Contribution
My Lords, where to start? Let me start with the easy, uncontroversial bit. I congratulate my noble friend Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay and the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, on once again crowbarring references to heritage railways into this group of amendments—they have done so brilliantly throughout this Committee, and I congratulate them again. It gives me an excuse to mention the fantastic Dean Forest Railway in my home area, as people would be very disappointed if I did not do so.
I was considering raising the concerns that the Delegated Powers Committee set out so ably in its report. I then spied the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay of Llandaff, and assumed, because I do not think that she has been in one of our sessions before, that she was here to do that. It was much more powerful coming from her, as a member of the committee, and I think that she set it out very well. The only thing I would suggest to the committee, if I may be so bold, is this. It has the Henry VIII definition, which it is forced to use quite a lot—and not just under this Government, to be fair. If we are going to see increasing reference to this ability to amend not just existing legislation but future legislation, perhaps I could suggest an amended definition of a Henry VIII power crossed with “Doctor Who”—although I do not quite know what that would look like—so that the committee could go into the future and change future legislation. It clearly needs another definition to show that Henry VIII powers are not the ultimate legislative terribleness and that there are worse things, such as amending things that have not even been written yet—as my noble friend suggested, you could just write them properly in the first place. If you are passing future legislation, perhaps you should just do it right, rather than relying on powers in existing legislation to fix the stuff you have not yet written. The noble Baroness set out all of that very well.
I listened carefully to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, who had similar concerns. The only point I would make—I say this to not just the Minister but the Whip—is that it should have been obvious, in listening to the debate, that the concerns seem to be coming from across the Committee and from all of the groups that are represented here. I am sure that the Whip will be doing the maths ahead of Report. I gently suggest to the Minister that he might want to reflect on this, and that a well-crafted amendment from the Government to address at least some of our concerns would be well advised.
Let me touch on the points that the Minister made in response to concerns, particularly those that I set out, before I ask the Committee’s permission to withdraw my amendment. First, he set up another straw man in suggesting that people want to get rid of Clause 72 in its entirety. My amendments would specifically not abolish Clause 72; they would heavily amend and constrain it. I recognise that you need some powers to bring regimes into alignment, and I do not think I heard any dispute about that in the Committee. So that was a bit of a straw man, as nobody suggested it in the first place.
The Minister repeated the point that I made in my introduction about his letter, which he helpfully sent today. I agree with my noble friend Lord Moylan that it was helpful to have that on the record. However, public ownership is not really the point, and my noble friend Lord Grayling challenged the Minister on this. My reading of Clause 72 is not that it gives the Government the right to take ownership of the assets. The problem—I come back to the point that the Prime Minister keeps making about public control—is that, if you make provisions about management, operation, pricing and all that, you are doing something worse than taking ownership of these assets because, by taking ownership, you would have to pay and compensate somebody for them. The danger here is that you can alter their economic use without having to pay for it. That is the concern of the investors and operators of these assets, and I do not think I heard anything from the Minister that would have reassured them.
On the issue in Amendment 276 about the right of appeal to the ORR, the Minister referred to the access and management regulations already containing a right of appeal, but, unless I am missing the point, this is not about access to the GBR network but about the basis on which people can use these private sector assets and the ability to charge for them. Unless I am very confused, I do not think the access and management regulations and the right of appeal to the ORR cover that point. As we have talked about previously, being able to appeal on a judicial review is quite narrow and does not encompass operators’ concerns.
A further point on Clause 73 is around the definition of GBR infrastructure. The Minister was talking slightly at cross-purposes when he said—I think I have got this right—that he wanted the definition of GBR infrastructure, and therefore non-GBR infrastructure, to be enduring. That is a good thing, but “enduring” means something that is set and that lasts for a long time, not something you keep fiddling with. Therefore, an enduring definition in which people can have confidence ought to be set out in primary legislation that cannot be amended by secondary legislation. As soon as it can be amended by secondary legislation, it is not an enduring definition any more, because Ministers can fiddle about with it pretty much at whim.
My final point, which is connected to this, is one which my noble friend Lord Moylan set out. We might lament the fact, but this infrastructure does not pop up without notice. In his response to my noble friend Lord Moylan, the Minister accepted that this stuff takes a very long time. In those circumstances, it would be up to the Government—I do not think it is that hard—to find an appropriate primary legislative vehicle. I accept that that would be an issue if you were trying to do it within a year or so, but it does not seem impossible over a number of years. We are talking here about significant capital investment, such as freight terminals and ports. That is hundreds of millions of pounds—even billions of pounds—of capital investment. If someone is making that sort of investment into the country then it would not be an enormous challenge for the Government to come up with a short piece of primary legislation to deal with any ambiguities or difficulties there might be in ensuring that that asset can operate. Investment in such infrastructure will not be made, go through the planning process, built, constructed and start to operate in less than a number of years. The concern is not really one that we should worry about.
Before I beg leave to withdraw my amendment, all I will say is that I do not think, based on what the Minister has said so far, that any of the concerns that people have set out have been addressed. The Minister should reflect further, following this debate, on the points that were made. We will look closely at his written response to the Delegated Powers Committee’s report and reflect on that before we get to Report to see whether we need to table any of these amendments again. The Minister might accept that there is an issue to be dealt with and, even if he does not go as far as we would ideally like, may wish to bring forward amendments of his own to constrain—not get rid of—the powers in Clauses 72 and 73 in a way that would reassure investors and those that operate this non-GBR infrastructure. On that point, I beg leave to withdraw Amendment 272.