Contribution
Before I start talking about my amendments, I will comment on the previous group. The Minister said that Clause 71(2)(d) covers the payment of compensation, but the subsection says that the regulations “may” provide for the payment of compensation, which means that, if the regulations do not provide for that—it does not say that they have to—there would not be a mechanism to pay the compensation. We had a conversation at an earlier stage about whether the regulations “must” provide for that, but they only “may”. I think that is the gap that my noble friend Lord Moylan referred to.
I have Amendments 272, 273, 274, 276 and 279 in this group. I will run through all of them briefly. The Minister, helpfully, wrote to me this morning. The private office sprayed out some letters this morning—I had seven. I have not had a chance to look at all of them, but I have looked at the one relevant to this clause. It deals well with a concern that I did not have, about whether this clause could be used, effectively, to nationalise non-GBR infrastructure. I think, from the conversation we had and certainly from what I will set out now, that the concern is a bit more nuanced than that but none the less important. I will set that out in due course.
Part of the reason for this concern is that the Prime Minister keeps saying that he is very much in favour of public control of various businesses, without necessarily going through all the palaver of nationalising them and paying people lots of compensation. He does not really spell out what he means by public control. Therefore, he cannot be enormously surprised that, when businesses hear the leader of the Government say that he is quite keen on taking public control of things, they naturally think he is quite keen on taking control of their things without paying proper compensation, which he would have to do if he nationalised them. That is the context in which businesses are, perfectly legitimately, concerned.
The concern about Clause 72, which refers to non-GBR infrastructure, facilities and services, is about the risk of open-ended interventions taking place after companies have taken investment decisions. If you do not address that it will change the climate in which companies make investment decisions. On earlier clauses, we talked about what I think is a shared concern on all sides of the Committee: we want to see private sector investment in rail infrastructure—I see the Minister nodding. The danger is that the clause, as drafted, will put that at risk. That is certainly the understanding that a number of private businesses have. I will set out what those concerns are and then run through the amendments. I will then move the lead amendment, Amendment 272.
For many of the investments that people carry out, such as rail freight terminals, a model is set up under which rail freight companies pay per train, and the charges are set to recover the capital over a period and cover the ongoing maintenance and life cycle risks. Clause 72, as drafted, creates a risk that the Secretary of State could intervene in that pricing or access policy after the decision has been taken. For example, the clause talks about the “terms, conditions and charges” that people may make
“for the use of non-GBR infrastructure and for the provision and supply of facilities”.
If people think it is possible for the Secretary of State to make those changes retrospectively then it undermines the business case for making the investment in the first place by putting uncertainty over that revenue stream.
Open-ended powers also reduce certainty and increase the risk of different interpretations of the legislation, which again makes long-term infrastructure harder to justify, particularly in business areas where the margins are relatively low and you have to recover the cost over a considerable period of time. That will reduce the investment into rail terminals, the expansion of ports and so forth.
The other risk is that the Government could set terminal charges or access terms when long-term logistics contracts rely on agreed access fees. A number of businesses are concerned that Clause 72 could require fee reductions and broader access for competitors, affecting profitability, contract compliance and the competitiveness of the port against other hubs.
There is also a concern, if Clause 72 is applied unevenly, that some businesses could face stricter requirements than others, which is clearly an issue. If you weaken the ability of the Office of Rail and Road to act as the independent regulator and appeals body—we had a lengthy debate in earlier groups, which I do not propose to revisit, about the basis on which you can refer things to the ORR and that being on a judicial review model rather than on a substantive debate about the detail—that then reduces people’s confidence in the system.
The final issue, if you have that regulatory uncertainty, is that you risk reducing investment into moving freight from road on to rail, and the investment required in green infrastructure in our ports to ensure that that transport is low carbon. Both those things are to do with the Government’s own policy areas.
The amendments would do a number of things. Amendment 272, which is the lead amendment—I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Moylan for having signed it—would limit the regulation-making power in Clause 72 specifically to
“the amendment, revocation, restatement or replacement of provisions”
in the existing Railways (Access, Management and Licensing of Railway Undertakings) Regulations. These regulations were set up in response to European Union directives that applied to us because we were members of the European Union at the time. They provide an appropriate basis that people are comfortable with. The amendment would limit the extent to which changes can be made.
Amendment 273 would limit the use of that power in Clause 72 to a single exercise in relation to each of the relevant provisions, and would require the power to be used only to facilitate the transition to a replacement regulatory framework. In other words, you cannot use it to keep changing things, but you can use it for the intended purpose, which is to make sure that the existing rules work under the new model. Under my amendment, you would not be able to keep changing the rules and, effectively, shifting the goalposts for private sector businesses.
Amendment 274 would require the regulations to
“apply consistently and without discrimination”
to persons, service facilities and locations in “materially comparable circumstances”. It would allow Ministers to have “objectively justified” and “proportionate” differences in treatment, but they would have to be clearly justified. That, again, is to deal with whether these are applied fairly.
Amendment 276 slightly repeats the debate we have had on previous occasions. It would mean that there would be a right of appeal to the ORR for people affected by the use of decisions under Clause 72. It would not just be on a judicial review basis; it would mean you could bring an appeal on the grounds that the decision was
“inconsistent with a statutory duty … based on an error of fact or law … discriminatory, or … disproportionate”.
It would be a much more comprehensive appeal mechanism and provide investors and businesses with confidence that the power was not going to be misused.