L

Lord Lemos (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this has been an extremely important, powerful and timely debate, with strong views expressed in different directions. I thank my noble friend Lady Levitt, both for her amendment and for giving the Committee the opportunity to have this rich and important debate. It is clear from this debate that there is much on which we all agree. First, we all agree that rape myths have absolutely no place in our courts or, indeed, in wider society. The noble Lord, Lord Marks, referenced my response to the Private Notice Question. I think that the media—online and traditional—as well as employers and civil society all have important roles to play in challenging rape myths. The law also has a significant part to play. Victims should never feel like they are the ones on trial, and we are already taking steps to change the culture in our courts. On the point from the noble Lord, Lord Russell, I pay tribute to the victims in the Brand case and in so many others for showing the courage to ensure that justice is done. In this Bill, we are changing the law to stop irrelevant evidence that relies on rape myths being weaponised against victims. The Lord Chancellor is standing up a rape justice taskforce to tackle not only inefficiency in rape cases but this precise challenge. The independence of the judiciary, as well as judicial discretion, are both cornerstones of the rule of law and of ensuring a fair trial. It is also right that steps are taken to ensure that directions are given consistently. My noble friend Lady Levitt placed some emphasis on that, which is one of the points of issue on this amendment; the noble Lord, Lord Russell, also mentioned it. So the Government agree that it is right that steps are taken to ensure that directions are given consistently and in line with the agreed standards set by the judiciary. In response specifically to the questions asked and the very powerful case made by my noble friend Lady Levitt, I will say today that the Judicial College has committed to updating the Crown Court Compendium to state that directions should be given in all sexual offence trials—this goes straight to my noble friend’s point—at the outset of the trial and when summing up, subject to judicial discretion. This new requirement would set a clear expectation. In the light of that, the college also intends to update sexual offences training for judges. The noble Lord, Lord Russell, raised the question of training for barristers. The job of regulating, setting standards for and training barristers is a matter for the Bar Standards Board, and it is for it to take this forward. It is already developing specialist standards for barristers acting in rape and serious sexual offences cases. As has been reported, the Lord Chancellor wrote to the Bar Standards Board this weekend to ask for a meeting to discuss progress on its planned standards. He made it clear that harmful rape myths should not be perpetuated. I am confident that the measures I have set out will ensure that directions are given consistently, as my noble friend Lady Levitt challenged us on. However, I understand that we have heard concerns expressed by my noble friend and others from all sides of the argument, and Minister Sackman and I are happy to meet with her and other such interested Peers, ahead of Report, to discuss the concerns that underlie this amendment and the measures that I have set out. We are happy to consider anything more that the Government can do, within the well-established parameters of judicial independence and discretion. I hope I have reassured my noble friend Lady Levitt and, on that basis, shall invite her to withdraw her amendment in a moment. I turn to Amendments 53E and 53G from the noble Baronesses, Lady Brinton and Lady Neate. These amendments are very similar in their intent. Amendment 53E seeks to place a duty on the Lord Chancellor to ensure sufficient resourcing for judicial training on areas related to vulnerable witnesses, domestic abuse, sexual violence and trauma. Amendment 53G focuses specifically on the funding for this judicial training and the duty on the Lord Chancellor concerned with child arrangement proceedings. The Government recognise the importance of specialist training being delivered to our judiciary, and the Lord Chancellor already has a statutory duty to ensure appropriate resourcing of the courts, which includes judicial training. Statutory responsibility for judicial training is rightly held by the Lady Chief Justice. A comprehensive programme of induction and continuation training is in place, which is designed to embed the necessary experiences and skills to deal with these cases. The Judicial College keeps judges up to date with a wide range of resources, as I just set out in relation to rape and serious sexual offences. The Crown Court judicial induction has a dedicated session on vulnerability, which sets out automatic eligibility for complainants in cases in these areas, including special measures. Domestic abuse training is not a stand-alone course or single intervention, and is instead embedded throughout the training programme, focusing on domestic abuse dynamics, coercion and the impact on children. The Judicial College draws on experienced practitioners and external experts, including survivors of domestic abuse and psychologists. In May, the college published a summary of judicial education in domestic abuse, and the college keeps judges up to date with a wide range of resources. The Government are therefore content that there is sufficient provision for this training provided by the Judicial College. Finally, on Amendment 53H, also tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Neate, I agree that it is essential that domestic abuse training is provided to all court staff. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness that HMCTS court staff must complete domestic abuse awareness training within three months of joining HMCTS. Existing staff are expected to complete the training every two years. In addition to the domestic abuse awareness training, in August, we introduced trauma-informed training for court staff. This aims to help staff to better understand how traumatic experiences, particularly domestic and sexual abuse, can affect the way that people communicate, behave and engage in court and throughout court processes. It has been developed to support the Government’s commitment to improve how courts support victims and witnesses. To preserve judicial independence, as I have said, statutory responsibility for the training of the judiciary rests with the Lady Chief Justice and is fulfilled by the Judicial College. With these reassurances, I hope my noble friend Lady Levitt will withdraw her amendment.

More from Lord Lemos (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.