, as we have heard, an interface that they can rely on. The other point is clearly understanding whether there is a subsidy. I am told that SNCF has a separate retail arm and that they both work differently. It needs to be looked at carefully, but an idea of an annual statement, whether publicly or through the regulator, would help provide some assurance, which the whole sector would appreciate. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s thoughts on this and whether we might see a future government amendment to tighten this up.

    View contribution permalink →

  67. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, it is difficult for me to disagree with any of the remarks made by noble Lords in this debate so far. I had an amendment in an earlier group to require the release of open data by Great British Railways, and the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, being much cleverer than me at these things, has also proposed an amendment showing how that could be made useful—not simply published, but published in a usable way. The noble Lord has also, ingeniously, proposed a mechanism that, in his view—this, of course, is something the Minister may wish to challenge—would allow a level playing field to be maintained between GBR, as retailer, and private sector retailers without having to rely on subjective considerations as in the retail policy document that has been produced. That would be a huge advantage. It would be a self-correcting mechanism. Again, it is for the Minister to say why the subjective method he has advocated is preferable to one that would, at least on the face of it, be self-correcting and not require subjective judgment. He could do that in two ways. One would be by showing that, for all its surface brilliance, the noble Lord’s proposal does not work. I would not be one to judge that but I would understand the nature of the argument he was making. The alternative would be for him to say that he thinks his own subjective judgment is better. I suspect that, when we come to hear him reply, it will be the latter. That would be a less convincing argument; indeed, I do not think it would convince anybody at all. I turn to Amendments 291A and 291B, concerning cross-subsidy and financial transparency. We also debated this earlier in Committee, but I do not believe that the Minister provided a satisfactory answer. He relied, in part, on Managing Public Money , but that is Treasury guidance; it is not a statutory prohibition on cross-subsidising GBR’s online retailer, which is what the Committee has been looking for, and does not provide an independent retailer with an enforceable statutory right to economic parity with GBR. There is also a significant issue concerning subsidy control. The Minister told the Committee earlier that the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations 2023 would be the relevant subsidy control legislation for retail. Section 48(1)(b)(iii) of the Subsidy Control Act 2022 provides that the ordinary subsidy control requirements under that Act do not apply to subsidies given in accordance with those regulations. The difficulty is that online retailing is an independent commercial activity of considerable scale, taking place in an open and competitive market. It should not simply be conflated with the wider public service obligation to provide passenger services or physical ticketing facilities. I repeat that the Subsidy Control Act does not apply if the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations do apply. It is the Government’s argument that the Subsidy Control Act does not apply; therefore, the regulations apply and the argument is that those regulations are inadequate. That is what I have been trying to say. There is an obvious distinction between maintaining ticket offices, call centres and other physical channels, which GBR may be required to provide as a public service, and operating an online retailer in direct competition with Trainline and other independent businesses. The Minister himself acknowledged in Committee that physical retail channels are substantially more expensive to provide. I think we all know that. Independent retailers generally operate on a commission of around 4.5% on most ticket sales, from which they must meet their technology, payment, fraud, customer service and other costs. Evidence to the Transport Committee described that 4.5% as the lowest cost of sale in the industry. If GBR’s online retailer is able to operate beyond comparable commercial economics because costs can be absorbed elsewhere within the wider organisation, there is a clear risk of market distortion. Without separately identifiable costs, revenues and public funding, how are the ORR, the CMA, Parliament or indeed competitors supposed to establish what is actually happening? The Minister told us in Committee that there would be 100% transparency, because GBR would put its costs into its business plan, but aggregate figures for a broad retail function are not the same as separately identifiable accounts for an online business competing directly against private companies. Amendment 330JB relates to open railway data. GBR will control important market-wide systems and data on which its competitors depend. The principle should surely be that, where data is necessary to allow independent retailers to develop products and compete effectively, they should have open and equivalent access to them. The draft retail code itself recognises that access to relevant data must be fair, transparent and non-discriminatory. That brings me to Amendment 330JD, and equal access to products, services and interfaces. Earlier in Committee, the Minister assured us that the retail code, which we had not seen at that stage, would require GBR to ensure access to products and provide services and data on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms. We have now seen the draft code, and the wording is rather narrower than that assurance might have suggested. Paragraph 6.11 applies the guarantee to “fares, products, and passenger-facing services that form a core part of the online customer offer”, and says that it applies “only where other retailers cannot reasonably provide that product or passenger-facing service independently of GBR”. Pay-as-you-go, for example, is expressly excluded. What constitutes “core” is not defined, which leaves us with some important questions. Passenger Assist is an obvious example. The Government have explicitly promised that passengers using the new GBR app will be able to buy their ticket and book Passenger Assist in the same place. Yet the draft code does not expressly mention Passenger Assist, and the Minister confirmed this again today. Independent retailers have been asking for access to the passenger assistance functionality for years. Indeed, this precise issue was raised during the Commons Committee evidence. If GBR can offer an integrated ticket and assistance service while independent retailers cannot, disabled passengers who want that function may effectively be pushed towards GBR’s own app, which would constrain customer choice. The same principle applies to future propositions such as loyalty schemes. There should be nothing wrong with GBR innovating, but if it creates a commercial loyalty offer, that offer should compete on its own economics. The concern would arise if GBR could offer comparable advantages while its cost was absorbed elsewhere. Amendment 330JD therefore ensures that when GBR’s own online retailer relies on a retail interface or market-wide functionality, competing retailers should be able to obtain equivalent access on equivalent terms. Finally, Amendment 330JC concerns transparency over the actual cost of GBR’s online retailer. We have repeatedly asked what this project will cost, here and through Written Questions. In our earlier debate, the Minister has said that much of the information remained commercially sensitive while procurement was under way and that it would be published in the usual way once available. When is it going to be available?

    View contribution permalink →

  68. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, for these amendments. He reflected, of course, on the publication of the draft code and the accompanying Office of Rail and Road consultation, which we sent out earlier in October. Let me start with Amendments 291A and 291B. The Government are committed to fair and transparent funding arrangements for GBR’s passenger services, including its retail activities. GBR’s retail activities will be funded through the wider passenger services framework in the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations 2023, which is the relevant subsidy control regime in this space, and will be reflected in GBR’s integrated business plan. Funding will be linked to specified activities and cannot exceed the net cost of delivering those obligations; nor can funding be diverted from infrastructure activities to support retail operations. The approach will be based on the principles that, as GBR will be funded to deliver its business plan, it will include retail activities; and that there should be sufficient transparency to allow parties to understand the level of funding being provided for those broader retail activities and to form a view on whether they consider that to be distortive of the market.

    View contribution permalink →

  69. Lord Harper (Con)

    May I press the Minister a little on what he has just said? I was listening to him. He said that GBR can be funded to cover its net costs. The problem with that, of course, is that, in a state body, this means that it can decide that it wants to throw a load of money at a problem, then the taxpayer happily chucks all the money in. This may mean that it has a competitive advantage over a business that has to worry about return on capital and all those sorts of things. Just saying that it can only cover its costs does not provide any reassurance to a private business at all.

    View contribution permalink →

  70. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    I just said that there will be sufficient transparency to allow parties to understand the level of funding being provided for those broader retail activities and to form a view on whether they consider that to be distortive of the market. This is important: if we are saying that we believe in a level playing field, as we are, I am saying that the business plan will show sufficient transparency for parties to understand that level of funding. Amendments 291A and 291B also seek to ensure that GBR pays its fair share towards retail systems. I assure the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, that the draft retail code of practice already contains an explicit provision requiring GBR to make a proportionate contribution towards the costs of systems and services relied on by all retailers. GBR will also be subject to competition law in discharging its functions and using public funding. It will need to act in a way that does not exclude competitors, distort the online retail market or abuse a dominant position; this includes any distortive cross-subsidisation of its retail activities. As the sector’s competition regulator, the ORR already has the powers it needs to monitor the market, obtain information and investigate concerns where they arise. It can initiate investigations through its own market monitoring or in response to complaints. Such investigations rely on detailed, case-specific information requests tailored to the circumstances of the case, rather than routine reporting exercises. The additional monitoring duty proposed by these amendments would therefore add little to the existing framework while creating an unnecessary regulatory burden. On Amendment 330JC, I agree that transparency is important. However, the level of disaggregation proposed does not reflect the nature of GBR’s integrated business. Many of GBR’s costs will be shared across activities—for example, its customer service centre will support a wide range of passenger enquiries, not just ticket sales. This will provide economies of scale reflective of its role as a public transport operator, not a retailer. The framework I have described will provide greater transparency of retail costs than exists today. However, it will not facilitate like-for-like comparisons with independent retailers because of GBR’s broader role as a passenger services operator, selling tickets across online, station and on-train retail channels. Requiring the publication of the detailed information proposed in the amendment could also reveal commercially sensitive information about GB’s resources, priorities and strategy. Independent retailers are not required to disclose equivalent information, and a fair and open market should apply as much to GBR’s retail business as to its competitors. Proper financial transparency will therefore be delivered through GBR’s wider funding and business planning framework, in a way that supports accountability while protecting commercially sensitive information.

    View contribution permalink →

  71. On amendment 330JD, I reassure the noble Lord that the Government are committed to ensuring that all retailers can access the rail products, systems, data and related services they need to be able to compete effectively in the market and deliver a high-quality service to passengers. That is why ORR’s draft retail code of practice includes fair access to products, systems and data as one of the fundamental principles that will underpin the retail market under GBR. The principle commits GBR to ensuring access is provided on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms, ensuring that all retailers will be operating on an equivalent level of back-office service to support their passenger-facing retail platforms.

