Contribution
My Lords, it is always interesting for me to follow the noble Lord, Lord Harper, partly because I disagree with so much of what he says but, further, because he manages to speak for five minutes—or more than five minutes—with no notes, which is very impressive. I welcome all the new noble Lords we have—even though one of them is trying to escape—and hope that they enjoy their days, weeks, years and decades here in our House.
Turning to the Budget, I do not doubt for a moment the Minister’s sincerity on this, and I am sure he has high hopes for the Government and this Budget. There were a couple of bright moments, such as tackling homelessness, which is something that I have always cared very much about; I hope that it can happen. I do not want to spend the whole of my allocated speaking time moaning about the climate crisis deficit and the Government’s lack of understanding about where we should be going in challenging our climate crisis, but, for a Green, this was a huge missed opportunity, and it is very difficult not to feel moments of despair. However, I will suggest solutions, and I hope that the Minister will include them in his reporting back.
Overall, it is a complete waste of time for the Prime Minister to be at COP today after presenting a Budget that drags his country backwards on climate change, even if he has appointed Dame Madeleine Alessandri as a special representative for climate security. I would be interested to know what powers she has, if any. As we all know, this is likely to be the warmest year ever, and climate change is accelerating. The UN is now saying that we could hit a disastrous 2 degrees of warming in the next 14 years. But instead of any hope that we can turn this around, we have victory after victory for the oil and gas lobby: the disastrous go-ahead for Jackdaw drilling in the North Sea and the go-ahead for airport expansion, with a laughable plan for sustainable aviation—aviation can never be sustainable.
These decisions are the result of fossil fuel money lobbying MPs and Ministers. Politicians and political parties should be banned from taking any money from the businesses that are wrecking the planet. Once again, we have the cancellation of the fuel duty increase, the cancellation of the EV target for 2030 and a go-slow on the warm home scheme. I do not see this Government cancelling the tax breaks for oil and gas companies operating in the North Sea. They cannot even commit to things such as electrification of the railways or switching households over to heat pumps. They say it is all too expensive, but these investments would cut bills in the future.
One quick win would be to switch funding away from the overpriced and redundant Sizewell C nuclear plant and unpopular carbon capture and storage schemes such as Peak Cluster, which is in an area extremely vulnerable to flooding where drilling of any kind, however far offshore—it is out at sea—could have awful consequences for residents. I have a question that I would like the Minister to answer, if not today then in writing, please. Did the Government do an independent value-for-money assessment before public funding was committed to the Peak Cluster scheme? It is a lot of money for an untested technology.
At the moment, taxpayers and consumers are made to spend billions of pounds in subsidies for nuclear power, while the Chancellor says there will be no money for renewables next year if they produce too much energy. I agree that it is ridiculous to have wind farms in Scotland and elsewhere being paid not to produce energy, but surely we could use that energy in some other way.
Where is the industrial strategy to create the battery storage revolution—or possibly the hydrogen storage revolution? We could do it. We have the skills, but we just do not have the willpower coming from government. We can save energy on the days when the sun shines and the wind blows and we can use it for later. We can pump water uphill and let it down to generate hydroelectricity. We can do all that; we have the skills.
A Green Prime Minister would stand up at COP and showcase a cost-effective energy economy run on renewables, combined with an energy storage revolution. Trump and his corporate friends in big oil would not like that very much—obviously, they might not be around for much longer—but it would guarantee lower bills, energy security and the planet’s future. This Government have got it wrong. I would so like them to pick up a few of the ideas in the Green Party’s manifesto. They are all costed, they are all sound, and they will all be accepted in 10 or 20 years, but that will be too late.