Contribution
Whether 15 or 30 years away, however, we are making progress, and that joke does not really apply anymore. We are trying to do something really extraordinary: to build a star here on earth, to heat hydrogen to around 10 times the temperature of the core of the sun, and to hold plasma in a chamber with magnets cooled to near absolute zero.
Britain is not sitting on the sidelines on this but is actually leading the world. The Joint European Torus at Culham has set records for fusion energy output. The MAST upgrade is the world’s largest operational spherical tokamak. Public and private investors, from the UK Atomic Energy Authority to Tokamak Energy, are pushing ahead and pushing each other forward. We have rightly earned our place at the heart of this.
The prize, as others have said, is incredibly large. The International Atomic Energy Agency counts fusion among the most environmentally friendly sources of energy: no carbon dioxide; no harmful atmospheric emissions; and it produces fuel from hydrogen and lithium, which are both widely available. We know that electricity demand here is expected to double, or more than double, by 2050, as we seek to electrify our heating, transport and industry. The UK Atomic Energy Authority believes that fusion could provide steady baseload power that would complement our renewables. If it works at scale, we could move from an energy politics of scarcity and competition towards abundance, and the global market has been estimated to be worth £12 trillion.
But we need to be honest about the climate argument, which is a point that the Commons Energy Security and Net Zero Committee also made. The earliest we will see this energy in production and viable is the 2040s, so we need to continue on our renewables journey and we need to cut our emissions. This energy will come late in the day in terms of meeting our climate targets.
That being said, we on these Benches back fusion. We support it, and we support the £2.5 billion invested so far and the £1.3 billion to be put into STEP. The Government are backing a winner, and I believe that it is justified, but the risk is also large, and the horizon is long. Ministers and the Government have a duty to be open about the costs and processes involved and to make sure that we are getting value for public money.
That brings me to EN-8. As the Minister said—I did not know this until she said so—it is the world’s first policy for energy fusion. Obviously, planning policy is our primary consideration here today. There is a lot here that we welcome and support, and my sense is that that is also the case for others around the Room today. We welcome the designation of low-carbon fusion energy as a critical national priority; the priority for brownfield and former energy sites; and the recognition that fusion’s low radiological risk means no population density limits. We also welcome the encouragement of collocation with energy-intensive users, such as data centres, and the 19 fusion-specific considerations on top of EN-1.
We also welcome the broadening of what can count as a nationally significant project. The Government are bringing in fusion infrastructure with thermal, or combined thermal and electricity, capacity over 50 megawatts, which recognises that fusion plants may supply heat as well as power. We also welcome the application of good design principles, which are key, and how the new plants will meet the very important climate-resilient targets—as we know, our climate is changing in the future.
As the Minister said, industry has broadly welcomed the draft. I thank the Minister for noting that the Government will look at the responses and points that have been made on that draft.
I have a few areas that I would like to explore while I have the chance to do so. In 2022, the Government decided that fusion would continue to be principally regulated by the Health and Safety Executive and the relevant environmental agency. As the noble Lord, Lord Khan, has already mentioned, of course we recognise that fusion is not fission, but the Commons Energy Security and Net Zero Committee was entirely unconvinced that removing the Office for Nuclear Regulation would reduce bureaucracy and warned that “the relative inexperience”—or, really, the complete inexperience—
“of the Environment Agency may lead to the excessive caution”
in this field. My question for the Minister, therefore, is: how will regulators be adequately resourced? What specialised staff are the Government seeking to recruit and what are the timeframes for ensuring that all this is done in good time?
I understand that fusion sits outside the nuclear siting and licensing regime of 1965; that makes sense, but questions remain about how third-party liability, insurance and—as has already been mentioned—long-term waste costs can be handled. As the industry seeks to invest, it will need further clarity on these points.
Can the Minister also say a little more on where we are at with the STEP programme? I understand that the aim is to submit a development consent application in 2029 and to start building in 2030. Even conventional schemes can take well over a year, so are we still on track for this timetable? It feels like quite a tight timetable for a one-of-a-kind plant.
Fusion plants will be strategic national assets and the supply chains behind them will depend on global supply chains. What considerations have the Government given to securing those supply chains, particularly when we will face a world of competition, particularly with the USA and China, which are particularly investing in this technology? What are we doing to make sure that those supply chains work?
The Energy Security and Net Zero Committee also called for non-proliferation guidance to be issued now, not at the five-year review. Will the Government accept that recommendation?
For me, another important point is that these are really big infrastructure projects and we want to support community benefits. What more are the Government doing to make sure that local economies, the wider economy and the people who live next to these big industrial sites will benefit from them? Is it still expected that STEP will support around 10,000 jobs? What work is being done to support the skills and apprenticeships that will go with that?
Issues have also been raised around how we talk to local communities about these projects. Obviously, this is a new, evolving and unknown technology, so there is a real need for the Government to put effort and consideration into how they communicate these projects to make sure that the public are reassured of their inherent safety.
Cooling water is an issue. Tomorrow, we will debate the Environment and Climate Change Committee’s report on drought. Obviously, we know that this is subject to forward plans, but it looks like we could be short by 5 billion litres of water per year by 2030. These plants have big cooling needs, and they may be collocated with data centres and other high intensity water and energy requirements. Given that collocation is mentioned in this document, will the Government give more consideration to desalinisation or other methods so that we can look at water usage? Water usage is quite a critical element of these projects.
There is still some debate about the relationship between EN-1 and EN-8; I understand what the Minister says, and that EN-1 is the overarching document. I welcome the fact we have developed a separate policy with EN-8, but there are some issues about the relationship between those two documents, which could do with further clarification.
I also want to ask about the energy spatial plan, which the Government are in the process of developing and should be published later this year. But this plan needs to work with the energy spatial plan. These plants, particularly at start-up, will require to draw huge amounts of energy from the grid—although, when they are up and running, they will supply energy back to it—so grid planning and siting are key issues.
I like the fact that we are at the forefront of this technology, but the technology is evolving and changing, and other countries are investing heavily in it. Just yesterday I was reading about the helicon current drive at the DIII-D national energy facility, which is a new development of an old technology that hopes to maintain a steady state for longer so that we can get closer to getting long-term energy out of these plants. That highlights that the technology is moving really quickly, so I guess there is a question about how EN-8 will develop with new technologies.
In the European Union, policy on fusion energy is still country based, and we are ahead of the EU now. But these are big, large-scale projects, and as part of our reset with Europe we should be looking for greater co-operation with our European partners. I think we are actually ahead of the game here, and on this document we could be leaning into Europe to develop better policies based on this. I would encourage the UK Government to include fusion as a key element of our European reset.
We are supportive of this national policy statement. We think this is a real opportunity for the UK to press home its technological advantages in this area. The development of and investment in this technology is really important towards providing our future long-term energy security and helping deal with the problems of energy use and climate change.