    View contribution permalink →

  72. This is a significant step forward compared to today, where no such commitment exists, and has been positively received by retail industry stakeholders in their public responses to the draft code. The commitment also provides certainty to potential new market entrants, guaranteeing that there will be no second-class service for independent retailers, as has been seen in some comparator European markets. The Government therefore believe that the objectives of this amendment have already been delivered in the draft retail code of practice. Placing detailed technical solutions of the kind proposed in primary legislation is unnecessary and lacks the flexibility to adapt with the pace of technological change in an innovative market.

    View contribution permalink →

  73. On Amendment 330JB, the Government share the noble Lord’s ambition. In fact, the industry already publishes data on several of the categories listed for free, including timetables, train running, disruption, crowding and accessibility, as it has done for over a decade and this will continue. The Bill already enables GBR to disclose information wherever such disclosure supports the performance of its functions. In practice, that will allow GBR to provide an open-by-default approach, while allowing it to make responsible decisions about what should be shared, in what form and on what terms.

    View contribution permalink →

  74. Many of the categories of data that this amendment lists are of interest primarily to current or future ticket retailers. The draft retail code of practice places additional obligations on GBR to ensure that much of this data is made available to all retailers on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms, compliance with which is a condition of GBR’s licence. However, it will still be for GBR to decide how to make data available, and that flexibility matters. The amendment would impose a single approach across a wide range of data, including a universal requirement for publication without restriction, fixed technical standards and, for charging data, a 60-second deadline.

    View contribution permalink →

  75. In practice, the appropriate approach will vary between datasets. GBR will need to consider data quality, technical feasibility, security, personal data, commercial confidentiality, intellectual property and whether it has the legal right to disclose the information. GBR may also need to legitimately charge for data in some circumstances. Core railway data has long been available without charge, and we expect that to continue. However, where data has been specially processed or compiled at taxpayer expense for a particular third-party use, GBR should retain discretion to charge where appropriate.

    View contribution permalink →

  76. The Government’s approach supports useful and responsible disclosure—

    View contribution permalink →

  77. Lord Harper (Con)

    Can I challenge the Minister on that point on charging? He is right to say that, if the taxpayers, in effect, pay to create data, there should be a charge for it, but I want to test that. Would GBR’s retail operation also have to pay for that data? We established on a previous group that GBR’s passenger services operations do not have to pay for the use of GBR infrastructure in the way that a private operator does. If GBR creates some data and charges third parties for it but its retail operation does not have to pay for it and include that in its pricing, that is by definition anti-competitive. So can the Minister reassure us that, if a bit of GBR creates some data that it wishes to charge third parties for, its retail operation would also have to pay for that data on the same basis?

    View contribution permalink →

  78. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    Recalling our previous discussion, the principle is that GBR will not pay for the access but will calculate what the cost of the access is so that it can correctly account for what is happening on the network. In respect to the proposition—

    View contribution permalink →

  79. Lord Moylan (Con)

    Surely the cost will be marginal for an internal transfer of data, so what cost is being charged, compared to the price that may be charged to outside parties, for this valuable data? I remind the noble Lord that this was not the approach taken by TfL when he was the commissioner and Boris Johnson was the enlightened mayor. As the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, said, that produced very positive results.

    View contribution permalink →

  80. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    I will reflect on the proposition that has been made. The principle that I was talking about was that, generally, data will be made freely available, but there are cases where data is especially processed or compiled at taxpayers’ expense where there should be a discretion to charge. I was expecting that charge to be at least no more than it costs to create the data, and I would have thought that the principle that GBR should adopt is that it should not unnecessarily create data for its own use and, where it does, it will have to account for the cost of creating it as part of the transparency needed to make sure that GBR is not doing things for itself that it would not do in the same way for anybody else.

    View contribution permalink →

  81. Lord Harper (Con)

    I am sorry to keep pressing this point. The Minister has just answered my question, but not in a good way. I think what he said is that GBR can come up with some datasets at a cost and it would not have to charge itself as long as it was happy to disclose what it was spending in the business plan. But that is not good enough. It means that a competitor will have to pay for it and GBR gets it for free, which is not a level playing field.

    View contribution permalink →

  82. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    It has to account for it, which means that there is a cost in creating it for itself. That will have to be shown so that there is a level playing field. Our approach supports useful and responsible disclosure, backed by contractual provisions and existing legal protections. The amendment is therefore unnecessary and could cut across those safeguards. But I also believe that we are aligned in our intentions for the retail market and on open data, and I have appreciated the discussions we have just had. I will of course reflect on what has been said in this debate before Report, as noble Lords would expect.

    View contribution permalink →

  83. Lord Dixon of Jericho (LD)

    I thank the Minister. I agree with him that it feels like we are very aligned on many important aspects of this. On funding transparency in particular, we are getting closer and closer, and it feels like there is something about the ORR’s evaluation being published, predictable and regular that would satisfy most parties in the House. I welcome the opportunity to work with him in more detail on that because, again, it feels like there is definitely substantial interest across parties on that issue. On which data you publish and how, I absolutely accept that it was an amendment that was trying to say that we need to think about the use of this data and how you actually make it usable, as well as what data is published. I am so conscious that we have published a load of data in unusable formats for so many years, and there is just no need to do that if you get the legislation right. Finally, I appreciate that the Minister has been briefed on a tremendous variety of things, but I urge him to think carefully about whether we can bake in incentives to how an organisation such as GBR uses its data in a way that means we do not have to have lawyers arguing about whether or not it is discriminatory. You can design it in from the start in a way that makes it not discriminatory by design. We can do that in the way that many other organisations, sectors and Bills have done. It would be strange to deliberately create something that makes more work for lawyers, because lawyers are very overburdened and do not need more work. We have one chance to get this right. I hope that we can have more discussions about that particular aspect. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

    View contribution permalink →

  84. Amendment 291A withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  85. Amendment 291B not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  86. Clause 74 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  87. Clause 75: Miscellaneous functions of ORR

    View contribution permalink →

  88. Amendment 292 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  89. Clause 75 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  90. Clauses 76 and 77 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  91. Amendment 293

    View contribution permalink →

  92. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  93. 293: After Clause 77, insert the following new Clause— “Direct enforcement of consumer protection legislation by the ORRSchedule (Direct enforcement of consumer protection legislation by the ORR) amends Part 3 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (enforcement of consumer protection law) and Scheduleusb 5 to the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (investigatory powers etc) so as—(a) to confer further powers to enforce consumer protection legislation on the ORR, and(b) to make connected provision.”Member’s explanatory statement This new clause would introduce a new Schedule (direct enforcement of consumer protection legislation by the ORR) provided for by my related amendment.

    View contribution permalink →

  94. Amendment 293 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  95. Clauses 78 to 81 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  96. Clause 82: Duty to consult Scottish and Welsh Ministers

    View contribution permalink →

  97. Amendments 294 to 296 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  98. Clause 82 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  99. Clause 83: Duty to consult mayoral combined authorities

    View contribution permalink →

  100. Amendments 297 to 300 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  101. Clause 83 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  102. Clause 84: Duty to consult Transport for London

    View contribution permalink →

  103. Amendments 301 to 303 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  104. Clause 84 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  105. Clause 85: Advice from relevant local government bodies

    View contribution permalink →

  106. Amendment 304 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  107. Clause 85 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  108. Clause 86 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  109. Clause 87: Charging for removal etc of road vehicles

    View contribution permalink →

  110. Amendment 305 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  111. Clause 87 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  112. Clause 88: Transfer schemes made by Secretary of State

    View contribution permalink →

  113. Amendment 305ZA

    View contribution permalink →

  114. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  115. 305ZA: Clause 88, page 55, line 5, at end insert— “(1A) The Secretary of State must make a scheme for the transfer of the Historical Railways Estate from the Secretary of State to—(a) Great British Railways,(b) a company wholly owned by Great British Railways,(c) a proposed GBR,(d) a company wholly owned by a proposed GBR, or(e) a company jointly owned by two or more of the Secretary of State, the Scottish Ministers, the Welsh Ministers, Great British Railways and a proposed GBR.” Member’s explanatory statement This amendment seeks to transfer responsibility for managing the Historical Railways Estate to Great British Railways to ensure that non-operational railway structures benefit from the same engineering expertise, economies of scale and strategic decision-making as operational structures.

    View contribution permalink →

  116. Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

    My Lords, this amendment relates to the historical railways estate. In moving it, I am conscious that I am going to use what my noble friend Lord Harper has called the “Parkinson crowbar”, which is to inject something to do with the legacy of our railways into what is otherwise a rather up-to-date Bill. After the Beeching cuts and the rationalisation of the railway estate, a number of bridges, viaducts and tunnels were redundant. They remained with British Rail until privatisation. Upon privatisation, the operational parts of the railway and sites that were right for development were passed to Railtrack and then to Network Rail, and the historic estate was transferred to the British Rail residuary board. In 2013, that board was abolished and the historical railways estate of some 3,100 legacy bridges, tunnels and viaducts was transferred to the Secretary of State. Since then, the structures have been managed on behalf of the Secretary of State, first by the Highways Agency and now by National Highways. This is done under a protocol agreement which primarily seeks to “reduce the liabilities for the Secretary of State in terms of individual structure safety”.

    View contribution permalink →

  117. My amendment proposes that the estate be transferred to Network Rail and, ultimately, GBR. Network Rail currently manages 30,000 rail channels and viaducts across England, Scotland and Wales. It therefore has an asset management regime, the necessary supply chain, and deep knowledge and experience of railway structures—as opposed to highway structures—which has accrued over many decades, allowing pragmatic and proportionate decisions to be made with confidence.

    View contribution permalink →

  118. As I said, the estate currently rests with the Department for Transport and National Highways, and the briefing I have been given shows that they take a risk-averse approach towards its management. The default position of the department is that any reuse must involve a transfer of ownership to another statutory body, whereas the residuary body was content to lease structures to other bodies for use with inactive travel schemes and cycle routes, for example, sharing maintenance costs.

