L

Lord Anderson of Ipswich (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have a few remarks on Amendment 32, which my noble friend Lord Carter has so ably introduced. I have conducted some independent inquiries of a sort that would fall within this clause, though none of them cost millions or hundreds of millions. In some cases, my noble friend was legal adviser to those who commissioned them, whether in the Home Office or in No. 10, so it is refreshing to see him, having been on the other side of the fence, championing the undoubted public interest in the recommendations of such inquiries receiving a prompt response. His solution is an attractive one but, as I have discussed with him, there are a couple of reasons why it would not always be feasible, at least in its current form. First, a fixed requirement to respond and lay those responses before Parliament within 56 calendar days could not easily be met if, for example, a report was submitted shortly before the calling of a general election and the arrival of a new Government. Perhaps that difficulty could be accommodated by the substitution of “parliamentary sitting days” for “days” in the amendment. In other cases, though, what used to be called pre-election purdah may have an impact on the timing of any response, making a 56-day limit too rigid in an unpredictable range of cases. Secondly, there are times when more than one report is commissioned on the same issue. A recent example is my report on the failure of the Government’s Prevent programme to divert the Southport attacker from the path that led him to murder three young girls in the most appalling circumstances. I sent my report to the Secretary of State last July. An informal reaction was given, and work began immediately on some of my recommendations. But the Home Secretary chose to delay her formal response until she had the report of phase one of Sir Adrian Fulford’s Southport inquiry, which was published in April this year. Our two reports made some overlapping recommendations, with implications across central and local government. A consolidated response was a rational solution in the circumstances, even though I had to wait almost a year for it. My final point relates to the importance of the timely publication of independent reports. It is publication that enables Select Committees, parliamentarians, media and NGOs to bring the findings of an inquiry to the attention of the public and to put pressure on Governments to implement them. As an independent reviewer, I was always more concerned by delays in publication than by delays in the Government’s response. It must be demoralising to submit a report to a Secretary of State which simply disappears, only to be published so long after the event that its impact is diminished. Unless the matter is a high-profile one, there can be no guarantee that parliamentary committees or the media will be much exercised by the delay or interested in it. If the Government’s reaction to recommendations has to be published within 56 days of receipt, as this amendment would provide, that must imply that the report itself has been published within 56 days. A Secretary of State could hardly lay before Parliament a response to recommendations of which Parliament and the public were ignorant. So, while the amendment does not on its face require timely publication of reports, it would appear to have that benign—I would say—side-effect. Perhaps the noble Lord could comment, when he closes this debate, on whether this is a feature of his amendment rather than a bug—I rather hope that it is. I look forward to hearing what the Minister has to say about the importance of timely publication as well as timely response.

More from Lord Anderson of Ipswich (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.