B

Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

I got on with him; that is not the same thing. Looking at the impact assessment of the Railways Bill, it seems the Government are uncertain there will be any benefits from this implementation. In fact, Eversholt, one of the three big private roscos in the UK, objects to the protocol, saying in 2024 that it did not believe it “would attract additional private sector investment or reduce financing costs” and that it was “concerned that ratification … would lead to increased costs and add an unnecessary layer of administration”. Even if there were savings for roscos, what reassurance would there be that they would pass these on to the public sector? Absolutely none. In fact, this is the last thing they are likely to do in such a concentrated market which, as we already know, means unrestrained profit extraction. Next, the protocol’s international reputation is frankly embarrassing. Despite being open for signature for 20 years, it has gained just seven parties, taking a shocking 17 years to come into force due to the lack of international interest. By contrast, its sister agreement, the Cape Town aircraft protocol, gained 87 parties in this time. Furthermore, the UK’s signature dates back to 2016, before the Brexit referendum. Would we make the same decision now, given the vastly different circumstances, and without the involvement of the EU? Finally, to address the issue of public ownership, why would the Government sign up to an instrument that entrenches the logic of private financing globalisation just at the time they have said they want to move towards privately owned rolling stock? Although the protocol would not directly prevent public ownership, it could raise the cost, litigation risk and practical barriers and increase the roscos’ market power. I realise I have gone over time, but I have been answering a few interventions. It could also worsen the chilling effect where public authorities know that policy changes and market interventions in rolling stock could trigger stronger legal claims. Why has the Luxembourg rail protocol been included in this Bill? What is the rational argument for it? It is hard to find anyone endorsing it except private law firms and a Switzerland-based lobbying group representing the main private law institution behind the protocol. Please, just take it out. It is utterly illogical. I still have another page but never mind. I will just say that all my amendments are worth passing.

More from Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb (GP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.