B

Baroness Brinton (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have signed Amendment 32 from the noble Lord, Lord Carter, which he set out clearly. We have had a fascinating debate, as with the previous group, on what is probably a Goldilocks issue—there are some things we clearly need to do, but others are problematic and we do not want to do them. Have we found the sweet spot? I apologise for mixing my metaphors. Throughout the progress of the Bill, we have had a great deal of debate on how we tackle the culture of public organisations that the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, just mentioned, in order to prevent future scandals. We have already heard about Hillsborough, infected blood, Post Office Horizon and Windrush; I do not think anyone has mentioned Grenfell yet today, so I will. The amendment is one of the tools in the box to show that both the structures and the culture must change. Whether it is 56 days or longer—the noble Lord, Lord Carter, will respond on this point—we are trying to find a mechanism to prevent the current practice, which we should not refer to as a culture, of the Government usually taking a year to respond to an inquiry or other major report, deciding that they need to consult on various parts of it, and then coming back with their recommendations. Often, it is two years or more before practical changes are discussed. It is clear from all the problematic disasters we have been discussing throughout the Bill’s passage that things have got stuck in a rut, leading to the public sector mindset of deflecting and not doing anything, because there have been no targets for the Government to respond to. That is why I like this amendment. It may need changing slightly, but the most important element is that the Government would have to give an initial response. If other reports are coming as well, that might alter the situation, but the whole point of the Bill is transparency and accountability, which means that if things have to change, the Government should not be afraid to say so. It has not been government culture to say, “Oops, we got this wrong”, or “Things have changed; we need to change this”; but if we are going to get these complex, difficult issues right, we must learn to take that approach. I was interested in what the noble Lord, Lord Beamish, said about one compensation body: my Amendment 115 will be discussed on the next day in Committee, and I am passionate about having one compensation body. Part of the problems is that we move civil servants who have been responsible for the problem into the compensation body because they are the only other people who know about it. We have to move away from that. We really need to focus our thoughts on the immediate response to make sure that things are not lost. We keep going on about cultural change, but part of the cultural change inside our public official organisations and with our public officials is feeling that you do not have the time to ignore something because it might go away if nobody does anything at all.

More from Baroness Brinton (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.