B

Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to this important group from my noble friend Lord Dixon, who has gone into great detail and shows his extensive knowledge in this area. It is important that we have this debate now, because we had an earlier debate before the draft retail code had been published. That was going to solve every problem, but it clearly has not. In a briefing note sent to me, Independent Rail Retailers has stressed that this is principle based only and that the mechanisms proposed are not enough to deliver these outcomes. The Bill is silent on many areas, as we have heard, including a fair, open and competitive market, funding and transparency. It does not yet provide the protections that retailers have repeatedly called for, or those the Government have promised. Even if the Government wish to redraft these amendments—they deal with a lot of the issues we discussed on the earlier day—it is really important that we make sure that data is open and easier to use for all operators, including future ones. The really strong point is that we have seen so much creativity across the country in this area. We saw it many years ago when Transport for London put all its data out there. How many bus apps popped up within a week or two, absolutely transforming how we use transport networks? It is really important that the data is in a format that is simple to use. Even with my lack of technological skill, I know that a PDF of data is next to useless. It is really important that Great British Railways provides it in that way and that Great British Railways retail must use the same as everyone else. Previously in Committee, I raised an issue that I had found recently. It may just be my technological skill, but I could not find the discounted fares on South Western Railway on my usual app. I had to buy the ticket through South Western Railway to get my £12 fare. Fair enough, I got a cheap ticket, but why was it not available on my regular app? Was it promoting it through its own app first? Third-party retailers need to have equal access. It has to be usable and, as we have heard, an interface that they can rely on. The other point is clearly understanding whether there is a subsidy. I am told that SNCF has a separate retail arm and that they both work differently. It needs to be looked at carefully, but an idea of an annual statement, whether publicly or through the regulator, would help provide some assurance, which the whole sector would appreciate. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s thoughts on this and whether we might see a future government amendment to tighten this up.

More from Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.