Contribution
My Lords, I apologise to the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate. I forget that the microphones are on all the time and pick up even whispers. I admire all noble Lords who are fully engaged in the Bill; I am finding it extremely difficult to listen to every word. For example, I salute the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, who has been listening to every word and has barely looked at his phone more than a few times. A few words have percolated through. For example, the noble Lord, Lord Harper, mentioned green infrastructure—at ports, I think—without spitting, and I was delighted by that. Perhaps we could talk about it another time. To paraphrase his long explanation about Henry VIII and “Doctor Who”, I think he meant that we must get this right the first time, which is what the noble Lord, Lord Dixon of Jericho, also talked about. I heartily agree with that. I thank the Minister for sending me a letter on designation. It threw up a few more questions, which I should perhaps send to him in writing rather than putting it all in Hansard now.
On Amendment 330JE, as far as I am concerned the private leasing of our trains is one of the great scandals of rail privatisation. It should not have been done. One of the big questions for this Bill and all the Government’s rail policies so far is: why have they focused on the nationalisation of rail services only, not the trains themselves? I note what the noble Lord, Lord Young, mentioned just now. Let us put it in the Bill; let us get it right and make it completely clear.
The cost of leasing and maintaining these trains is about a third of the day-to-day running costs of the railway: over £4 billion in 2024. That does not sound like good business to me. The rate of profit extraction is notorious. The trade union ASLEF estimates that the private rolling stock companies have extracted £2.9 billion in profits and dividends over the last five years. A recent report from the Office of Rail and Road states that the roscos’ profit margins fluctuate between 5% and 31%. Perhaps we could all have that profit margin. This level of profit extraction is happening because we are locked into what is essentially a dysfunctional market in which there is no real choice and where interventions to fix the competitive market have repeatedly failed. This wasteful system now passes to GBR, unless something is done to stop it.
There is at least some good news. At Labour’s conference last month, the Transport Secretary announced that GBR would consider public ownership for all new rolling stock. This commitment was made in the Government’s new Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strategy, published on the same day. This was a welcome announcement, but it is not enough. Governments will come and go, whereas fixing this wasteful system will take decades. The commitment belongs in the Railways Bill, not merely a strategy document. It would be an unforgiveable missed opportunity to announce this new policy direction while passing up the chance to secure it in law.
This is the intention behind my amendment on the ownership and financing of new rolling stock. This amendment reflects exactly what the Labour Government have said in their new Rolling Stock and Infrastructure Strategy. It would require GBR to assess public ownership whenever it orders new trains, looking at cost and value over their whole life and across the railway. It does not dictate the outcome but would ensure that GBR asks this question and always chooses the best option for taxpayers. This is the absolute minimum that should be done, and a direct challenge to the Government—so will they put their money where their mouth is?
Moving on, Amendment 330JF goes further than the Government’s policy pledge. It would establish a clear goal: to “increase progressively the proportion” of publicly owned rolling stock, and it would require GBR to publish and implement a strategy to achieve that. The amendment then distinguishes between new and existing trains. New trains procured for GBR passenger services must be publicly owned. For existing trains, GBR must assess public ownership options
“before entering into, renewing or extending a lease”
or
“committing to its major refurbishment or life extension”.
That is a requirement to properly assess other options, not a requirement to buy the existing trains.
Major refurbishments and life extensions can involve substantial amounts of public money. Before committing that money, surely we should ask whether continuing to lease and refurbish these trains offers the best long-term value, or whether there is another approach that would make better use of taxpayers’ money. The point here is to establish a systemic approach to assessing “whole-life” and “whole-system” costs and value—to use the Government’s words in their recent strategy document—not simply asking what costs least today but asking what makes best use of taxpayers’ money over the decades ahead.
These assessments would not remain behind closed doors. GBR would have to publish them, explain the resulting decisions and recommendations, and report annually on progress. We need to move beyond one lease renewal at a time with no clear destination. This amendment would give us both a long-term plan and a transparent process for assessing the options. First and foremost, it would strengthen the quality and accountability of GBR’s decision-making, while bringing much-needed direction to this wasteful and discredited market.
To conclude on both amendments, it is truly a time of reckoning for the private leasing of rolling stock. There is one further issue which requires a detailed explanation from the Minister. This concerns the Office for National Statistics, which is preparing to review the status of rolling stock leases. This creates a real possibility that the assets and loan liabilities could be brought on to the public balance sheet. As I understand it, it would mean that the debt and liabilities will appear on the public ledger, reducing the Government’s capacity for borrowing even while the legal ownership and profits from rolling stock remain private. Will the Minister explain what that will mean for reported public debt and the Government’s fiscal rules? Has the Treasury assessed the implications, and will it publish that assessment? I see that the noble Lord, Lord Young, thinks he probably knows the answer to that. Perhaps not.
If private leasing no longer keeps those liabilities off the public balance sheet, what remains of that argument against public ownership? This appears potentially to be a serious issue, and I would appreciate a clear written response plus reassurance that these issues are being properly considered in time for making decisions on the Bill. I look forward to the Minister’s detailed response.
I move on to Clause 95 on the Luxembourg rail protocol, which I oppose in full. This clause would give powers to the Secretary of State to implement the 2007 Luxembourg protocol to the Cape Town convention. The stated intention of the protocol is to reduce private sector financing costs by strengthening roscos’ and lenders’ rights to cross-border enforcement. All this really seems to be is an expansion of private law jurisdiction and globalisation, entrenching the market power of roscos and the big banks behind them.
Did I hear some criticism in the audience here?