    View contribution permalink →

  119. The DfT is reluctant to transfer legacy structures to heritage railways, even those with a long-standing track record of being good custodians of such structures, as mentioned by my noble friend Lord Parkinson and the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner. This approach has condemned many bridges, tunnels and viaducts with the potential for alternative use to a fate of perpetual decline, often resulting in demolition or infilling. This means that the social and economic benefits that could otherwise have been enjoyed are lost. I do not think this is good governance.

    View contribution permalink →

  120. In 2021, the Transport Select Committee in the other place criticised National Highways’ stewardship. It urged the department to stop viewing the disused bridges, tunnels and viaducts as financial risks and called for them instead to be used as valuable public assets to be preserved, maintained and enjoyed, rather than filling the bridges with aggregate and sealing them.

    View contribution permalink →

  121. I come now to what is known as the Great Musgrave Bridge controversy—I see the Minister perking up at that mention. The infilling of a masonry arch bridge in Great Musgrave, in Cumbria, became a major flashpoint. Eden District Council rejected National Highways’ retrospective planning application and ordered the agency to remove 1,600 tonnes of concrete and then restore the original structure, at a public cost of several hundreds of thousands of pounds. I have been given other examples of bridges in Hertfordshire and tunnels in Wales where this risk-averse approach of a body not set up to manage heritage railway structures has meant lost opportunities for imaginative reuse. Some have even accused National Highways of cultural vandalism.

    View contribution permalink →

  122. Its remit is to make structures safe and to minimise the liability of the Secretary of State. I would argue that this is a rather narrow approach and risks precluding other options. Noble Lords should be aware that other options are available—even National Highways has done some good examples, if you look at its website. If we transferred the estate back to GBR, there could be some economies of scale and improved decision-making, which would result in better overall value for the taxpayer. In addition to a transfer of responsibility, there needs to be a change of culture from the top to avoid this risk-averse approach.

    View contribution permalink →

  123. Amendment 312, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Leaman, is along the same lines and has my strong support. I understand that none of her options would preclude the subsequent reuse of the track as a railway should that then become possible.

    View contribution permalink →

  124. I note that the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, has Amendment 330JE. This is a rerun of the debate we had some time ago on whether roscos would be classified as public bodies. It may be, subject to what the ONS decides, that the ambition of the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, of taking the roscos into public ownership may be done, as it were, in a less public way, through the ONS simply deciding that, due to the degree of control exercised by the Secretary of State over roscos, they are, in effect, a national body, rather like Network Rail, and so they would be reclassified. It may be the case that the noble Baroness’s ambitions are met by the ONS, without the need for legislation. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  125. Viscount Stansgate (Lab)

    My Lords, I will not detain the Committee—

    View contribution permalink →

  126. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    Good.

    View contribution permalink →

  127. Viscount Stansgate (Lab)

    As the noble Baroness is obviously very keen to contribute, I will make way almost immediately. The noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, has made a good case. I hope that when my noble friend the Minister comes to wind up, he will recognise that this is a Bill about the railways and that, as I am minded to believe, when it comes to the stewardship of the historical railways estate, any body other than National Highways, especially one connected to the railways such as the new body being set up, would be a better steward of the estate than others.

    View contribution permalink →

  128. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    My Lords, I apologise to the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate. I forget that the microphones are on all the time and pick up even whispers. I admire all noble Lords who are fully engaged in the Bill; I am finding it extremely difficult to listen to every word. For example, I salute the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, who has been listening to every word and has barely looked at his phone more than a few times. A few words have percolated through. For example, the noble Lord, Lord Harper, mentioned green infrastructure—at ports, I think—without spitting, and I was delighted by that. Perhaps we could talk about it another time. To paraphrase his long explanation about Henry VIII and “Doctor Who”, I think he meant that we must get this right the first time, which is what the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, also talked about. I heartily agree with that. I thank the Minister for sending me a letter on designation. It threw up a few more questions, which I should perhaps send to him in writing rather than putting it all in Hansard now. On Amendment 330JE, as far as I am concerned the private leasing of our trains is one of the great scandals of rail privatisation. It should not have been done. One of the big questions for this Bill and all the Government’s rail policies so far is: why have they focused on the nationalisation of rail services only, not the trains themselves? I note what the noble Lord, Lord Young, mentioned just now. Let us put it in the Bill; let us get it right and make it completely clear. The cost of leasing and maintaining these trains is about a third of the day-to-day running costs of the railway: over £4 billion in 2024. That does not sound like good business to me. The rate of profit extraction is notorious. The trade union ASLEF estimates that the private rolling stock companies have extracted £2.9 billion in profits and dividends over the last five years. A recent report from the Office of Rail and Road states that the roscos’ profit margins fluctuate between 5% and 31%. Perhaps we could all have that profit margin. This level of profit extraction is happening because we are locked into what is essentially a dysfunctional market in which there is no real choice and where interventions to fix the competitive market have repeatedly failed. This wasteful system now passes to GBR, unless something is done to stop it. There is at least some good news. At Labour’s conference last month, the Transport Secretary announced that GBR would consider public ownership for all new rolling stock. This commitment was made in the Government’s new Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strategy , published on the same day. This was a welcome announcement, but it is not enough. Governments will come and go, whereas fixing this wasteful system will take decades. The commitment belongs in the Railways Bill, not merely a strategy document. It would be an unforgiveable missed opportunity to announce this new policy direction while passing up the chance to secure it in law. This is the intention behind my amendment on the ownership and financing of new rolling stock. This amendment reflects exactly what the Labour Government have said in their new Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strateg y . It would require GBR to assess public ownership whenever it orders new trains, looking at cost and value over their whole life and across the railway. It does not dictate the outcome but would ensure that GBR asks this question and always chooses the best option for taxpayers. This is the absolute minimum that should be done, and a direct challenge to the Government—so will they put their money where their mouth is? Moving on, Amendment 330JF goes further than the Government’s policy pledge. It would establish a clear goal: to “increase progressively the proportion” of publicly owned rolling stock, and it would require GBR to publish and implement a strategy to achieve that. The amendment then distinguishes between new and existing trains. New trains procured for GBR passenger services must be publicly owned. For existing trains, GBR must assess public ownership options “before entering into, renewing or extending a lease” or “committing to its major refurbishment or life extension”. That is a requirement to properly assess other options, not a requirement to buy the existing trains. Major refurbishments and life extensions can involve substantial amounts of public money. Before committing that money, surely we should ask whether continuing to lease and refurbish these trains offers the best long-term value, or whether there is another approach that would make better use of taxpayers’ money. The point here is to establish a systemic approach to assessing “whole-life” and “whole-system” costs and value—to use the Government’s words in their recent strategy document—not simply asking what costs least today but asking what makes best use of taxpayers’ money over the decades ahead. These assessments would not remain behind closed doors. GBR would have to publish them, explain the resulting decisions and recommendations, and report annually on progress. We need to move beyond one lease renewal at a time with no clear destination. This amendment would give us both a long-term plan and a transparent process for assessing the options. First and foremost, it would strengthen the quality and accountability of GBR’s decision-making, while bringing much-needed direction to this wasteful and discredited market. To conclude on both amendments, it is truly a time of reckoning for the private leasing of rolling stock. There is one further issue which requires a detailed explanation from the Minister. This concerns the Office for National Statistics, which is preparing to review the status of rolling stock leases. This creates a real possibility that the assets and loan liabilities could be brought on to the public balance sheet. As I understand it, it would mean that the debt and liabilities will appear on the public ledger, reducing the Government’s capacity for borrowing even while the legal ownership and profits from rolling stock remain private. Will the Minister explain what that will mean for reported public debt and the Government’s fiscal rules? Has the Treasury assessed the implications, and will it publish that assessment? I see that the noble Lord, Lord Young, thinks he probably knows the answer to that. Perhaps not. If private leasing no longer keeps those liabilities off the public balance sheet, what remains of that argument against public ownership? This appears potentially to be a serious issue, and I would appreciate a clear written response plus reassurance that these issues are being properly considered in time for making decisions on the Bill. I look forward to the Minister’s detailed response. I move on to Clause 95 on the Luxembourg rail protocol, which I oppose in full. This clause would give powers to the Secretary of State to implement the 2007 Luxembourg protocol to the Cape Town convention. The stated intention of the protocol is to reduce private sector financing costs by strengthening roscos’ and lenders’ rights to cross-border enforcement. All this really seems to be is an expansion of private law jurisdiction and globalisation, entrenching the market power of roscos and the big banks behind them. Did I hear some criticism in the audience here?

    View contribution permalink →

  129. Lord Harper (Con)

    No. I confess that, when I looked at the amendments and the Bill, I was not enormously sure what those things were. The more she talks about how dreadful they are, the more she is recommending them to me.

    View contribution permalink →

  130. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    On a different issue, I want to correct the record on Boris Johnson as mayor. He was not enlightened; he was chaotic and inconsistent. That really ought to go into Hansard . That is my only bite back at the noble Lord, Lord Harper, who I am sure was a great friend of Boris Johnson.

    View contribution permalink →

  131. Lord Harper (Con)

    No, actually.

    View contribution permalink →

  132. Lord Moylan (Con)

    The noble Baroness was great friend to Boris Johnson at one stage, I recall.

