L

Lord Grayling (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I rise to speak in support of Amendment 275, in my name. My noble friend Lord Harper has articulated the concerns that many of us have about this specific part of the Bill very well, so I will not repeat all his points. I have highlighted the issue of specific facilities, and I declare my interests as set out in the register. I might work for Hutchison Ports Europe but this issue is broader than that: it is not just about ports, it is about private sector facilities in freight in ports and airports. The key point here—I say this in the full knowledge that the Minister is smart enough to realise the implications of the decisions he is making—is that the Minister will not always be the Minister, and this is a Government who have taken decisions that are sometimes ideological, and sometimes ideological in a way that takes things into reverse rather than going forward. They know what some of those decisions are. I do not have confidence in a Labour Government not to make decisions for ideological reasons, and I do not have confidence that we will always have a Minister who does not make decisions for ideological reasons. The decisions taken for ideological reasons can sometimes completely undermine the commercial viability of a new investment or an existing investment or business. We are talking about facilities that may be extremely important to the United Kingdom, where the public sector can sometimes encourage the private sector to open up to doing positive things, but if it gets them wrong, the consequences may be serious. The obvious example that comes to my mind is the opening of the line to Okehampton. The Minister was involved in that when he was at Network Rail, as I was when I was Secretary of State. To my mind, it was a great success, but the Minister also knows that part of that route was a freight line controlled by a local quarry business. If the Government were to decide to pass regulations to bring more services to Okehampton or to extend the line beyond Okehampton, what would happen to that quarry business or the facilities it accesses? As the Minister knows, when the Government proceed with their support for the expansion of Heathrow Airport—as I hope they will—there will be no scenario in which the taxpayer can afford to pay for western and southern rail access. That will have to be privately funded. What will prevent a future Minister making a decision about access to the network and the line into and around Heathrow Airport that materially impacts on the business case for private sector investment in those two essential rail routes? As my noble friend Lord Harper rightly said, we are looking for the Minister to provide some comfort on Report—to indicate that there will be constraints on how the powers in this clause can be used, particularly to prevent decisions that will materially undermine investments made by the private sector, which the Minister rightly wants to see. There is another point in this clause on which I have not tabled a specific amendment, but where I thought I could issue a friendly challenge to the Minister, who has been extremely accommodating on this subject in other areas. There is a reference in this clause to criminal prosecutions. If those prosecutions are to be focused purely on safety, it would be absolutely right and proper for an operator of a section of private infrastructure that has broken safety rules in a criminal way to face sanction. I accept that. However, I should like to see some constraint on how this power can be used. As the Minister and I have discussed, on the civil aviation Bill and earlier on this Bill, it is very easy to stick a reference to criminality into a piece of legislation without any clear idea of what it is for. May I therefore ask the Minister to go away and review that clause, to see whether it would be sensible to make some clarification before Report? Neither he nor I want open-ended legislation that would allow a future Minister to make pretty much anything in this area a criminal act. I hope he is willing to do that and come back to us with some thoughts on Report.

More from Lord Grayling (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.