L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is difficult for me to disagree with any of the remarks made by noble Lords in this debate so far. I had an amendment in an earlier group to require the release of open data by Great British Railways, and the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, being much cleverer than me at these things, has also proposed an amendment showing how that could be made useful—not simply published, but published in a usable way. The noble Lord has also, ingeniously, proposed a mechanism that, in his view—this, of course, is something the Minister may wish to challenge—would allow a level playing field to be maintained between GBR, as retailer, and private sector retailers without having to rely on subjective considerations as in the retail policy document that has been produced. That would be a huge advantage. It would be a self-correcting mechanism. Again, it is for the Minister to say why the subjective method he has advocated is preferable to one that would, at least on the face of it, be self-correcting and not require subjective judgment. He could do that in two ways. One would be by showing that, for all its surface brilliance, the noble Lord’s proposal does not work. I would not be one to judge that but I would understand the nature of the argument he was making. The alternative would be for him to say that he thinks his own subjective judgment is better. I suspect that, when we come to hear him reply, it will be the latter. That would be a less convincing argument; indeed, I do not think it would convince anybody at all. I turn to Amendments 291A and 291B, concerning cross-subsidy and financial transparency. We also debated this earlier in Committee, but I do not believe that the Minister provided a satisfactory answer. He relied, in part, on Managing Public Money, but that is Treasury guidance; it is not a statutory prohibition on cross-subsidising GBR’s online retailer, which is what the Committee has been looking for, and does not provide an independent retailer with an enforceable statutory right to economic parity with GBR. There is also a significant issue concerning subsidy control. The Minister told the Committee earlier that the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations 2023 would be the relevant subsidy control legislation for retail. Section 48(1)(b)(iii) of the Subsidy Control Act 2022 provides that the ordinary subsidy control requirements under that Act do not apply to subsidies given in accordance with those regulations. The difficulty is that online retailing is an independent commercial activity of considerable scale, taking place in an open and competitive market. It should not simply be conflated with the wider public service obligation to provide passenger services or physical ticketing facilities. I repeat that the Subsidy Control Act does not apply if the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations do apply. It is the Government’s argument that the Subsidy Control Act does not apply; therefore, the regulations apply and the argument is that those regulations are inadequate. That is what I have been trying to say. There is an obvious distinction between maintaining ticket offices, call centres and other physical channels, which GBR may be required to provide as a public service, and operating an online retailer in direct competition with Trainline and other independent businesses. The Minister himself acknowledged in Committee that physical retail channels are substantially more expensive to provide. I think we all know that. Independent retailers generally operate on a commission of around 4.5% on most ticket sales, from which they must meet their technology, payment, fraud, customer service and other costs. Evidence to the Transport Committee described that 4.5% as the lowest cost of sale in the industry. If GBR’s online retailer is able to operate beyond comparable commercial economics because costs can be absorbed elsewhere within the wider organisation, there is a clear risk of market distortion. Without separately identifiable costs, revenues and public funding, how are the ORR, the CMA, Parliament or indeed competitors supposed to establish what is actually happening? The Minister told us in Committee that there would be 100% transparency, because GBR would put its costs into its business plan, but aggregate figures for a broad retail function are not the same as separately identifiable accounts for an online business competing directly against private companies. Amendment 330JB relates to open railway data. GBR will control important market-wide systems and data on which its competitors depend. The principle should surely be that, where data is necessary to allow independent retailers to develop products and compete effectively, they should have open and equivalent access to them. The draft retail code itself recognises that access to relevant data must be fair, transparent and non-discriminatory. That brings me to Amendment 330JD, and equal access to products, services and interfaces. Earlier in Committee, the Minister assured us that the retail code, which we had not seen at that stage, would require GBR to ensure access to products and provide services and data on fair, transparent and non-discriminatory terms. We have now seen the draft code, and the wording is rather narrower than that assurance might have suggested. Paragraph 6.11 applies the guarantee to “fares, products, and passenger-facing services that form a core part of the online customer offer”, and says that it applies “only where other retailers cannot reasonably provide that product or passenger-facing service independently of GBR”. Pay-as-you-go, for example, is expressly excluded. What constitutes “core” is not defined, which leaves us with some important questions. Passenger Assist is an obvious example. The Government have explicitly promised that passengers using the new GBR app will be able to buy their ticket and book Passenger Assist in the same place. Yet the draft code does not expressly mention Passenger Assist, and the Minister confirmed this again today. Independent retailers have been asking for access to the passenger assistance functionality for years. Indeed, this precise issue was raised during the Commons Committee evidence. If GBR can offer an integrated ticket and assistance service while independent retailers cannot, disabled passengers who want that function may effectively be pushed towards GBR’s own app, which would constrain customer choice. The same principle applies to future propositions such as loyalty schemes. There should be nothing wrong with GBR innovating, but if it creates a commercial loyalty offer, that offer should compete on its own economics. The concern would arise if GBR could offer comparable advantages while its cost was absorbed elsewhere. Amendment 330JD therefore ensures that when GBR’s own online retailer relies on a retail interface or market-wide functionality, competing retailers should be able to obtain equivalent access on equivalent terms. Finally, Amendment 330JC concerns transparency over the actual cost of GBR’s online retailer. We have repeatedly asked what this project will cost, here and through Written Questions. In our earlier debate, the Minister has said that much of the information remained commercially sensitive while procurement was under way and that it would be published in the usual way once available. When is it going to be available?

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.