    View contribution permalink →

  133. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    I got on with him; that is not the same thing. Looking at the impact assessment of the Railways Bill, it seems the Government are uncertain there will be any benefits from this implementation. In fact, Eversholt, one of the three big private roscos in the UK, objects to the protocol, saying in 2024 that it did not believe it “would attract additional private sector investment or reduce financing costs” and that it was “concerned that ratification … would lead to increased costs and add an unnecessary layer of administration”. Even if there were savings for roscos, what reassurance would there be that they would pass these on to the public sector? Absolutely none. In fact, this is the last thing they are likely to do in such a concentrated market which, as we already know, means unrestrained profit extraction. Next, the protocol’s international reputation is frankly embarrassing. Despite being open for signature for 20 years, it has gained just seven parties, taking a shocking 17 years to come into force due to the lack of international interest. By contrast, its sister agreement, the Cape Town aircraft protocol, gained 87 parties in this time. Furthermore, the UK’s signature dates back to 2016, before the Brexit referendum. Would we make the same decision now, given the vastly different circumstances, and without the involvement of the EU? Finally, to address the issue of public ownership, why would the Government sign up to an instrument that entrenches the logic of private financing globalisation just at the time they have said they want to move towards privately owned rolling stock? Although the protocol would not directly prevent public ownership, it could raise the cost, litigation risk and practical barriers and increase the roscos’ market power. I realise I have gone over time, but I have been answering a few interventions. It could also worsen the chilling effect where public authorities know that policy changes and market interventions in rolling stock could trigger stronger legal claims. Why has the Luxembourg rail protocol been included in this Bill? What is the rational argument for it? It is hard to find anyone endorsing it except private law firms and a Switzerland-based lobbying group representing the main private law institution behind the protocol. Please, just take it out. It is utterly illogical. I still have another page but never mind. I will just say that all my amendments are worth passing.

    View contribution permalink →

  134. Lord Berkeley (Lab)

    My Lords, that was a very interesting speech by the noble Baroness. The Luxembourg protocol is something I have been working with for years on rail freight because, maybe unlike with the lovely high-speed trains we have here, there has been a history of rail freight wagons perhaps going to far off places such as Italy and not coming back. Of course, the owners of these wagons stand to lose quite a lot of money. Italy has, more recently, I think, got better. But I think with some of the eastern European countries, whether it is because of the Ukraine war or other things, those who finance things need some guarantee. The noble Baroness can say it will all be done by the Government, so it does not really matter. But most rail freight wagons are financed in the private sector and obviously the people doing that require some guidance as to the guarantees they will get if they get stolen. Through this protocol, there is now an international registry called URVIS, based in Luxembourg, to identify all wagons with a unique number and, I hope, keep track of them. It is easy to say they are only wagons and you can get lots of other wagons, but the modern freight wagon is a very sophisticated piece of kit and has developed over time so you can carry heavier loads faster right across Europe. What we are really talking about is the wagons which operate in the UK and on the continent. What the protocol says that it is going to do—I think it has already started to do it—is to allow default remedies, such as expedited relief, asset transfer and export on debtor default or insolvency. It does not cost us anything, but it cannot fully operate until a large number of countries, not just in the European Union but in other places, have signed up to it. I do not see any downside at all. The Government have, bless their heart, for the last five years been trying to find a way of fitting this provision into some suitable legislation, which suits the Luxembourg people, the Treasury and the Government. They appear to have found it in this Bill—and congratulations. I strongly oppose the view expressed by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, that this is a waste of time. It is actually very useful for the international rail freight sector, and it could also be useful if there were more passenger trains—it is a guarantee. I fully support the measure in the Bill, in Clause 95.

    View contribution permalink →

  135. Baroness Leaman (LD)

    My Lords, Amendment 312 in my name would establish a rails-to-trails programme, a framework to help councils and community groups to acquire disused railway lines, a long-term fund to convert them, and fair compensation for landowners. My aim today is to understand the Government’s plans for the old railway lines that Great British Railways is about to inherit. The amendment follows a new clause tabled in the Commons by my honourable friend Olly Glover, who argued that these routes could offer paths kept well away from traffic. The economic case is strong: Active Travel England’s analysis finds that walking and cycling seems to typically return between £3.50 and £19 for every pound spent. Few transport investments can boast that. I would like to dwell briefly on a benefit that is often missed. Time spent in the great outdoors in our beautiful British countryside does us all a lot of good. Arguably, this matters most for young people at a time when we are seeing growing evidence of rising mental ill health among them. Too much of that countryside remains closed to anyone who cannot climb a stile or scrabble up a rocky slope, which is where old railway lines provide such a wonderful opportunity. They were engineered for steam engines that could not cope with hills, so they are flat, gently graded and generally straight. For a wheelchair user, someone on a hand bike or a mobility scooter, or even a parent with a buggy, that is often going to be the difference between an afternoon spent outside in the countryside or an afternoon merely looking at it through a window. But it is a benefit that can be easily squandered. A path that is perfectly level for 10 miles is of no use at all if every access point has steps, a kissing gate or a barrier designed to stop motorbikes that also stops wheelchairs. So accessible entrances would need to be built into any programme from the start and not added as an afterthought. In the Commons, the Minister spoke warmly of the path from Selby to York and confirmed that the historical railways estate will pass to GBR, which will be expected to look for ways to reuse redundant land. I welcome that and have three questions which I would be grateful if the Minister could address. First, will GBR be told to weigh active travel, including access for disabled people, fairly against housing and commercial uses before it disposes of land? Secondly, will local communities be consulted before a line is sold? Thirdly, where a line might one day reopen, could it serve as a trail in the meantime, protecting a corridor rather than losing it? I look forward to the Minister’s reply.

    View contribution permalink →

  136. Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

    I support the views of my noble friend Lord Stansgate in support of the amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham. I am looking forward to the Minister’s reply, which I am sure I will find totally convincing, but the issue is important, so I hope that he will offer some sort of positive approach to what has been discussed. I want to say a word on Amendment 312. There is a concern about ex-railway lines, and there should be a presumption in practice, and possibly in legislation, that they will be returned to railway use. I support the principle of Amendment 312: we wish to encourage the development of footpaths, and it is quite right that a footpath along an old railway track would provide an easy approach to walking. But sometimes organisations representing walkers—I will probably be shot down for saying this—can get very possessive. For example, when the proposal was made to reinstate the Welsh Highland Railway through the Aberglaslyn Pass—one of the country’s top tourist attractions—the walking lobby argued strongly that it should be retained as a footpath rather than being restored as a railway. I am just asking my noble friend the Minister to assure us that the general approach of policy is to exert that the prime purpose—the ultimate objective—with disused railways is to reinstate them. We have seen the vast success of the Northumberland line, among others, so the presumption should be their return to use as a railway.

    View contribution permalink →

  137. Lord Hampton (CB)

    My Lords, in speaking to Amendments 330A and 330B in my name, I promise not to mention the Luxembourg protocol once. Oh, I did. If your Lordships were to turn left out of the school where I teach, go under the railway bridge and turn left again, they would get to Andre Street. It has railway arches down one side—it is a wonderful Hackney Street. It is vibrant, and the railway arches are full of car repair shops and respray places. There is a prop maker and all sorts of people down there. It is safe for the students who walk down—it is the main way to Hackney Downs—late at night or when it is dark, when they are perhaps returning from sports events or coming out of detentions. At least, that was the case a year ago. Since then, several of the arches have been refurbished and the rest have gradually shut down because of rent increases. Andre Street is now empty, graffiti covered and rubbish strewn. It is a danger for a child to walk down. We have lost a vital community hub, and I am willing to bet that, for every yard of coffee shops or microbreweries in Hackney, there are 10 streets like Andre Street now, which have just become deserts. I have tabled Amendment 330B because, as the freeholder, we need to know what GBR will be taking on and that it will do its job to make money but also to serve the community. I am going to take your Lordships on another journey with Amendment 330A, by rail this time, to Hampton Court. At the approach to Hampton Court station, your Lordships will see a crumbling ruin covered in scaffolding. Is this something medieval, a motte or a bailey? In fact, it is Hampton Court station, which was built in 1837 and is now in ruins. This was part of a scheme between Railtrack and a private developer that was first submitted in 1985 to Elmbridge Council. Outline permission was granted but, then due to poor viability, was scrapped. Schemes were also submitted to Elmbridge in 1987, 1990—

    View contribution permalink →

  138. The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Faulkner of Worcester) (Lab)

    I apologise for interrupting the noble Lord, but a Division has been called in the Chamber. The Committee will adjourn for 10 minutes.

    View contribution permalink →

  139. Sitting suspended for a Division in the House.

    View contribution permalink →

  140. Lord Hampton (CB)

    My Lords, I left noble Lords on a cliffhanger, so I remind those with slightly short memories that we were at Hampton Court station, gazing at a crumbling edifice and wondering what it was. We discovered that it was, in fact, Hampton Court station, which was under Railtrack. Private developers have been trying to develop it: the first plan was submitted by Network Rail and a developer to Elmbridge Borough Council in 1985, but it did not progress. Schemes were also submitted to Elmbridge in 1987, 1990, 1995, 2007 and 2008. In October 2024, permission was finally granted, but then it failed the viability test. As Andrew Roberts of the Hampton Court Rescue Campaign said recently, the campaign has accepted that the current scheme is not viable and has submitted a variation to reduce the car park from 207 spaces to 93 spaces—a total disaster for residents and rail users. He said that, in terms of a railway mandate to provide capital to fund rail infrastructure and housing, it could not be a worse scheme, with very nominal capital and a small number of seven-figure-value houses for millionaires. Hampton Court station has been falling down for 40 years. The first view of Hampton Court that visitors get is of a load of scaffolding, hoardings, litter and rats. Neither the House of Lords Library nor I could find a list of the projects and ongoing planning applications in which Railtrack or Platform4 are involved but, as with the rent reviews, we need to know, before GBR takes on this stuff, what it is taking on.

