L

Lord Beamish (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I welcome the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Carter, on a very important issue: what happens to the outcomes of very lengthy and expensive inquiries? The noble Lord raised what has been spent on public inquiries since 1990 and I suspect that will grow even further. The problem we have got into—as a parliamentarian I am possibly as guilty of this as anyone else—is that, as soon as something goes wrong, we call for a public inquiry as though somehow it will get to the truth and change things. I have spent a long time with the victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal. What do people want? They want two things. First, they want the facts out there and, in some cases, they quite rightly want compensation. But, more than anything, most of them say “We don’t want this to happen again”. It is about changing things in the future. Let us deal with compensation. The Public Accounts Committee report a couple of weeks ago was very good. It said we need to set up a permanent body to deal with compensation. I should have declared an interest: I sit on the Post Office Horizon advisory board. We have five different schemes just on that one scandal. We are inventing these things every single time. It leads to a waste of effort and delays in getting victims compensation. The call for a permanent government body to deal with compensation is important. I have sympathies with this amendment, because it comes to something that I and Professor Chris Hodges, who chairs the advisory board for Horizon compensation, have been doing some work on: how do you ensure that public inquiries’ recommendations are implemented and accepted by government? I welcome the debate. It is good that we are having it. The problem is how it is framed: Governments could hide behind this very easily by saying, “Well, we note the report; things are going to be looked at possibly in the future”—or, if there is a change of Government, it just gets lost. My personal preference is: yes, we need timely reports of inquiries, but we also need actions on behalf of the departments to implement the recommendations. This is where it falls down. I remember, for example, Sir John Saunders’s inquiry into the Manchester Arena bombing, which made some very good recommendations. One of his concerns was how they would be followed through afterwards. He wrote to the ISC asking whether we could monitor: well, we did not have the capacity and nor were we set up to do that. That showed me that there was a gap there. I think the only way to do this is by doing two things. First, we need to reform inquiries; we need a permanent new body, perhaps a super-ombudsman-type organisation, which sits permanently to look at these scandals and make timely recommendations. Secondly, we need parliamentary oversight alongside that. You could perhaps have a Joint Select Committee of the two Houses or whatever, which would not only be able to look at the work of the inquiry organisation that I am envisaging but also, more importantly, look at the implementation of the recommendations of inquiries. Without some type of parliamentary oversight and pressure on the Executive, there will always be a default position where, once something is out of the headlines, as the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, has just said, it is a matter of, “Do we really need to worry about this?”. That is the problem. Public inquiries get a lot of heat and light when the recommendations come out. But what is the follow through? Some will take a long time and a lot of detailed work to implement—as well as cost. That needs to be monitored and should be a role for Parliament. Otherwise, we will have a lot of publicity when we get the recommendations of inquiries, then a lot of disappointed people afterwards, because they do not get the understanding that things will change in the future, which I believe is more important than anything for them. You talk to a lot of the victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal and what do they want? What you hear more than anything else is, “We don’t want this to happen again to anybody in the future”. That is a common tenet among a lot of the victims of a lot of these scandals. They want meaningful change and for their suffering to have some effect in terms of changing things for the future.

More from Lord Beamish (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.