Contribution
The Government believe that it is not drafted to enable it to be used.
I emphasise the safeguards that apply to any proposed use of the power. The Secretary of State must consult on any regulations made under this clause, and any regulations would be subject to the affirmative parliamentary procedure, ensuring parliamentary scrutiny and debate in both Houses before any changes can be made.
Turning to Amendments 272 and 280 to 283, from numerous noble Lords, I reiterate that the power cannot be used—we believe that the clauses are so drafted that this is their effect—to bring other infrastructure managers, the operators of those facilities or any of their assets into public ownership, whether they are freight, open access or heritage. Clause 72(1) sets out the matters about which the Secretary of State may make provision by regulations, and neither those matters nor the consequential power in subsection (4) confer a power to transfer ownership of infrastructure or assets into public ownership. If the Bill intended to confer a power to transfer ownership, it would have needed to spell that out explicitly.
Equally, it is not intended to disrupt the way that such facilities are operated, change their commercial basis or weaken the protections that underpin private investment. As I have explained, its purpose is to ensure that the adjacent regulatory frameworks remain coherent and workable alongside the new arrangements for GBR. However, I emphasise that any regulations made under this power will be subject to the affirmative procedure, meaning that they cannot be made without first being considered and approved by both Houses.
Turning to my noble friend Lord Berkeley’s Amendment 280A, I have already made it clear that Clause 72 cannot be used to bring private infrastructure into public ownership. However, there may be circumstances in which changes affecting the wider railway require amendments to regulations that apply to non-GBR infrastructure, including freight-only facilities. Excluding such infrastructure entirely from the scope of the power could unnecessarily prevent necessary changes. My noble friend raised the sale of DB Cargo. My understanding currently is that there are a number of bids, all of which treat the company as a going concern. The Government are not considering or taking any action to buy the company, and neither do they intend to buy its terminals, although many of them are protected by covenants to ensure the use of freight. The Government’s intention is to leave freight operations in private ownership.
Constraining the power in the ways suggested by these amendments risks making it ineffective as well as limiting the opportunity to make future improvements sought by the Welsh Government or other infrastructure managers. I also emphasise that restricting this power could ultimately be detrimental to the very infrastructure managers these amendments seek to protect. As the new GBR arrangements bed in, changes to the wider railway could have unintended consequences for non-GBR infrastructure, potentially affecting its ability to operate effectively alongside, and remain connected to, the wider network. Without the flexibility provided by Clause 72, we could find ourselves unable to make the regulatory changes necessary to address these consequences, leaving non-GBR infrastructure managers worse off.
I agree with the noble Lord, Lord Harper, that, if the existing regulations need to be amended or replaced using the Clause 72 power, the access and management regulations are most likely to be affected. However, railway legislation is interconnected, so amendments to one piece of legislation may require consequential amendments to other Acts or regulations. It would therefore be unwise to exclude the possibility of such amendments, as doing so could risk preventing necessary or beneficial changes in the future.
In relation to international rail services, while the Bill does not directly impact those services, I recognise the importance of maintaining effective cross-border operations, including services operated on High Speed 1 through the Channel Tunnel. We agree that consultation with those involved would be particularly important where proposed changes to the domestic framework could create misalignment with European arrangements. However, Clause 72 already requires the Secretary of State to consult such persons as she considers appropriate before making regulations, providing the flexibility to engage with relevant parties where these issues arise. With these points in mind, and recalling the consultation requirements and parliamentary scrutiny provided for in the Bill, the Government consider that Clause 72 strikes the right balance between flexibility and oversight.
I turn to Amendments 275, 278, 279 and 280 and am mindful that this is also relevant to Amendment 283 from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. I completely agree that consultation is an important principle and that the Secretary of State should consult those affected. As I have said, Clause 72 already requires the Secretary of State to consult such persons as she considers appropriate and she must act reasonably in deciding who to consult. Where facility owners, operators or users are affected by proposed changes, we would certainly expect that they would be consulted and would also expect consultation to include the Office of Rail and Road. The amendment would also require the publication of an impact assessment before regulations could be made. However, established government processes already require the impact of regulatory proposals to be assessed proportionately. Where appropriate, an impact assessment or other supporting analysis would accompany the regulations, providing transparency on the expected impacts and effects of the proposed changes. We therefore do not consider that a statutory requirement is necessary.
The noble Lord, Lord Grayling, raised the issue of criminal sections at Clause 72(3)(a) and, in light of our previous discussions about criminal sanctions, I will consider what he says further.