    View contribution permalink →

  141. Lord Grayling (Con)

    My Lords, I support the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham. This transition is long overdue. I understand why the historic rail estate is in the hands of National Highways, but it should not have been so for this long, and it is absolutely time for it to return to the railway world. It needs to do so for three reasons, in my view. The first is that I absolutely buy the argument that it should be protected for the future development, first, of the historical railway. Many historic railway lines are looking to extend their routes, have started work and have saved money—but they have long-term ambitions that may take another decade or more to come to fruition. It would be an absolute travesty if the opportunity to achieve that growth were lost because of ill-advised planning decisions or land sales now. So the first key reason is to protect the ability of the historic railway to continue to grow, develop and be the success story it has been for the last two generations.

    View contribution permalink →

  142. Secondly, on a practical note, areas of the historic estate will have a potential role in the future. Although most of the country branch lines that were closed by Dr Beeching will not have a role for the railways in the future, some lines clearly will. Both I and my noble friend Lord Harper as Secretaries of State started the ball rolling on reopening some routes. I mentioned the Okehampton line. Of course, the initial ones are on track beds that have survived and are of use, and there will be others that, as the need for rail grows—as I believe it will in the future—give opportunities to extend, reopen and develop. There was a disused line in Birmingham that I assigned to the Mayor of the West Midlands to expand the tram system there, which will be another area where the historic railway may have a future role in the current public transport system. So that is the second important area.

    View contribution permalink →

  143. The third area goes back to our debate a little while back on amendments proposed by the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, about Network Rail’s and, going forward, Great British Railways’ responsibility on biodiversity. These routes are hotbeds of biodiversity in many areas. They need to be protected. I absolutely agree with the noble Baroness that, in some places, it is right and proper that they are used as walking and cycling routes. Equally, they need to be protected because they are one of the havens in the countryside for a variety of species.

    View contribution permalink →

  144. I want to see the role that Great British Railways will play in maintaining biodiversity, which the Minister assured us about in those debates, extended to the historic estate to fulfil that part of its potential. In a country that needs to do more to enhance and restore biodiversity, that estate can play an important part. The Minister has assured us that Great British Railways will play its part in that, and this estate should be a part of that. So, in every respect, this transition should happen. I hope that, if the Minister does not accept my noble friend Lord Young’s amendment, he will give a clear categoric assurance that this transition will happen.

    View contribution permalink →

  145. Lord Harper (Con)

    My Lords, I will speak relatively briefly on five of the amendments in this group and the clause stand part debate. I support my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham’s amendment. He is right on the risk-averse piece and about wanting to ensure that, as those assets are managed, the same economies of scale and expertise are available to them as are available to the operational estate. Bringing as many of those assets into useful operation as possible is a good ambition to have, so I support his amendment. I also support Amendment 323 in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan, which is about ensuring that there is a published rolling stock investment framework. I hope that there will be a lot of shared agreement on this. We started the process, albeit at an early stage, of publishing some of the rolling stock programme. The Minister has taken it a bit further, and I think the Government have plans to do that. So, even if this amendment is not quite to his liking, having a commitment in statute to publish the long-term rolling stock plan would be very good and would provide a lot of confidence to the industry. So I welcome my noble friend’s amendment. There will be a useful debate off the back of it, and we can listen to what the Minister’s plans are as we think about what we formulate for Report. Those are all the bits where I can be positive, but I am afraid there are three amendments where I am a bit less positive. I am positive about quite a lot of Amendment 330H, but not all of it. The one thing that I would counsel a bit of caution on is the electrification programme, which is generally a very good thing. The problem is with the specificity, as it says that there has to be full electrification of the network. It depends what you mean by the network, but I think we debated at a prior stage that there are bits of the network on which trying to electrify the route with overhead cables would make no sense from a cost and engineering perspective. There are other ways of electrifying the network in terms of its operation—for example, having trains powered by batteries where there are no overhead cables. If the electricity to charge them has come from sustainable sources, that may be excellent. The thrust of the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, is fine—

    View contribution permalink →

  146. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    Would the Minister give way—sorry, not the Minister?

    View contribution permalink →

  147. Lord Harper (Con)

    Of course, absolutely. Freudian slip.

    View contribution permalink →

  148. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    I totally agree about the batteries. The only thing is that you have to look at the lifetime cost of all these things. It might be cheaper in the long run to put in the infrastructure for electricity rather than to try to use batteries. There could be all sorts of other problems associated with them. It is best to keep an open mind if one is thinking about the long term.

    View contribution permalink →

  149. Lord Harper (Con)

    I will overlook the Freudian slip, although I think it was more offensive to the Minister than to me.

    View contribution permalink →

  150. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    It has been noted.

    View contribution permalink →

  151. Lord Harper (Con)

    He has noted it; that will count against her at some point. On keeping an open mind, I completely agree with her. The problem with the amendment as drafted is that saying full electrification of the network is not keeping an open mind. At least, it is arguably tying the Minister’s hands about how you deliver electrification. But the thrust of it is absolutely fine. I have a bit more of an issue with Amendments 330JE and 330JF, which are what I might call her anti-rolling stock amendments, because that it what they seem to be. They are a bit contradictory. Amendment 330JE is attempting to pretend to be neutral by saying that Ministers have to consider the whole life and whole system costs and manage all that. They basically have to choose direct public ownership where that assessment says that it is better. However, Amendment 330JF basically says that the Secretary of State and GBR have to use their functions to progressively increase the proportion of the railway rolling stock that is publicly owned. It does not have anything in it about whether that is actually good value or not. That does not seem to make any sense to me. It basically says they just have to have it all owned by the public, even if it is a terrible deal, and that makes no sense. I suspect that the noble Baroness reached that slightly contradictory conclusion because it sounded from her analysis that she used as her single source of truth the well-known reasonably neutral arbiters of these things, the ASLEF rail union. In my experience, it is not awfully neutral about anything, and I would not necessarily take it as the only source of whether you should or should not have private capital involved in the rail industry. Its view is that it wants everything nationalised. I am afraid that is because that is the model in which they it has the most power to jack up wages at the expense of the passenger and exact that power over Ministers. I do not think that is a very good idea for passengers. I would not use ASLEF as the best sort of source of information about financing railway assets.

    View contribution permalink →

  152. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    This is something that I have believed for a long time. It is just that ASLEF agrees with me.

    View contribution permalink →

  153. Lord Harper (Con)

    Very good. That is perhaps slightly better, but it does not make the argument any more compelling. The central bit that is completely missing—I am sure the Minister will say this—is the fact that the Government and the public sector do not have an infinite supply of capital. In the real world, the one we live in, the Government have choices about borrowing money and what they spend it on. I am afraid that if we adopted the model that the noble Baroness set out, the railway rolling stock would be competing for taxpayer-funded government capital against the capital available to build schools, hospitals and other public assets. The evidence from the past is that trains are not the winners in those competitive processes, which is exactly why we had privately financed rolling stock in the first place. When we had privatisation—I see my noble friend Lord Young nodding—we had massive investment in new rolling stock and better and more modern trains, which would never have happened if it had all been funded by taxpayer-funded capital. The reason for the returns that the noble Baroness talked about—she cited ASLEF’s figures on the money “extracted”—is the fact that capital has a cost. To access capital, you have to pay for it. There is a risk attached to it, and that has to be paid for by somebody: either the private sector taking these risks or the taxpayer. You cannot just wish it away. The noble Baroness is right in saying that the Secretary of State had in her party-political conference speech a throwaway line about looking at this. However, I suspect—I may be wrong—that a small number of people in the department are doing a bit of work, the conclusion of which, in due course, will be that they are going to stick with the current model, and that that will be slipped out quietly, as opposed to the party-political announcement to cheer up the Labour troops at conference. I do not expect the Minister to comment on that either way, but I suspect that that is what happened and I would not put too much weight on there being a solution that requires the taxpayer to fund it all. Finally, I have to confess that I have not spent lot of time on Clause 95, which is the subject of a stand part notice, but when I had a look at the two things that the noble Baroness refers to, they sounded like a fantastic idea. The Cape Town convention gets rid of legal inconsistency, lowers costs and has good insolvency protections for mobile assets, which seems a very good thing to do. I am amazed that she is against the Luxembourg rail protocol, because it establishes a global legal framework to make it easier and cheaper to finance trains, trams and other railway equipment, thus making it more likely that we can invest and shift people from roads to rail, supporting the green transition and net-zero goals. I would have thought that the noble Baroness would be in favour of all those things. Clause 95 should absolutely stay in the Bill, and I hope that that is what the Minister says when he responds.

    View contribution permalink →

  154. Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

    My Lords, I will speak first to Amendment 309 in my name, which would establish a new funding mechanism for local authorities to bid for central government funding for feasibility studies on, or the construction of, new stations, railways or other enhancements. It is important that we continue to have a pipeline of projects and that local authorities can secure funding for feasibility studies to help make improvements to the railway in their area. It is a simple ask to ensure a regular fund to keep improving and investing in the railway. Amendment 310 sits alongside this and would require the Secretary of State to review the restoring your railway fund announced by the previous Government in February 2020. I understand that this was a £500 million programme which delivered 11 miles of reopened line and two new stations. We believe that it would be beneficial for the Secretary of State to undertake a review of the now cancelled restoring your railway fund to understand what worked and what did not work for future projects and funds. My noble friend Baroness Leaman’s Amendment 312 would require the Government to turn disused railways into active travel paths where appropriate. This is so important if we are to encourage people to use greener forms of transport. If paths are protected and accessible they often feel safer for newer cyclists and pedestrians. I have cycled on one down in Whitstable, the Crab and Winkle Way, which follows the path of the historic Canterbury to Whitstable Railway. The part that is on the old railway line feels very safe. This “rails to trails” programme would create the potential for communities to more easily acquire disused railway lines and turn them into walking and cycling routes. Some disused railways are no longer owned by railway organisations, but some are. This new clause would facilitate acquisitions so that we can create more segregated travel facilities where they are appropriate.

