L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I strongly support these amendments, which the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, introduced so ably. He will remember that he and I covered this important issue at Second Reading. I will take the two aspects separately. Amendments 291A, 291B and 330JC are about stopping cross-subsidy from GBR’s other operations to its retail ticketing arm and putting in some transparency, which are mutually reinforcing and important measures. Successful businesses that operate competitively exist only because they serve their customers. If they did not serve their customers, they would not exist. They are not concerned about GBR in proper competition on a level playing field; they are perfectly content that they can operate in that space and compete perfectly well. Either they will be good at it, which they think they will, or they will not be good at it, and that is fine; they have no complaint about that. What they are worried about is GBR using its non-retail revenues, or its access to the infrastructure and the cost that it has to pay for that, to compete unfairly with them. In a previous group we talked about the fact that the passenger services part of GBR will not have to pay for the access charges to GBR infrastructure—the other part of the business. If a retail operator looks at that model, it will think, “Hang on, does that mean that GBR’s retail operation can access the data and infrastructure that it needs to run that operation without having to pay for it?” If it can do that, which is what the Bill sets out, that clearly means that it is not competing on a level playing field and that the taxpayer is, in effect, subsidising GBR to put out of business a company that employs staff, makes profits, pays taxes and has innovated to produce a model that serves customers very well. Clearly, that would not be welcome. As far as I can tell, all the noble Lord’s amendments would do is to make sure that GBR cannot cross-subsidise. He set out a number of ways in which that could be done, recognising that there are some commercial constraints here. Again, if the Minister does not like the way the amendments have been worded, it is completely open to him either to make suggestions to the noble Lord or to come back with his own amendments. These are real concerns that real businesses have and, frankly, passengers will have them too—they might not have them now, but they will if any of these commercial businesses stop existing and they get left with one monopolistic government operator selling tickets. That has never been a recipe for innovation and great customer service, which is what people are used to at the moment. The second part of the amendments is about access to the data, which I strongly support. This is something that the coalition Government did when my noble friend Lord Maude of Horsham was the relevant Minister in the Cabinet Office. They led the world in making available lots of government and official data in an open and transparent way, which led to the development by the private sector of innumerable apps that have been of enormous benefit to the public. That is what the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, is trying to do here: to make sure that GBR has to make that data available. His solution is an excellent one: it is consistent with best practice in industry—it is not a legislative vehicle that will not work; as he said, it is how many other businesses operate already—and it would ensure, in a very future-proofed way, that GBR’s retail operation has to run a good operation in terms of data because it will use the same systems and interfaces that all its competitors have. If it wants to disadvantage its competitors, it has to disadvantage itself in the same way and vice versa. That is a very good solution because it means it is future-proofed and does not require an enormous amount of regulation with somebody else managing a very complicated structure. It is a model which we know works in technology and retail businesses because we have seen it in others, including those that are heavily regulated, such as Openreach. These amendments have a lot to recommend them. The concerns are shared, as highlighted by my noble friend Lord Moylan signing several of them. I think, remembering back to Second Reading, that these concerns were shared across the House. I will listen carefully to what the Minister has to say in response to see whether he can deal with it. Setting out assurances about how he will conduct himself is obviously helpful, but we are passing laws that have to operate and endure under Governments of potentially many different complexions with many different Ministers and attitudes. It is the legislation that maters, not just what the Minister says about it. The legislation is too weak and requires tightening up. These are excellent amendments which have a lot to recommend them to the Committee. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.