L

Lord Grayling (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 21 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, Amendment 267 in this group is in my name. There is a really important principle here. The Minister has quite a lot of reassurance to give on this particular part of the legislation because, at face value, it allows the Secretary of State to issue regulations that rewrite the existing access arrangements. We know that both the Treasury and, I have to say, this Secretary of State are not wildly keen on the existing open access contracts. The Secretary of State recently wrote a letter to the ORR that basically said, “No more open access. We can’t cope with it and we don’t want it”; I am paraphrasing, but the Minister knows full well that that was the broad gist of what she wrote. The Treasury certainly does not like open access, for the reasons we heard from various noble Lords in our earlier debates. Ultimately, Treasury officials see this as a loss of revenue and, as a result, a theoretical increase in the subsidy that they have to provide for the railways. I do not doubt that the Treasury would like to see open access disappear altogether and, having taken the decision to have a unified Great British Railways, would like to have that as the only organisation operating passenger services on the network. Yet there has been a significant expansion of open access in recent years. Right now, we see the launch of a Lumo service from London to Stirling using the west coast main line, rather than the east coast main line, which is one of the busiest railways in the country. The ORR has identified potential train paths that are available to do that, but I do not doubt that the Treasury’s view will be, “Oh no, not another open access operator. We don’t want that”. I also do not doubt that, in the Department for Transport and under the leadership of the Secretary of State, there will be a degree of reluctance given the letter that was written to the ORR saying, “The Government do not want to see more open access on the rail network”. This particular clause appears to allow the Secretary of State to use congested infrastructure, constraints in the infrastructure or similar to say, “We are going to rewrite some of our existing open access operators’ contracts”. The Minister is shaking his head slightly, but that is what it says: it clearly allows the existing access arrangements to be overwritten for infrastructure reasons. The only logical infrastructure reasons there could be for taking those contracts away would be if the Government said, “Actually, there’s not enough space. There are too many constraints. There are blockages and things we don’t want to do in terms of infrastructure management. We want to run fewer trains”. So I want to hear a clear explanation of the purpose of this from the Minister. My amendment is basically designed to set some clear limits on how it can be used. I very much want to hear the Government justify this clause and explain why what I am proposing is not necessary and should be rejected. Although we will not divide on this tonight, I hope that, at the very least, the Minister will go away and come back with a more reasonable clause that properly protects the interests of the existing open access operators—unless there are absolutely exceptional circumstances, in which case proper compensation would need to be paid. It is very much over to the Minister to justify something that seems entirely unjustifiable.

More from Lord Grayling (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.