    View contribution permalink →

  155. On the other amendments in this debate, the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, has made some strong points about the historic railways estate. I welcome that amendment and the reminder of that point about the ONS when we start talking about rolling stock, which came up so many weeks ago that I had forgotten about it. It is a really important point—we may see our rolling stock, effectively, on the public books. The noble Baroness, Lady Jones, made a point about wanting public ownership of the rolling stock. We must understand that a train could operate for 35 years or more. Some London Underground trains have been operating for over 50 years and will need major refurbishments, reliability improvements, accessibility enhancements and so on. It is important that whoever owns that rolling stock can provide continuous investment throughout a train’s lifetime. We have seen this from some of the roscos in recent years. One of them, Porterbrook, funded a £100 million-plus investment to upgrade some of the trains on GTR, including Southern Railway trains. That is just one example. This is serious money.

    View contribution permalink →

  156. I heard the announcement from the Secretary of State at the recent Labour conference. I wonder whether she was referring to EUROFIMA, a European body that provides alternative funding financial solutions for public passenger railways. I have asked questions about this to the Minister previously. Can he update us on that? There is a real challenge. Previously in Committee, the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, talked about the challenges of securing rolling stock when you are the Transport Secretary—as he was many decades ago—and up against everyone else. From looking at other projects, such as the pause to the Midland main line electrification in the last spending review, we know that the Government are strapped for cash. We must look very carefully to make sure that we can keep upgrading and investing in our rolling stock, whether through private companies, the roscos, or other organisations such as EUROFIMA. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

    View contribution permalink →

  157. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, I have no intention of going over the broad range of topics that have been raised in this debate. I will make just a couple of remarks. I say to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, that just because something has “Euro” in it does not make it inherently attractive. It is not an EU body, but even when we were in the European Union we never used finance from EUROFIMA. I do not know why that was but, assuming that the Department for Transport and the train operating companies are reasonably rational, there must be something wrong about it, which means that we have more attractive sources of finance.

    View contribution permalink →

  158. Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

    I understand that EUROFIMA is available only to publicly owned passenger railways. Therefore, it would not have been available previously whether we were a member of the EU or not.

    View contribution permalink →

  159. Lord Moylan (Con)

    In any event, it has been in existence for very much longer than the privatisation of the railways here and we never made use of it, as far as I am aware, so my point stands. The point from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, about financing rolling stock was dealt with comprehensively by my noble friend Lord Harper, so I will not go back on that. It is relevant, though, to say that I have a friend, now retired, who ran a branch of a foreign bank in London. Wondering what it could do that would make it some money, that being quite difficult in London where there are a lot of banks, it went into the business of aircraft lease financing. It would finance aircraft. Its great problem was that if the owner of the aircraft decided that they did not want to pay—noble Lords would be surprised at how many people decide that they do not want to pay, especially for private planes—they simply fly the plane away to a different jurisdiction. He had a hit squad of people who would try to immobilise planes on the ground while they were still in a jurisdiction where action could be taken, because there were jurisdictions where one could not take action. Admittedly, the movement of rolling stock and railway carriages is rather less dramatic than taking off and flying a plane off into the blue yonder; there is a need for connected tracks that will take you somewhere else. I have to admit, I imagine that the Cape Town protocol and so on are rather more valuable in continents such as Africa, where freight wagons that start out in Bloemfontein might end up in Ouagadougou, and you would never know quite how you were going to get them back—or they might wander into a war zone in northern Nigeria; heaven knows what you would do then. However, it is less likely that our rolling stock is going to wander all over the continent, given that we have only one fixed link. None the less, there can be no harm in bringing this in, I think. I hope that the noble Baroness agrees—unless she was thinking of hijacking a train and heading off to the continent and beyond, in which case I can see why she might be opposed to this.

    View contribution permalink →

  160. Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

    Never say never.

    View contribution permalink →

  161. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Amendments 321, 322 and 323 will occupy the rest of my remarks. Amendment 321 would establish a long-term rolling stock leasing framework with a presumption in favour of longer lease terms and greater consideration of whole-life costs. Amendment 322 would require GBR to publish a rolling 15-year pipeline of infrastructure and rolling stock works, including renewals, enhancements, signalling, major station works, and rolling stock procurement and refurbishment. Amendment 323 would require a 15-year rolling stock investment framework, setting out future requirements for new trains, refurbishments, decarbonisation and accessibility, as well as, importantly, the opportunities for continued private investment in rolling stock. If these amendments are to exist—that is a matter for the Government to decide—they should be part of an understandable, long-term framework. These amendments have become even more relevant following the publication of the Government’s Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strategy on 28 September. We have had only a few weeks to consider that document, and we have certainly not had the opportunity for the detailed parliamentary scrutiny that a strategy of this importance deserves. There are, however, some important questions already. The first relates to the question of where the pipeline is. The strategy talks about giving the supply chain greater certainty, but it does not itself provide the detailed forward pipeline of procurements that the industry needs. Instead, there will be a fleet and infrastructure plan, which will remain an internal planning tool, and “appropriate information” will subsequently be shared with the market; that is considerably less certainty than my Amendment 322 would provide. In its report, Rail Investment Pipelines: Ending Boom and Bust , the House of Commons Transport Committee found: “Fluctuating investment increases costs and undermines efficiency”, whereas a “steady pipeline … enables suppliers to plan, retain skills and innovate”. It warned of future “cliff edges” for the rail supply chain and concluded that future investment needs to be “steady, carefully sequenced and clearly communicated”. Secondly, the strategy raises—this was mentioned earlier—important questions around who will own the trains. I do not object in principle to the idea that the Government should procure trains. When I was the deputy chairman of Transport for London, I arranged for 1,000 new Routemaster buses—the so-called Boris buses—to be acquired directly by TfL because we could not get an appropriate lease deal. There are times when direct acquisition is appropriate, but it has certain adverse consequences. We, the supply chain and the finance sector need to know. Frankly, it is not responsible of the Secretary of State for Transport to throw out ideas on a political party platform if she is going to make a change. I do not dispute her right to make a change to government procurement policy in this regard, although it has consequences, but this is a ridiculous way of behaving—one that undermines the very sense of certainty and commitment that we all think is so important. I very much hope that my amendments, which my noble friend Lord Harper spoke in favour of—I am very grateful to him—commend themselves to the Minister. In essence, the Government’s attitude in relation to the Bill is, “We will tell you in good time what is good for you”. We and the Transport Select Committee think that we have some ideas on what is good for the railways. This is one of those ideas: long-term planning; a long-term infrastructure pipeline; and a long-term procurement pipeline, in particular for rolling stock. These things should be right at the heart of the Bill and the Government should be willing to commit to them, or they will leave us in a position where we are constantly being asked to trust them. That is not really how parliamentary democracy works.

    View contribution permalink →

  162. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    My Lords, this is the Minister replying, in case there was any doubt about that. If I may, I want to indulge the Committee by correcting what I said about Amendment 330JB in our debate on a previous group, in a response to an intervention by the noble Lord, Lord Harper. GBR will pay if it requires data that is specifically formatted in a way other than what is generally available; I thought that that would be a helpful correction to make. In response to the next intervention from the noble Lord, Lord Harper, on access charges for infrastructure— they are different to retail data, but they were raised in that context—GBR will factor the costs that it would have paid into its pricing for other operators. I hope that those are both useful corrections, and I am sorry that I was not quick enough to make them in our debate on the previous group. I shall start with Clause 95 and the Luxembourg rail protocol, which is an international agreement that is designed to provide more security to those financing rolling stock overseas. It establishes a new legal framework for the creation and registration of international interests and rolling stock, meaning that, in effect, creditors can ensure that their assets will be recognised by legal processes in participating countries. This makes financing the rolling stock overseas more attractive by ensuring that, in the event of insolvency or default, a creditor can pursue their interests without fear of being at the mercy of an overseas legal system. If the UK did not ratify the protocol, the UK would be a less attractive place for overseas creditors to invest in rolling stock, meaning that we could miss out on investment. Also, UK creditors would not benefit from the protections afforded by it, meaning that investment costs would be higher. As more countries ratify the protocol, the UK will become less competitive for investment. In addition, the industry is generally supportive of the ratification protocol, although I note what the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, said about rolling stock. More importantly, the protocol is not a barrier to the future rolling stock ownership models for GBR. It costs the Government nothing to ratify it, and the protocol does not prevent public ownership of rolling stock. I am delighted to agree with my noble friend Lord Berkeley for once: Clause 95 is a good thing. I will write to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, on EUROFIMA because I cannot currently remember what the position is. While on that topic, I turn to Amendments 321, 323, 330J and 330JF. I agree with the principles of Amendments 321 and 323, because rolling stock decisions should take account of whole-life and whole-system costs and greater long-term certainty can support better value for taxpayers and give the wider supply chain the confidence to invest, which is exactly why we published the long-term rolling stock and infrastructure strategy, which provides a clearer view of future requirements and supports a more strategic approach to fleet and infrastructure planning. The strategy puts passengers at its heart, considering future requirements such as decarbonisation, accessibility, passenger comfort, and the infrastructure changes needed to support the fleet.

    View contribution permalink →

  163. The publication of the strategy already effectively delivers the substance of Amendment 323, and it will be a document for GBR to inherit and implement once it is established. I do not believe that legislation is the right place to set out the detailed content and timetable of such a strategy. I also do not believe that it is right to prescribe how GBR manages its commercial relationship for the rolling stock leasing markets, as Amendment 321 would do. Imposing a minimum lease term of 15 years would restrict GBR’s ability to respond to operational needs, changing passenger demands and market conditions, and would constrain GBR’s freedom to negotiate a range of options to secure best value for taxpayers. As I am sure noble Lords will be aware, the appropriate contract and commercial arrangements will depend on the circumstances at the time and should be determined on the basis of value for money rather than legislation, as this amendment suggests.

