L

Lord Lemos (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for their contributions to the debate. I note, with some humility, the enormous experience that has been demonstrated in the debate from noble Lords who have chaired inquiries. I will come to those in a minute. I will first deal with the government amendments. These are technical amendments to make sure that statutory and non-statutory inquiries established by Welsh Ministers are subject to the provisions in the Bill regarding the conduct and reporting of conduct of public authorities at inquiries and the engagement and conduct of legal representatives. This will allow Welsh Ministers to set out an overriding objective regarding participation and maintain the inquisitorial nature of proceedings in relation to statutory inquiries. We are also making an amendment to the Government of Wales Act 2006 to ensure that should the Senedd subsequently legislate to remove the relevant concurrent functions, it would be able to do so without requiring the consent of a Minister of the Crown. I commend these amendments to the Committee. I turn to Amendment 32, from the noble Lord, Lord, Carter. The Government entirely agree that there should be a clear and consistent expectation on public authorities to respond to inquiry reports and their recommendations. The question from the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, goes to the point about timely publication; long delays, at any stage of the process, are a significant problem. I note the comments from the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, about the risk of inquiries overlapping with each other, and the many inquiries about children—including her own distinguished inquiry. She referred to the last time she heard someone in your Lordships’ House say, “We do not listen to children”. I think that might have been me, so I plead guilty as charged. The only thing I would say in my own defence is that we still do not listen to children. I think everybody would agree that it is vital that public authorities have enough time to fully consider an inquiry’s recommendations and support Ministers to make informed decisions about how to respond. Once inquiry recommendations are accepted, they become government policy that must be delivered—that is a really important point. I note the comments from the noble Lord, Lord Bichard, about the delivery of the agreement to the recommendations, not just the agreement to the recommendations. I am very familiar with his work on the Soham inquiry and the importance of the changes that were made. I entirely share the sentiments of my noble friend Lord Beamish. Having talked to the victims of many kinds of disasters over the years, I know that the pressing feeling of the survivors, victims, bereaved families and so on is that they do not want this to happen again, and the way to make sure it does not happen again is to deal with it promptly. We slightly go round in circles on that point, but it is obviously right. As the noble Lord, Lord Carter, may be aware, we are taking steps to improve the Government’s delivery of accepted inquiry recommendations, including through the inquiry recommendation dashboards. However, the Government agree that the noble Lord is right to raise this issue, and we note that there has been some discussion in the other place. I will take away his proposal to consider it. I note the comments and questions that have been raised by other noble Lords about the deadline and so on. We will take away the noble Lord’s proposal to consider how we can establish a clearer and more consistent expectation on public authorities to respond to inquiry recommendations. In my response, I think I dealt with the three questions asked by the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, but I am very happy to do so explicitly. The Government should respond and give their reasons, and they should do so in a timely fashion. As I say, we will take this away. I think the feeling of the Committee is that there is a bit more work to do to get this right. In the meantime, I ask the noble Lord, Lord Carter, to withdraw his amendment.

More from Lord Lemos (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.