L

Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

The answer is that I will not guarantee to do such a thing but I will reflect, between now and Report, on all the discussions that we are having on these amendments. As I said, Network Rail is consulting with existing contract holders to establish precisely what amendments may be required across the several hundred existing contracts that will need to be updated to operate under the new framework. It would therefore be undesirable to constrain the power in a way that could prevent necessary changes from being made. Inoperable contracts do not benefit anyone. My noble friend Lord Berkeley also seeks to limit this power though Amendments 268A, 268 and 269. However, a restriction based on broad and undefined concepts such as the “nature of the bargain” risks creating uncertainty and disputes about whether necessary amendments fall within the scope of the power. We should not allow restrictive drafting to undermine changes agreed to by all the parties. Clearly, that could risk frustrating the very transition that the power at Clause 71 is intended to facilitate. Likewise, imposing an unduly strict test of necessity, as under Amendment 268, would hamper the purpose of the clause, which is to ensure a smooth transition to the new access regime. A test of necessity would also risk creating legal dispute and uncertainty as to whether a particular change is strictly necessary or merely desirable. On Amendment 269, a number of existing access contracts extend into the mid and late 2030s, far beyond the start of the next funding period in 2029, as proposed in this amendment. It is therefore important that sufficient time is available to ensure that contracts can continue to function effectively throughout their lifetimes. A shorter sunset period could result in the power expiring before issues affecting longer contracts have been fully resolved. On Amendment 271, the Government strongly support engagement with industry, and, as I have mentioned, extensive consultation is already taking place. Network Rail is currently consulting on draft model access contracts and the future industry codes. Given that that extensive programme of engagement and consultation is currently live and in the public domain, we do not consider it necessary to impose retrospectively a separate statutory consultation requirement in Clause 71 itself, because it is already happening. The final amendment that looks to restrict this power is Amendment 270, from the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. I am pleased to reassure her that the effect she seeks is already achieved by the Bill as drafted. Clause 71 applies only to access agreements and access rights “so far as the agreements or rights have effect in relation to GBR infrastructure”. The scope of the power is therefore already limited to those agreements and rights affected by the transition to the new GBR access and charging framework. As a result, the power cannot be used to amend access agreements that relate to non-GBR infrastructure. Those agreements will therefore continue to operate unamended under the existing framework. I hope that the noble Baroness is reassured by this. Turning to Amendment 340, from the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, the Government consider the negative procedure to be most appropriate in this case, because any future use of the power would be to make necessary technical changes to ensure that existing contracts remain operable under the new access framework established by the Bill. I reiterate that the power will not be used to alter the substantive access rights that operators currently hold. It is included purely to give effect to the discussions that are already ongoing between Network Rail and operators regarding the necessary amendments of contracts to ensure that they remain operable in the new framework brought forward by the Bill. The Government therefore consider that the negative procedure provides the appropriate degree of parliamentary oversight for regulations where the purpose is to operationally implement this transition. Finally, I turn to Amendment 266, from the noble Lord, Lord Lansley. He is right that the Bill revokes Regulation 5(8) of the access and management regulations, which places a duty on infrastructure managers to ensure that a train operator’s right to access their network is honoured. Although GBR will not be an infrastructure manager for the purposes of these regulations, the regulations will continue to apply to non-GBR infrastructure managers. I agree with the noble Lord that retaining this duty for non-GBR infrastructure is important and that its effect should be retained in those regulations. The Bill already achieves the noble Lord’s objective, because Clause 70 amends Regulation 5(1) to make it clear that it is the infrastructure manager who is required to grant access rights. As a result, Regulation 5(8) is no longer needed, because its effect will instead be achieved in the amended Regulation 5(1). For completeness, I emphasise that the existing right of appeal to the Office of Rail and Road in Regulation 5(9) also remains unaffected by the Bill, providing a clear right of recourse for operators if an infrastructure manager who is not GBR sought to deny access to any operator in contravention of Regulation 5. I thank noble Lords for their discussion on this topic. I believe that aspirations are aligned here, as nobody wants inoperable contracts or to remove the rights that operators have been legitimately granted to run trains on the network. The power is essential to make the railway work in the future and that is why I am defending it. It will not be misused. The Government have put that on record in a number of ways, including in this speech today. I hope that this will allow noble Lords not to press their amendments.

More from Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.