    View contribution permalink →

  164. On Amendments 330JE and 330JF, I am pleased to confirm to the noble Baroness that the strategy to which I have just referred also sets out that leasing will no longer be treated as a default for rolling stock and direct public ownership will be considered where it provides greater control, flexibility or value, just as Amendment 330J suggests. The Government acknowledge that public ownership of rolling stock could offer greater flexibility and substantial savings in some circumstances. However, it is important that GBR is able to take a case-by-case approach to new rolling stock and consider whether public or private ownership gives taxpayers the best overall value, which of course Amendment 330JF would prohibit.

    View contribution permalink →

  165. The noble Baroness raised the ONS classification of rolling stock. The ONS have said that it expects to review the classification of rolling stock leases in the national accounts. Its recent forward look suggests this is likely to happen during quarter 3 of 2027, but this is a decision for the ONS to take independent. We continue to work with His Majesty’s Treasury to understand the full implications of forthcoming policy decisions and their impact on classification risk as we prepare to establish GBR.

    View contribution permalink →

  166. On Amendments 309 and 322, I share the ambitions in the amendments to enhance the railway network so it can better serve people and places in future. That is clearly an important part of any discussion about railway funding. However, as I have said a number of times throughout Committee, we must preserve GBR’s role as the directing mind for the railways and resist the temptation to be overly prescriptive in legislation. If I were to accept Amendment 309, it would take away from GBR the ability to consider, design and decide on matters relating to investment and enhancement. This is one of the benefits of the GBR model, allowing GBR to plan and co-ordinate the network and bid for enhancements that will make the greatest difference to the most people. GBR will be the body with the expertise to ensure the right outcomes are delivered locally and nationally.

    View contribution permalink →

  167. However, I assure the noble Baroness that the fundamental principle of GBR investing locally remains a key priority, which is why GBR will be organised on a local basis with empowered regional and business units working collaboratively with local leaders, ensuring that local needs are considered in decision-making. That is also why mayoral strategic authorities will have a statutory role via GBR’s partnerships and GBR will be able to agree funding arrangements with the partnerships. I understand the noble Baroness’s point. What has been regrettable in the railway up to now has been the inability for the railway to respond in a proactive manner to suggestions for local investment in stations and other railway facilities. I hope that she can agree that GBR, with its autonomy but its integrated judgment, can work with local funders and transport bodies to determine how best to translate funding into an operational railway that works for everyone. That is the best way to achieve the outcomes Amendment 309 seeks.

    View contribution permalink →

  168. Amendment 322 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, would require a long-term pipeline of works. I have to say to the noble Lord that that is a very different idea from the past 30 years, when there has been no long-term pipeline of works. Indeed, successive Governments have been reluctant and have not published any forthcoming pipelines. I am pleased to confirm to the noble Lord that the Bill already proposes that GBR will include funded enhancement activity in its five-year business plans in response to funding settlements, those will be updated annually and they will be guided by the long-term rail strategy and its duties, providing transparency and far more certainty to the supply chain. I do not agree that 15 years is the right figure, because the railway is a dynamic place, and these ideas will necessarily change over the long term but not necessarily the short term. The vast array of information required by the amendment would be an unnecessary administrative burden on GBR and could adversely affect its commercial position with major suppliers by making commercially sensitive information freely available.

    View contribution permalink →

  169. On Amendment 305ZA tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Young, I agree with him and other noble Lords who have spoken about transferring the ownership and management of the historic railway estate to GBR, which will be the organisation with the capability, knowledge and experience to maintain the estate and put it back into use where it is appropriate. That is why the Government have already been clear that the historic railway estate will transfer to GBR, as the amendment seeks. The Bill already contains the appropriate mechanisms to enable this in its transfer schemes in Clause 88. It is firmly a government intention to do that.

    View contribution permalink →

  170. I absolutely agree that it is critical that GBR can begin to reconnect communities and support underserved parts of the country. However, under the Restoring Your Railways programme, decisions were made centrally by the Government, and the vast majority of the projects were unfunded and never implemented. That cannot be the right approach. It was part of the fragmented view of the railway, which the Bill is intended to resolve, with decisions being made centrally without any plan to deliver them operationally. GBR will be best placed to consider future investments in the railway, ensuring that new investments in infrastructure support its general plan to fulfil its duties and make a better railway for everyone.

    View contribution permalink →

  171. I am afraid that I cannot accept Amendment 312. While I agree with the noble Baroness about the benefits of reusing redundant railway land for active travel and, indeed, the Government have already established Active Travel England to support the introduction of new walking and cycling routes, this purpose alone cannot be the default option for railway land. There are other equally valid uses of railway land, sometimes to reuse it as a railway route, as noble Lords have said, but also in regeneration initiatives for housing, such as via Platform 4, which has been much discussed during the Committee. There is also its use for heritage railways, which many have spoken about so passionately during these proceedings. Another potential use is for freight, to support the Government’s freight growth ambition.

    View contribution permalink →

  172. All the options for railway land need to be assessed against clear criteria, and I confirm that GBR will do just that when making decisions. It will be guided by its duties when doing so, which include promoting the interests of potential passengers, promoting freight and acting in the public interest, all of which clearly relate to selecting the right use for disused railway land. It will consult where it is appropriate, but not in every case. I encourage both noble Baronesses to work with me and, in time, GBR outside this Bill process to improve the current use of disused railway land. I hope that the assurances I have given about the historic railway estate will help in that respect.

    View contribution permalink →

  173. Turning to Amendments 330A and 330B from the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, I appreciate the interest and enthusiasm that noble Lords have shown throughout our Committee debates in the important work that Platform4 is doing. While I appreciate the intent of Amendment 330A, I can assure the noble Lord that Platform4 already operates within a robust framework of business planning, financial oversight and corporate governance and that this will continue under GBR.

    View contribution permalink →

  174. The viability of development and regeneration schemes is continuously assessed through established approval processes, board scrutiny and shareholder oversight from the Secretary of State, and Platform4 also publishes its annual accounts and reporting online. Regeneration schemes, such as those pursued by Platform4, often involve complex negotiations with local authorities, developers, investors, landowners and prospective occupiers over many years, and I hope that the noble Lord can see that requiring a statutory publication of project viability assessments, as the amendment seeks to do, could undermine Platform4’s commercial position in those negotiations by making public the viability details of every project, potentially reducing value to the taxpayer and deterring private sector investment in future regeneration activity. It is not how any other private company would do business and it is not how Platform4 should work either.

    View contribution permalink →

  175. Viability is an evolving status in regeneration projects and not a fixed assessment. Projects can take many years to progress from land assembly and planning through to delivery, and market conditions, construction costs and funding arrangements can all change in that time. A statutory review would provide only a snapshot of what is in reality a moving picture, potentially giving a misleading picture of long-term viability and public value. The noble Lord raised in this respect, and in support of his amendment, Hampton Court station, but I do not think we can decide future legislation on the basis of one case that, as he clearly laid out, has a very long history. I am happy to look at that particular issue, but not at the cost of a general obligation in the Bill that would adversely affect the future development of railway land.

    View contribution permalink →

  176. Amendment 330B would require a rent review of Network Rail properties ahead of its transfer to GBR. I can confirm that the leases that Network Rail and subsidiaries have with tenants already provide for rent reviews. Some of the leases include turnover rent arrangements, under which tenants provide turnover rents and regular updates. Network Rail also has existing property management systems in place, monitoring the management of rent reviews to ensure value for taxpayers. An additional rent review would not alter those existing legal obligations; it would be duplicative of those existing processes.

    View contribution permalink →

  177. The noble Lord also raised the case of railway arches in Hackney. I do not know whether he knows this, but the majority of commercial space in railway arches has been let on a long lease to the private Arch Company, which is responsible for the collection and review of rents. When I was chair of Network Rail, I supported this process because Network Rail simply did not have the money, and if it did it should not have used it for the purpose of investing in arches rather than investing in the railway itself. The money that that sale raised from the long leases was reinvested back into railway infrastructure, helping to increase commercial income and reduce subsidy.

    View contribution permalink →

  178. Finally, Amendment 330H seeks a statutory electrification programme. Decarbonisation is a key objective of this Government, and electrification is essential to achieving that. The recently published R olling S tock and I nfrastructure St rategy is an infrastructure strategy because it is clearly indicating a move away from diesel traction towards electric traction, including electrification and the use of battery electric trains. The Government are clearly acting on this, even without a statutory requirement to do so, which is what this amendment proposes. I agree with the noble Baroness on the importance of keeping the costs of electrification low while maintaining domestic capability, and we are most likely to get the best value for money if the skills required exist here. But I do not agree that a legislative duty to carry out an electrification programme is the right approach. Funding for electrification needs to be balanced across a number of competing priorities. It should be GBR and the Government of the day who make those trade-offs, without being restricted by duties on specific projects.

    View contribution permalink →

  179. In addition, it is impossible to say with certainty that electrification will be the most important thing to receive government funding in 15 years’ time. Advances in battery technology, for example, probably will mean that the same decarbonisation can be achieved by different means. But I reassure the noble Baroness that with GBR we will have a directing mind able to advise future Governments on where funding for electrification is best spent, taking into account the long-term rail strategy, the rolling stock and infrastructure strategy, and the business plan.

    View contribution permalink →

  180. Lord Grayling (Con)

    The Minister did not respond to my question about biodiversity. Can he reassure us that he will mandate Great British Railways, when it uses the historic rail estate, to make sure it also protects the unique elements of biodiversity that can be found on it?

