Contribution
My Lords, it is an honour to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt. I am sorry that I was too late to sign her amendment, but she knows she has from these Benches our full support.
I read in Hansard her Private Notice Question to the Minister a week ago today regarding mandatory jury directions on harmful myths and stereotypes in trials for rape and serious sexual offences—RASSO. In that same Question, the noble and learned Lord, Lord Burnett of Maldon, was helpful in referring your Lordships’ House to read the Crown Court Compendium on sexual offences and jury directions. I am convinced that the vast majority of lawyers in this House are already very familiar with it, but it was an interesting read over the weekend. As a non-lawyer, I read the chapter on sexual offences and I found it extremely helpful. However, it does not resolve one of the issues that we have covered both in this Bill and in previous Bills, and that is when a small number of judges do not follow this excellent compendium and do not give directions or advice to the jury.
In her contribution, the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, raised one of the myths about doubting rape victims if they did not report the rape immediately. It is commonplace for victims to block out what has happened while they are trying to come to terms with the thing, and that can be for quite a long time. As a parallel, I remember that the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse found that most of the serious historical cases of child sex abuse were not reported for years; sometimes, as with Nicky Campbell, decades can pass before victims can bring themselves to speak of it. These myths must not be permitted to happen during cases.
Research shows that myths around the victim in RASSOs are still believed unless they are challenged, and the noble Baroness, Lady Levitt, outlined some of them. These include that few people can accurately identify that most rapists know their victim; fewer people—a quarter—knew that victims will not always be distressed when talking about what happened to them; and only a third of respondents to the survey knew that women rarely make up allegations of rape.
Then there is the behaviour of defence barristers. One rape survivor, Morwenna Loughman, said:
“Defence barristers rely on these myths … I lived that reality throughout my trial … we shouldn’t have to, but I expected the lazy dissembling of ‘you were drunk, what were you wearing, you invited him back, you asked for it, you’re easy’”.
One victim reported that a defence barrister at a sentencing argued that, as the victim has been asleep or unconscious, it meant that she had not been deeply affected by what the defendant did to her. Victim Support’s Suffering for Justice report found that three-quarters of survivors of sexual violence are subject to rape myths during cross-examination. The Victims’ Commissioner and other victim support organisations say that victims tell them that their credibility was assessed against these stereotypical expectations of how a victim should behave.
The Law Commission found that the discretionary approach to giving directions was inconsistently applied, specifically in which directions are given, the content and the timing in the proceedings. It relies on individual judges identifying myths, deciding whether to intervene and then crafting the directions, and that creates inconsistency. Some studies have found that judges rarely countered rape myths because they were not obliged to.
Amendment 50 would ensure that concerns are addressed about the consistency of tailoring directions, as judges would still retain discretion where directions are unnecessary in the specific circumstances of that case. However, it would ensure that relevant directions are necessary. That is why, from these Benches, we support Amendment 50.
I have laid Amendment 53E, to deal with the other key element to breaking the problems of rape myths, as well as the facts of domestic abuse and other RASSOs. Amendment 53E would strengthen judicial training and guidance. This has not been my first amendment on judicial training and guidance, and I think there are more to come shortly. The Law Commission has recommended that the Judicial College should develop guidance to support judges when lines of questioning are used that rely on rape myths and misconceptions, or to respond appropriately when these generalisations are used in advocates’ speeches. However, it needs to be more than guidance.
This is a complex area, and Amendment 53E sets out the arrangements for the resources and reporting mechanisms for judicial training. The amendment proposes that the Lord Chancellor should make available the resources for training, with a list of the areas to be covered, and the confirmation that, where there is a new appointee of a recorder, deputy district judge in the magistrates’ court, or a justice of the peace, they have completed the training. It then goes on to say that the Lord Chancellor should report to Parliament once a year on how many people have concluded the training and any other relevant data. Finally, it says that the Lord Chief Justice—not the Lord Chancellor—is the person who defines what needs to be in the training, as well as the delivery of it, keeping the policy and practice separate.
I have also signed Amendments 53G and 53H, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Neate. Amendment 53G brings us back to the theme of training, this time training on domestic abuse for judges in criminal cases and certain child welfare cases. Amendment 53H makes the case for a duty for the Government to ensure that there is high-quality, evidence-based mandatory training on domestic abuse for criminal court professionals and those involved in certain children’s law cases. We absolutely support both of these amendments from these Benches.