L

Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I was concluding the debate on the group beginning with my Amendment 305ZA, and I was complimenting the noble Baroness, Lady Leaman, on her supportive speech, which identified alternative uses of surplus assets. In that connection, Sustrans has done some heroic work in reusing a disused rail track. The noble Lord, Lord Hampton, who is not in his place, did not declare an interest, so we assume that Hampton Court was not at one point the ancestral home of the Hamptons. He raised a valuable point about making the maximum use of assets. I have two points in relation to the noble Baroness, Lady Jones. My noble friend Lord Harper explained the difficulties with the Government owning the roscos. To underline his point, I note that I was Secretary of State to begin with when British Rail was British Rail, and I was also Secretary of State when it was Railtrack. In both cases, I came along with a substantive business case for investment in rolling stock. When I went to the Star Chamber of fellow colleagues in the Government, I explained that there would be less cost for maintenance, better passenger safety and less use of fuel. They would say, “This is a fantastic story but, sadly, we have a limit on government expenditure, and we have just heard that the Home Secretary wants more policemen, the Health Secretary wants more nurses and the Education Secretary wants more teachers”. So I was told, “I’m sorry, George; you can’t have your new train set for Christmas”. However, afterwards, the business case spoke for itself. It got the investment without any Treasury veto. The scenario that the noble Baroness, Lady Jones, was urging us to accept would mean that the Secretary of State would be in exactly the same position as I was in 1995. The other point that the noble Baroness raised was about the implications of the roscos being scored as public expenditure; she said it would be a very serious issue. Indeed, it was, and we had an earlier debate in that regard. The Government’s position is that we should await the conclusions of the ONS. However, the more that the Minister developed his case that there would be a proactive pipeline strategy, the more I thought he was digging a hole for himself, in that that is more likely to lead the ONS to take the view that this is a government-controlled body, with the Government calling the shots. The Minister might like to reflect on his ambitions for the rolling stock strategy, with the ONS hanging on his every word. On a final point, I am most grateful to the Minister for basically agreeing with Amendment 305ZA. What he did not say was why he could not accept the amendment itself, as it would actually deliver government policy. Yes, he has the powers under Clause 88 to do it, but this would oblige him to do it, removing any doubt at all. Although I will withdraw the amendment, the Minister did not explain why it was not acceptable. No drafting defect was identified, which is the normal alibi that a Secretary of State or a Minister adopts if he cannot accept an amendment. But because it was a helpful reply, I do not want to be curmudgeonly, and so I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

More from Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.