Amendments 274 and 276 focus on appeals and non-discrimination. On Amendment 274, public law principles already require the Secretary of State to act proportionately, rationally and fairly when exercising this power, meaning that an additional test for non-discrimination is not necessary. The amendment also creates ambiguity and uncertainty, as it means that the scope of the power depends on judgments about whether different people affected by regulations are in materially comparable circumstances. Rather than introduce this uncertainty, we have instead designed the power so that a combination of public law principles and appropriate scrutiny provide the necessary safeguards against it being used unfairly. Amendment 276 would require regulations to provide a right of appeal to the ORR against decisions made under the regulations, but that is unnecessary because the access and management regulations already provide for a right of appeal under Regulation 32, and I can reassure noble Lords that there is no intention to remove that.
I turn to Amendments 273 and 277. The Government do not consider the restriction in Amendment 273 to be workable. As I have set out, one possible use of the regulations is to avoid inconsistencies, gaps or operational frictions emerging between the GBR and non-GBR regimes. This could arise not only when the new regime is introduced, but successively over time as the GBR regime evolves. I point again to the Welsh Government’s aspirations for the Core Valley Lines as an example of why that would be inappropriate. If the power was used only once to help align the GBR and non-GBR regimes, it could not then be used again to amend the same provisions to support those aspirations. On Amendment 277, I have read the report of the Delegated Powers Committee carefully. I take its recommendations seriously and, of course, will take today’s debate into account as I continue to consider them prior to Report.
I turn to Amendment 285 and reassure the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, that the concern underlying this amendment has already been addressed during the Bill’s passage. It is certainly not the Government’s intention that third-party infrastructure should be brought into the scope of the GBR access regime. Indeed, earlier this year the Government identified a risk that the original definition of GBR infrastructure could have been interpreted as including infrastructure operated by GBR on behalf of another infrastructure manager under a contractual arrangement—High Speed 1, among others. A government amendment was therefore made in the other place to clarify that infrastructure managed or operated by GBR on behalf of another person does not fall within the definition of GBR infrastructure in Clause 73(1). The change was specifically intended to ensure that infrastructure adjacent to GBR and managed by GBR under contractual arrangements, as the noble Baroness describes, remains outside the GBR access and charging framework.
The Bill therefore already draws a clear distinction between infrastructure for which GBR is responsible in its own right and infrastructure that it may operate in future on behalf of a third party, such as the specialist management that Network Rail High Speed delivers to High Speed 1 today. To be clear, the Bill, following this amendment, ensures that the High Speed 1 concessionaire can continue to outsource various activities for operations, maintenance and renewal without impacting the nature of the concession agreement itself and without bringing that infrastructure into the GBR access regime.
Further, the Government recognise that any future change to the definition of GBR infrastructure would be significant. That is why regulations made under Clause 73(2) would be subject to the affirmative procedure, ensuring that Parliament would have the opportunity to scrutinise and approve any such change before it could take effect. I have already set out the Government’s approach to assessing the impacts of proposed regulations. I am happy to confirm that the Government do not intend to reclassify freight facilities, HS1 or any other private infrastructure in the way that the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, has described.
I turn to Amendment 284, from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay. I understand the concerns of the Delegated Powers Committee that the definition of GBR infrastructure ought not to require amendment. This definition is of fundamental importance, because it determines which railway assets fall within the new GBR access and charging regime created by the Bill and which are to remain subject to the existing regime. The Government consider that, given the importance in defining the boundary between the two regimes, there should be a means short of primary legislation to update the definition should circumstances change. While the definition is intended to provide a clear and enduring boundary between the two regimes, it is not possible to anticipate every future development in the structure, ownership or operation of railway infrastructure. For example, new infrastructure could be built under commercial or contractual arrangements that differ from those used today. In such circumstances, it may be necessary to adjust the definition to ensure that the relevant infrastructure falls within the correct regulatory framework.
The power may also be needed to provide clarity and certainty when questions arise about the application of the definition in particular circumstances. Indeed, as I have explained in relation to Amendment 285, the Government brought forward an amendment earlier in the Bill’s passage to make sure that the definition does not capture infrastructure operated or maintained by GBR on behalf of a third party. That enables us to reassure stakeholders that their particular commercial arrangements would not be unintentionally affected by the Bill. The power could be used in a similar way.
I recognise that any change to the definition would of course be significant. That is precisely why the power is subject to the affirmative procedure. Any affected parties would also be appropriately consulted before any such changes were brought forward.
I hope that the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, is reassured by what I have said. Of course, as I have said before, we will be responding formally to the Delegated Powers Committee’s report before Report, where I will set this out in further detail.