Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, and the committee. This is an excellent report. It is very irritating to me to have to follow the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Manchester because he has covered issues I wanted to cover. That is the problem with coming sixth in a debate in a room full of people who know and understand climate change.
The report has made one thing abundantly clear, which is that drought is no longer a rare or occasional problem. It is becoming a defining challenge for England’s environmental and economic future. This summer cost farmers an estimated £390 million with cereal harvests set to be the lowest ever recorded. It is clear that this crisis goes far beyond simple hosepipe bans to potentially developing into a severe risk to our food supply. What we grow has to change, and the Government have to help farmers to make that transition and do it quickly.
One of the most striking conclusions of the report is that we are not facing a simple shortage of rainfall. In fact, the UK receives more rain than it did several decades ago. The problem is that climate change is altering when and how that rain falls. We are seeing wetter winters, more intense downpours and hotter and drier summers. Too much water arrives when we do not need it and too little arrives when we do. Hotter temperatures mean greater evaporation, lower river levels and more pressure on agriculture, ecosystems and public water supplies. If we fail to address climate change, the challenge of drought will become increasingly severe. For Greens, this is a crucial point because nature is not simply something that is nice to have, to look at and to walk our dogs in. It is part of the solution that we need for this problem. We do not need wildlife and ecosystems damaged because we are failing to address the problem. Healthy wetlands, restored floodplains, thriving peatlands and better managed catchments to help retain water in the landscape are needed. They increase resilience during dry periods while reducing flood risks during wetter months. Clearly farm reservoirs have a role to play in that.
It is not enough to tell consumers, that is, households, that they have to cut their water consumption because clearly people do a lot. I already flush my loo with washing up water and things like that. What has made it really bad is the privatisation of the water industry. First, there was the failure to build any new reservoirs despite English water companies going £72 billion into debt. That money went to shareholders, not infrastructure. Secondly, there is the failure to fix broken pipes. The hose-pipe bans this summer saved a bit of water and ruined a lot of gardens, but leaks lost five times more water. Thirdly, there is the massive expansion of housing and consumption without regulations to limit water use and encourage reuse in new and old buildings.
Reservoirs are needed, but the public do not necessarily trust the water companies to build them. I have been involved with local councillors and campaigners in Havant because the new Havant Thicket reservoir is coming online. At the moment, it is a beautiful watery space, absolutely gorgeous, but South West Water is planning to put recycled effluent into it. That will be a problem. Local people are already asking whether they want to drink that water, whether it is going to be healthy and whether is it going to be okay. South West Water does not have a good reputation. It is dumping sewage and all sorts of chemicals into local rivers and on to the seashore. I have mentioned the Havant Thicket reservoir before; it is a problem. A water industry driven by profit and debt cannot adapt quickly enough to the new climate and new needs. Only public ownership can get us through the coming crisis.
The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Manchester also mentioned data centres. A detailed set of amendments has been drawn up by experts at Manchester University who were raising concerns about data centres. They wanted water reuse and some restrictions on where you put the data centres so it did not impact on areas already subject to drought conditions. They were sensible ideas but the Government ignored them.
We are on track to be living the hottest year on record, and the frightening thing is knowing that the new record could be broken next year or the year after. Climate scientists working via the UN have been making predictions for decades, and every single one of those predictions has underestimated how bad things are going to be and how fast things are going to change.
I have come to all the things that I have scribbled out because other people have said them, but I will try again. Water availability must become a far more important factor in planning decisions. It makes little sense to recognise the risk of future shortages while continuing to approve developments that place ever greater pressure on limited resources. On the Government’s insatiable obsession with data centre expansion, I point out that it will only place further demand in areas where demand is already rapidly increasing due to housing developments.
The solutions are available. We can reduce leakage and use water more efficiently. We can restore natural systems that help store and manage water. We can ensure that development takes place within environmental limits and, above all, we can recognise that tackling climate change is fundamental to securing our future water supplies and our future well-being as a human population.
The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, came up with all sorts of really good ideas. I did not make a note but I will check in Hansard—I am sure they are already Green Party policy. However, the biggest thing we can do to fight climate change, or to slow it down at least, is to stop using fossil fuels. I ask the Government, when they talk about growth, to please focus on climate-friendly growth. It is not enough and it is not good enough to talk about constantly expanding all sorts of development when we need to put the climate first. It is not just the climate; it is the future of us, our children and our grandchildren.