    View contribution permalink →

  181. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    At an earlier stage in Committee, we talked about the commitment to biodiversity that GBR has to have. I would expect that to apply to the historic railway estate when GBR takes it over, just as it applies to the rest of the property that it owns and manages.

    View contribution permalink →

  182. Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to everyone who has taken part in this debate, which went to a number of destinations: Hampton Court, Whitstable, Luxembourg and various destinations in southern Africa. I am particularly grateful to those noble Lords who supported my amendment: the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, the noble Lord, Lord Davies, my noble friends Lord Harper and Lord Grayling, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. The noble Baroness, Lady Leaman, put some colour to my amendment by outlining the various options.

    View contribution permalink →

  183. Sitting suspended for Divisions in the House.

    View contribution permalink →

  184. Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

    My Lords, I was concluding the debate on the group beginning with my Amendment 305ZA, and I was complimenting the noble Baroness, Lady Leaman, on her supportive speech, which identified alternative uses of surplus assets. In that connection, Sustrans has done some heroic work in reusing a disused rail track. The noble Lord, Lord Hampton, who is not in his place, did not declare an interest, so we assume that Hampton Court was not at one point the ancestral home of the Hamptons. He raised a valuable point about making the maximum use of assets. I have two points in relation to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones. My noble friend Lord Harper explained the difficulties with the Government owning the roscos. To underline his point, I note that I was Secretary of State to begin with when British Rail was British Rail, and I was also Secretary of State when it was Railtrack. In both cases, I came along with a substantive business case for investment in rolling stock. When I went to the Star Chamber of fellow colleagues in the Government, I explained that there would be less cost for maintenance, better passenger safety and less use of fuel. They would say, “This is a fantastic story but, sadly, we have a limit on government expenditure, and we have just heard that the Home Secretary wants more policemen, the Health Secretary wants more nurses and the Education Secretary wants more teachers”. So I was told, “I’m sorry, George; you can’t have your new train set for Christmas”. However, afterwards, the business case spoke for itself. It got the investment without any Treasury veto. The scenario that the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, was urging us to accept would mean that the Secretary of State would be in exactly the same position as I was in 1995. The other point that the noble Baroness raised was about the implications of the roscos being scored as public expenditure; she said it would be a very serious issue. Indeed, it was, and we had an earlier debate in that regard. The Government’s position is that we should await the conclusions of the ONS. However, the more that the Minister developed his case that there would be a proactive pipeline strategy, the more I thought he was digging a hole for himself, in that that is more likely to lead the ONS to take the view that this is a government-controlled body, with the Government calling the shots. The Minister might like to reflect on his ambitions for the rolling stock strategy, with the ONS hanging on his every word. On a final point, I am most grateful to the Minister for basically agreeing with Amendment 305ZA. What he did not say was why he could not accept the amendment itself, as it would actually deliver government policy. Yes, he has the powers under Clause 88 to do it, but this would oblige him to do it, removing any doubt at all. Although I will withdraw the amendment, the Minister did not explain why it was not acceptable. No drafting defect was identified, which is the normal alibi that a Secretary of State or a Minister adopts if he cannot accept an amendment. But because it was a helpful reply, I do not want to be curmudgeonly, and so I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

    View contribution permalink →

  185. Amendment 305ZA withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  186. Amendment 305A not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  187. Clause 88 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  188. Amendment 305B not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  189. Clauses 89 to 91 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  190. Schedule 3 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  191. Clauses 92 and 93 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  192. Clause 94: Licensing etc of train drivers

    View contribution permalink →

  193. Amendments 306 to 308 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  194. Clause 94 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  195. Clause 95 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  196. Amendments 309 to 325 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  197. Amendment 326

    View contribution permalink →

  198. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  199. 326: After Clause 95, insert the following new Clause— “Conditions for commencement(1) Before the end of the period of six months beginning with the day on which this Act is passed the Secretary of State must publish and lay before Parliament—(a) a consultation document and draft retail code of practice,(b) a final retail code of practice resulting from the consultation referred to in paragraph (a),(c) a consultation document and draft access and use policy document or documents proposed under section 59,(d) a final access and use policy document or documents proposed under section 59 resulting from the consultation referred to in paragraph (c),(e) a consultation document and draft licence proposed to be granted to Great British Railways,(f) a consultation document and draft proposals for the charging and performance schemes set out in sections 64 and 65 respectively,(g) a draft rail strategy required by section 15, and(h) a document setting out the stages by which Great British Railways is to be established and the target date for the completion of each stage.(2) Before the end of the period of six months beginning with the day on which this Act is passed—(a) the ORR must publish a consultation document on the principles, practice and procedure for appeals proposed under Chapter 1 of Part 3, and(b) the Secretary of State must lay that consultation document before Parliament.”Member's explanatory statement This amendment and two others in the name of Lord Moylan seek to place various conditions on the commencement of the principal operational provisions of the Act.

    View contribution permalink →

  200. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, I have three amendments in this group, two of which are effectively consequential on Amendment 326. It is frankly a disgrace that we are being asked to pass this Bill when so many of the documents that will determine how the new railway actually operates have not been finalised or have not even been published. We saw this problem in Committee on 16 September, when the Government published their update on the long-term rail strategy on the very morning when we were to debate that strategy in the afternoon. Of course, we had no time to take account of it before we entered into that debate. Many noble Lords arrived at the Committee without even having seen the document. We were effectively asked to scrutinise provisions concerning the strategy while blind to the Government’s thinking on it. The provision with other key documents is little better. The access and use policy is now being consulted on, but the Government’s own timetable says that the final policy will not be published until spring next year. The retail code of practice is also currently out for consultation, with the final code again not expected until the spring of 2027. The ORR’s consultation on a new access appeals procedure—something crucial to our debates in this Committee—is not due until spring 2027, and the charging and performance framework consultation is also scheduled only for spring next year. Most remarkably, the final long-term rail strategy—the document supposed to provide the overarching strategic direction for this entire new railway—is not expected until autumn of 2027, yet the Bill as drafted would allow the Secretary of State to commence the principal operational provisions without Parliament first having seen and scrutinised the most fundamental documents. These various documents will determine who gets access to the railway, how operators are charged, how performance is regulated, how independent retailers compete with GBR, how appeals operate and ultimately how this enormous new public body exercises its powers. We should not be asked to sign a blank cheque and discover the terms only later. Amendment 326 and Amendments 346 and 347 as consequential require the central elements of the new regime before the principal provisions are commenced. It is an amendment the Government cannot gainsay if they have any respect for Parliament. If they are confident in the framework they created, they should have no objection to Parliament seeing that framework before it is brought into force. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  201. Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

    My Lords, I appreciate the desire of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, to see many of these documents, but I assure the Committee that these amendments are unnecessary. It is already the case that all the necessary supporting documentation will be published before GBR day one, and the Government have set out the schedule for the publications already in their policy publication timetable on GOV.UK, making clear what Parliament and the public can expect to see and when, and ensuring the Government can be held to account in hitting their key milestones. Recognising the desire for more information about planned publications, in May we published our policy publication timetable. The Government are clearly demonstrating their adherence to the timetable, having met every single stated publication date so far. This started with our GBR licence policy document in May, and a summary memorandum of understanding between the passenger watchdog and the ORR in June. That has continued throughout this Committee, during which we have published our interim freight targets, rolling stock and infrastructure strategy, a consultation on GBR’s draft access and use policy and a consultation on the retail code of practice. There are documents due in 2027, either because they require the establishment of GBR in order to be published or because they are being consulted on ahead of this and the timing allows for a prior consultation and response. For example, the Bill explicitly requires GBR to respond to the ORR appeals consultation, which I am sure the noble Lord will understand means that GBR will therefore need to be established before it can take place. He knows that the access and use policy and the retail code of practice are being consulted on as we speak. It is vital that the responses received to these are given proper consideration to inform proposals, ahead of the final documents being published. I contend that the Government are clearly committed to and are delivering a steady drumbeat of information for both this House and our wider stakeholders, to keep everyone informed of progress towards reforming the railways and establishing GBR, and this progress will absolutely continue over the coming months. A requirement in the Bill to publish the documents before the commencement of the majority of the clauses would risk complicating and delaying the already complex process of reforming the railways, while changing absolutely nothing about what documents will be published or when. For these reasons, I encourage the noble Lord not to press his amendments.

    View contribution permalink →

  202. Lord Moylan (Con)

    My Lords, as ever, the arrogance of the Government is driving us all into a brick wall. There is little point in continuing banging one’s head against it this evening. We will return to these matters on Report. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

    View contribution permalink →

  203. Amendment 326 withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  204. Amendments 327 to 330JF not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  205. Clause 96 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  206. Schedule 4: Minor and consequential amendments

    View contribution permalink →

  207. Amendments 330K to 332 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  208. The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Lord Faulkner of Worcester) (Lab)

    I advise the Committee that there is an error in the first line of Amendment 333. It should say: “Schedule 4, page 93, line 9, leave out sub-paragraphs (i) and (ii)”.

    View contribution permalink →

  209. Amendment 333 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  210. Amendments 333A to 338 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  211. Schedule 4 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  212. Clause 97 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  213. Clause 98: Regulations

    View contribution permalink →

  214. Amendments 339 to 344 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  215. Clause 98 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  216. Clause 99: General interpretation

    View contribution permalink →

  217. Amendment 345 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  218. Clause 99 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  219. Clause 100 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  220. Clause 101: Commencement

    View contribution permalink →

  221. Amendments 346 and 347 not moved.

    View contribution permalink →

  222. Clause 101 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  223. Clause 102 agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

  224. Bill reported with amendments.

    View contribution permalink →

  225. Committee adjourned at 8.10 pm.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5424543.