B

Baroness Brinton (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, my Amendment 53F seeks to re-establish “His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Criminal Court Administration as an independent statutory body to inspect and report on the administration of the criminal courts, with particular regard to the experience of victims and witnesses and the delivery of their entitlements under the Victims’ Code”. An independent courts inspectorate would provide robust oversight of Crown Court and magistrates’ court performance, helping to identify systemic inefficiencies, improve transparency and accountability, and support efforts to reduce delays. It would also assess how effectively courts deliver for victims and witnesses, ensuring that victims’ experiences are also recognised as a core measure of performance. It would have the powers to make recommendations requiring a formal government response. This means that the inspectorate would provide an early warning mechanism to identify emerging problems. Accountability, transparency and consistency would ensure that court reform delivers meaningful improvements for victims and the wider justice system. The mechanism would deal with a considerable number of concerns raised earlier in discussions on the Bill, including court backlog reduction, treatment of victims in the criminal justice system—especially victims of rape and serious sexual offences who need more protection than other victims and witnesses—and the wider effectiveness of court facilities. Reform will succeed only if its implementation is subject to effective and consistent scrutiny and accountability. The CPS, police, prisons and probation are all independently inspected. However, there remains no body responsible for assessing court performance. Indeed, the noble and learned Lord, Lord Leveson, supported the re-establishment of a courts inspectorate, saying that the arguments for its closure have not stood the test of time. Our late, much-missed Baroness Newlove, in her 2025 Victims’ Commissioner report, Justice Delayed, also called for the reinstatement of the court inspectorate. Her report found that many of the issues identified by the former court inspectorate in its 2007-08 joint review of victims and witnesses’ experiences remained evident in 2024, demonstrating the persistence of long-standing shortcomings within the court system. It concluded that a reinstated inspectorate could play a vital role in identifying inefficiencies, driving improvements in court performance and monitoring victims’ experiences to ensure compliance with the victims’ code. Along with my honourable friend Jess Brown-Fuller MP, I am proud to support the Victims’ Commissioner with this proposal, which will ensure improved scrutiny of the courts and the courts estate, and identify and correct where systems fail. Victims are clear too. I had the privilege of meeting Lee and hearing about his experience. Lee first reported allegations of abuse in September 2021. Following a lengthy investigation, charges were brought against his perpetrator in March 2024. A trial listed for March 2026 was vacated shortly before it was due to begin and relisted for May 2028 due to court capacity issues. In July 2026, Lee gave evidence through Section 28 special measures, recorded for use at trial. I am sorry to say that the prolonged delays have had a significant impact on Lee’s well-being, working life and ability to plan for the future. He said: “I have a few things I would like from this Bill. I’d like to see a credible plan to reduce waiting, and I would ask Peers to demand clear milestones, sufficient resources and public reporting. I would ask how Ministers will demonstrate that the reforms actually reduce prolonged waits, and for accountability for avoidable adjournments. Reasons should be recorded, recurring failures identified and responsibility assigned for fixing them. Victims should receive prompt explanations and there should be consistent communication and support. Victims need a clear point of contact, realistic updates and support through repeated delays. Use victims’ experiences as a measure of performance. I would suggest you test every proposed reform against a straightforward question: will this reduce the time victims spend waiting, improve how they’re treated and make someone accountable when the system fails them?” A reinstated courts inspectorate would help to deliver the accountability that Lee is calling for. Is the Minister prepared to reconsider the previous decision, over a decade ago, and reinstate the courts inspectorate? I agree with Amendments 54 to 57 from the noble and learned Lord, Lord Bellamy, which ask for clarity on scope and a review of the arrangements of the court system. I also support my noble friend Lady Hamwee’s Amendments 59, 60 and 67B on the appointment and scope of court reviews, and Amendment 62 from the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, asking for a statement in relation to delays on the transportation of persons in custody to court. I beg to move Amendment 53F.

More from Baroness Brinton (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.