Contribution
My Lords, on the first day of Committee we discussed amendments to ensure that records, physical and digital, are explicitly added to the application of the duty of candour, because we know there have been a number of egregious cases where information was hidden. For example, I spoke of the nuclear veterans’ medical records that had been hidden in a Ministry of Defence storage centre—hidden because nobody knew they were there, and they were not on any index. One of the reasons the Bill is necessary is that there are too many cases of public officials, regardless of department or organisation, trying to hide or even destroy key information that would demonstrate clear intention to mislead.
In July 2025, Andy Burnham, at that point still Mayor of Manchester and a passionate supporter of justice for the Hillsborough law, said that parts of Whitehall were
“fighting hard to preserve the status quo”.
Even then, he felt that Ministers and civil servants were misleading the public with “false” and “unfounded” claims about the then proposed legislation that has now changed positively into this Bill. It is now much clearer and stronger. The former Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, and our new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, agreed that introducing criminal sanctions for dishonesty was key to making this Bill work.
However, I agree with our new PM that there is still an issue with the culture of the status quo. For decades, at its worst, including in recent years, this has included some public officials—those who would be accountable under the terms of this Bill—who have destroyed information that would have been important evidence for inquiries, inquests and investigations, especially police investigations.
My Amendment 31, signed by my noble friend Lady Hamwee, creates the offence of destruction of information or records that are relevant to an inquiry, investigation or inquest. It is a stand-alone clause that says that a public authority or public official commits the offence not just if they deliberately destroy information or records that would be relevant, but if
“they know that, or are reckless as to whether, the information is relevant to or required by an inquiry, investigation, or inquest”.
Subsection (2) of the proposed new clause then sets out that the offence under this clause is, upon conviction, liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding the general limit in a magistrates’ court in England and Wales—not exceeding 12 months in Scotland or six months in Northern Ireland—and, on conviction and indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years. Each of these sub-categories is liable to a fine, or imprisonment and a fine.
It is vital to specify the details of this crime—including “recklessness”, a phrase used earlier in the Bill—because of the history of behaviour of certain public officials who have destroyed information. That has not only re-victimised the victims because the evidence could not be produced at inquiries or investigations, but it has too frequently meant a delay to justice. This delay has cost the victims and the nation through scandal after scandal and successive inquiries on the same issue. It has also cost the state considerably more in the costs of inquiries and appropriate compensation to the victims, which was delayed.
Volume 7 of Sir Brian Langstaff’s infected blood inquiry report has an entire chapter on the disappearance and/or destruction of documents over the many decades. There is a box on page 2 summarising how documents were destroyed over the years and then denied. In 1988, Lord Owen’s files record that the destruction of his paper by the Department of Health was:
“Normal procedure after 10 years”.
We will return to that in a minute. The report continues. From 1990-91,
“relevant documents are identified as missing during the HIV litigation. February-March 1993: registered GEB/1 files relating to ACVSB sent to the DRO. September 1994: registered file GEB/1 volume 4 is destroyed in advance of its review date. June 1995: Dr Rejman notifies Solicitor’s Division that one of the ACVSB files ‘has apparently been destroyed’. May 1996: documents relating to the settled HIV litigation are identified as missing. October 1997-November 1998: remaining GEB/1 volumes are destroyed. April 2000: the report of the internal audit of missing ACVSB documents. March 2004: Department of Health informs Lord Owen that its review into self-sufficiency ‘does not address why papers from your Private Office at the time may have been destroyed’. April 2005: meeting between Nigel Crisp and Lord Jenkin to discuss missing papers”.
I have quoted those headings at length to demonstrate that this is not just a one-off error of destroying papers too early—this is a culture of destroying important information. This list does not even cover many of the doctors’ own files and patient files that were quietly destroyed as it became clear at the turn of the 1980s that illegal blood products research had been carried out on children without either their or their parents’ consent. The first infections happened in the 1970s. The known destruction of documents started in 1988. That destruction of papers has cost Governments in this decade billions of pounds.
Then there is Hillsborough. The Lord Justice Taylor report was about the arrangements on the day of Hillsborough and did not focus on the behaviour of the police, although he did have some concerns about that. However, the report of the Hillsborough Independent Panel, published a quarter of a century later, was able to remedy this, and Chapter 11 starts at paragraph 2.11.1, saying that
“statements made by South Yorkshire Police (SYP) officers in the form of handwritten recollections of their experiences on the day of the disaster underwent an unprecedented process of review and alteration before their submission to the official inquiry”—
namely, Lord Taylor and his inquiry. At paragraph 2.11.6 it says:
“In contrast to their professional training, officers were instructed not to record their experiences in pocket books and ‘anyone who was involved yesterday take time to sit down and make some notes’. The briefing officer asked if officers had ‘made a pocket book brief’. None had. The briefing officer continued: ‘Do not start making pocket book entries. Yesterday was the most traumatic experience of my life and large chunks of it I cannot remember. I am sure it must be the same for many of you’”.
Both of these two egregious examples demonstrate actions by individual public officials as well as their corporate organisational behaviour.
Last year, Inquest’s report on the Hillsborough law family listening day, known as All or Nothing, powerfully set out how key the destruction of evidence was for the victims and their families. One Hillsborough family member said their loved one
“was not afforded the truth he should have been. It was traumatic. It [the inquest] should have been the end”.
It was not.
As well as in the Hillsborough tragedy, the destruction, hiding or changing of evidence is key to the Post Office Horizon scandal, the Covid inquiry, the nuclear test veterans, the infected blood scandal and many more. This is not a one-off; this is cultural. We cannot have the further destruction or hiding of evidence. That is why this amendment would make it clear to public officials, public organisations and, above all, the public that this must change. I beg to move.