L

Lord Lansley (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

UK-EU Agreement on Competition Laws

Contribution

Oh, the noble Lord is ahead of me. That is a very good basis on which we can bring these issues back. Frankly, the European Union is in balk. The Commission has withdrawn its proposals, and the European Parliament is challenging that in the European court, so the EU cannot make progress. We should think that it is incumbent on us to try to lead the way. I hope that we will be able to have a constructive debate—if necessary, outside the formal processes of Parliament—on how we can take SEPs forward. I say to the noble Lord, Lord Bruce, that I think there is an interesting example. The Safran/Collins one I referred to is an interesting example of co-operation. I hope we can see different jurisdictions doing things in their own terms differently, but with the same objective and, as it happens, the same remedy. That is a very good example of the way in which I hope this kind of co-operation will proceed in the months and years ahead. The noble Baroness was very positive about the possibility of taking forward co-operation by phases. Of course, from the European Union’s point of view, the legislative base for this agreement does not extend into the Digital Markets Act, so we may need to think about something new under the trade and co-operation agreement rather than simply an extension of this agreement. But I hope that we will put that into the mix for 20 November—the many things that I hope will form part of a “positive reset”. My noble friend Lord Hunt talked about investment and innovation and the balance. The competition reform Bill, when it comes, presumably will be directed very much to the balance between promoting investment and growth and ensuring that we maintain effective competition. I said in my opening remarks that monopolists have always been able to demonstrate short-term benefits to consumers; the problem is that they kill long-term investment and innovation because they kill market entry on the part of others, and market entry is absolutely critical in this. The Furman review was very clear that there had been very many acquisitions of start-up and innovative companies in the digital space by the leading market players. We have not had an SMS designation here long enough to be able to see how far this new regime, through the notification procedures under the DMCC, will enable intervention to ensure that market entrants are able to succeed in digital markets. It is fundamentally an interface between the digital competition regime and the conventional competition regime because notification under the DMCC leads directly into merger reference under the Enterprise Act, on which Standing Committee I was honoured to serve back in 2002 as well. Digital competition and conventional competition cannot be disentangled; they are part of the same thing, and it will be important to see the co-operation under this agreement, working, I hope, to help to support the scrutiny of merger references in the digital world. The noble Lord, Lord Bruce, talked about the power and wealth of the tech magnates. They are, as it were, the railway barons of the modern age. I think we should hope that there is a bit of Andrew Carnegie about this. Although you might argue about his desire to maximise profit and the way he went about it, his purpose was to maximise profit so he could deploy that money for the public interest, not least in Dunfermline, if I recall correctly. There is a bit of the Carnegie philosophy about some tech leaders—not all. They are not railway barons or creating Standard Oil or US Steel but they are creating the companies dominating our industry today and, if this is a new golden age, I hope we find some of that. However, let us remember that the golden age led to the anti-trust legislation in America in the early part of the 20th century. Here in the 21st century, we have to make sure that our anti-trust and pro-competition regime is equally as effective in preventing the abuse of dominance—

More from Lord Lansley (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.