L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

He has noted it; that will count against her at some point. On keeping an open mind, I completely agree with her. The problem with the amendment as drafted is that saying full electrification of the network is not keeping an open mind. At least, it is arguably tying the Minister’s hands about how you deliver electrification. But the thrust of it is absolutely fine. I have a bit more of an issue with Amendments 330JE and 330JF, which are what I might call her anti-rolling stock amendments, because that it what they seem to be. They are a bit contradictory. Amendment 330JE is attempting to pretend to be neutral by saying that Ministers have to consider the whole life and whole system costs and manage all that. They basically have to choose direct public ownership where that assessment says that it is better. However, Amendment 330JF basically says that the Secretary of State and GBR have to use their functions to progressively increase the proportion of the railway rolling stock that is publicly owned. It does not have anything in it about whether that is actually good value or not. That does not seem to make any sense to me. It basically says they just have to have it all owned by the public, even if it is a terrible deal, and that makes no sense. I suspect that the noble Baroness reached that slightly contradictory conclusion because it sounded from her analysis that she used as her single source of truth the well-known reasonably neutral arbiters of these things, the ASLEF rail union. In my experience, it is not awfully neutral about anything, and I would not necessarily take it as the only source of whether you should or should not have private capital involved in the rail industry. Its view is that it wants everything nationalised. I am afraid that is because that is the model in which they it has the most power to jack up wages at the expense of the passenger and exact that power over Ministers. I do not think that is a very good idea for passengers. I would not use ASLEF as the best sort of source of information about financing railway assets.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.